View Single Post
  #26   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 03-04-2008, 00:32
Lavapicker's Avatar
Lavapicker Lavapicker is offline
Registered User
FRC #1056 (Hot Rocks)
Team Role: Mentor
 
Join Date: Jul 2004
Rookie Year: 2003
Location: Hilo, HI
Posts: 101
Lavapicker is just really niceLavapicker is just really niceLavapicker is just really niceLavapicker is just really nice
Re: GP? I think not.

Wow, you took some hits on your comments on this one! Its a shame it had to be anonymous. I'm all with you on it however! For some teams this has become a glorified pinewood derby where the adults build the robot and the kids drive. We all see it so get your heads out of the sand everyone! What to do about it? There is no formula of what percentage has to be built by students and I don't think you could enforce one anyway. You just have to be satisfied that students on those teams are not going to get the same experience as yours. I can tesitfy that coming from a team with one single mentor for four years, a fantastic one by the way, and with a budget where some teams spend more on one wheel than we spend on the entire robot you can still build a robot that can do very well. If its about the students then the game is just a game and the process of learning that takes place is more important in the long run anyway. Yes, you will have losing years when kids rotate through and you have to start all over but who is the real loser? I'd say the students who are adult driven teams.
__________________
2003 - Pacific Northwest Regional-Seattle :Quarterfinalist
2004 - Pacific Northwest Regional -Oregon
2007 - Silicon Valley Regional
2007 - Atlanta:Galileo Field (5-2)
2008 - SVR finalist*, Engineering Inspiration Award
2008 - Hawaii semi-finalist, Team Spirit Award
2008 - Atlanta:Archimedes (3-3-1)
2010 - Hawaii regional quarterfinalist
2011 - Hawaii regional finalist, Engineering Inspiration, Innovation in control
2011- St. Louis Galileo Field (7-3) 14th seed, quarterfinalist

2012 - Hawaii Regional Semi-finalist, creativity, industrial design awards