Can you show us one of these head-scratch-prompting errors? Someone here might understand it better than you do right now.
What do you expect the User 1 and Status lights to be doing? What are they doing instead?
You say the power jumper is in the right spot, but is that spot itself in the right spot?
Is the jumper on an Analog Breakout board atop the AI module in slot 1, and does it have 12V power connected - in the correct polarity -- to it? Is its green power light lit?