Quote:
Originally Posted by Cory
You're forgetting one small detail. FIRST has never said that teams should be run as a high school team.
In fact, they celebrate teams that are run as a business through the Entrepreneurship award. They celebrate engineers through the Engineering Inspiration award, and they celebrate mentors and engineers through the Woodie Flowers Award.
To me it is insulting to hear someone say so convincingly and so self righteously that the way other teams (my own included) are doing things is wrong, against the principles of FIRST, hurting the kids, and just plain unfair.
When FIRST becomes about being a high school science fair, maybe you'll be right. But the reason FIRST is great is because of the way it is. If you didn't have all these amazing engineers that FIRST students (heck, and mentors) look up to like Andy Baker, Paul Copioli, Raul Olivera, Dave Lavery, Al Skiekerkiewicz, Ken Patton, Dan Green, and countless others, where would this program be?
Some could contend having an all student team is just as "wrong" as having a mentor dominated team, but who cares?
The real point here is you have a team. Everything else is gravy. Whatever you choose to do with it from that point on is awesome, as long as the kids are getting inspired; and there's no way you can tell me the kids on the powerhouse teams who everyone thinks are engineer built (and often are surprisingly different than they may appear from the outside looking in after you get to know them) aren't being inspired.
How is that not a good thing?
|
While I agree with most of your points, I think you do need to consider what a "superpower" team looks like from the outside looking in.
Essentially, all teams start the season with the same basic resources - a kit of parts, a game description, and six weeks.
Now imagine you're a kid on a small team with a limited budget and mentor resources. You work for 8 hours after school each day, plus weekends, and finally show up at competition with something made of your own blood, sweat, and tears. It probably is a little homemade looking, maybe it works okay most of the time, but it is your own small victory after six weeks of hell.
Then you look in the pit next to you and see a robot that looks like it was ordered out of a catalog.
As an adult, how would that make you feel? I sure would be jealous!
Now, as a high school aged-student, how would that make you feel? Are you telling me that a 16-18 year old has the emotional maturity to not feel bad - even a little - about his own showing when kids the same age are sitting next to a future FIRST championship winner?
Life isn't fair, and FIRST isn't either. That's a hard lesson for a kid to learn.