Quote:
Originally Posted by Andrew Schreiber
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Catapult
Nope, its a catapult but at the same time it is a trebuchet as well. Think quadrilateral -> square. Catapult is the generic term.
I would argue it is a trebuchet because it is essentially using the tubing to act as a weight.
|
OK if we go with the Webster definition of catapult
"an ancient military device for hurling missiles", then yes all trebuchets are catapults (but obviously not all catapults are trebuchets). That would then mean that all missile throwers are catapults, including ballistae, onangers, mangonels, and even more modern weapons like howitzers, cannons, rifles, pistols, magnetic rail guns, FA/18 jet fighter...... All of these devices hurl missiiles. (though not all could be classified as ancient).
But if we look at Webster's definition of Trebuchet
"a medieval military engine for hurling heavy missiles (as rocks)" there is little difference. It would appear as though the two devices are the same. I attribute this discrepancy to laziness on the part of Webster. I still think a catapult refers to the traditional definition of on arm with a basket on the end that rotates about a pivot until it hits a stop, thereby propelling a projectile forward.
But I have been told to sit down and shut up before, I expect I will be again.
