|
Re: Car Nack Predicts 2010-1
Say whatever you want, but Car Nack has the track record that makes you stand up an take notice.
Having said that, you will not be surprised to discover that I am sure Car Nack's predictions have merit.
Please note that having 2 robots suspended and one robot elevated does not provide +8 points as many have argued!!!
To my way of thinking it provides a mere +2 -- the two robots that go from 2pt elevated to 3 point suspended.
This is a lot of pain for not a lot of benefit. If these +2 points were free or nearly free (in terms of time and risk), that would be one thing but they aren't.
It is quite hard to imagine a situation where 3 robots could configure themselves into an 8 point configuration as quickly and reliably as they could configure themselves in 6 point configuration. Every time I come up with a solution that WOULD provide this advantage, the solution I come up with requires so many resources from the various robots that if they put those same resources into building a robot that does other tasks better, they'd be ahead of the game (by a lot).
Callin' 'em as I sees 'em.
Joe J.
__________________
Joseph M. Johnson, Ph.D., P.E.
Mentor
Team #88, TJ2
|