Quote:
Originally Posted by UndergroundVoid
But does that really give a reason to tear an idea apart even if it were to be used for a competition purpose or personal project.
|
Tear apart? No. However, Adam is right; put a thread in Technical Discussion without some frame of reference to the contrary, and people will default to thinking about FRC applications.
Of the teams I've worked with, only one has ever attempted treads; that would be 1293 in 2007, the first season I was not active with them. Their
entry that year, Atlas, had some limitations. Their approach was solid, with the exception of their gearbox mount; the BaneBots gearboxes they used were mounted in the front of the robot using an open-front frame for their grabber. This left their setup particularly exposed to hits, and left them scrambling to move in their last match where they partnered with us. Some might argue it to be
too solid; each of their drivetrain pods weighed over ten pounds. (That thread actually has a lot of tread lessons learned; I'll see if I can get a member of the team to offer any further insights here.)
You may also want to read Chris Hibner's
paper on drivetrains. Much of it carries over from wheels to treads.
For the side talk about the appropriateness of treads, I say this: I care about whether your robot can successfully execute a strategy that complements our own. Wheels, treads, kiwi, swerve, it doesn't matter; all that matters is that I can rely upon you to execute.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by UndergroundVoid
But isn't it unfair for a person to ask a question and get answers that you didn't ask for. i expected help would bring the essence of the word to my questions and not some little post going off on how treads are bad, wheels are good. If i ask what color the sky was and they said 4 or something i would be irritated like i am now.
|
If you ask me a question about how to step on a car's gas pedal, I would feel obligated to make sure you were aware of how to step on the brake as well. The ability to relay both sides of an issue is important in any regard.