Go to Post Engineering is so much easier when you give all the components personalities. Then you just watch the drama unfold and try to fix it. - EricVanWyk [more]
Home
Go Back   Chief Delphi > FIRST > Rumor Mill
CD-Media   CD-Spy  
portal register members calendar search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read FAQ rules

 
Closed Thread
Thread Tools Rate Thread Display Modes
  #16   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 14-11-2001, 00:28
Unsung FIRST Hero
Jason Morrella Jason Morrella is offline
Robotics Education and Competition
AKA: J-Mo
no team (RECF)
 
Join Date: Jun 2001
Rookie Year: 1998
Location: San Jose, CA
Posts: 154
Jason Morrella has a reputation beyond reputeJason Morrella has a reputation beyond reputeJason Morrella has a reputation beyond reputeJason Morrella has a reputation beyond reputeJason Morrella has a reputation beyond reputeJason Morrella has a reputation beyond reputeJason Morrella has a reputation beyond reputeJason Morrella has a reputation beyond reputeJason Morrella has a reputation beyond reputeJason Morrella has a reputation beyond reputeJason Morrella has a reputation beyond repute
Hey Joe, a couple replies to your reply - hope all is well by the way :)

Does anyone think that a good compromise would be that robots were direct shipped from regional to regional - but all teams going to Orlando would have 3 days to work on the robot after their last regonal. This way every team at every event would have had basically the exact same amount of robot construction time as all the other teams at the event???

First, I should clarify that I TOTALLY agree with and understand the arguements in favor of getting to keep the robot for 3 days to work on it. Extra driver practice IS a great thing to get more of, getting to work on the robot and make repairs after an event IS a great thing, and so on - all is true. In a few years, when there are local regionals for almost all teams, then it would be fair. But with some 200-300 teams NOT having a local regional (or having their local regionals on consecutive weeks - 4 days between them), this rule just increases the advantage of being able to go to multiple regionals and having more regionals in your area.

This really isn't a big deal - ideally I agree that the rule should let teams work on the robot after a regional - it just doesn't seem equitable based on geography and some regionals being 4 days apart while others aren't. When in doubt on a rule, I just normally seem to agree with whatever is 100% consistent to all teams - not favors some over others. Doesn't mean it's right, just how I normally feel.

I admire Bill Gold from 258 for stating that they would just rather not have the advantage out of respect for the teams who can't work on their robots - he would rather compete with them with the same amount of time to build & drive the robot. Teams going to multiple regionals already get extra practice & robot build time just by being there for 3 days - I just don't feel they need more if other teams can't get more.

I don't think anyone is wrong on this issue - just seems there are different perspectives.

Quote:
As to teams west of the Mississippi being at a disadvantage, I am not sure what you are saying. Is your point that every geographic region should be equally disadvantaged? Should FIRST limit the density of machine shops to the level available in Hawaii or Alaska?
Nope, not my point at all - I hope it didn't come across that way. Just a Tomato/TomAto thing. For the most part, I see any rule which is consistant across the board and effects all teams the same as fair. As the rule was last year, I see all the teams NOT being able to take the robot home for 3 days as "disadvantaged". If all teams shipped directly, I would not see anyone as disadvantaged, because it would be equal for all. One important point - direct shipping in NO WAY "equally disadvantages" any team. It doesn't impact the 6 week design & build process at all. All teams would still have the same amount of days to work on the robot at home, in their work place.

I don't really care about the advantage/disadvantage of extra resources or funding. In fact, I look at the teams with more funding or resources than most teams as a good example, or goal, for newer teams to look up to and strive to achieve. These are things teams can work towards year round to try to improve their program. My point was that when it is a rule, dictated by FIRST, TOTALLY out of the hands of teams, which gives an advantage to some teams over others and ADDS work days with the robot to some teams but not others, than I disagree with it. This rule is not a resource or funding issue - it is a geography and time issue .

Quote:
As to direct ship causing no significant problems, that is just not the case. Yes, teams worked around it, but for the most part it was a hassle.
I guess it's just a different experience for different teams. The teams at the West Coast Team Forum overwhelmingly support the direct ship rule - at least between regionals - as they have NO WAY to work on it for 3 days after an event, especially since all three west coast regionals were placed on consecutive weekends.


Quote:
Finally, at least one robot I am aware of broke in the elimination rounds for the simple lack of being able to run it in a quiet room where the stress on the machine would have certainly been heard. I am not asking for sympathy, I am just saying that to so easily dismiss the problems teams had does not match my memory of the events.
You are right that the part which broke "may" have been caught beforehand, but very well may not have - especially since it didn't break until the 3rd day in Florida after practice and qualifying rounds. It could have been that the part simply broke due to the fatigue and stress of all the matches it participated in during 4 events. (if CD had only entered 3 events in 2000 - I think they would have been National Champs, but needed just a few more matches before the fatigue caught up with that crucial part) I have said this before and will say it again, in my eyes the CD robot from 2000 was the top robot in the country. Much like the TechnoKats in 98 and Beatty in 2001, it is incredible when one robot stands out above all the rest - but CD did in 2000. I normally expect a number of teams to distinguish themselves as being equal "top tier" teams - as I felt happened in 99 - but I was so impressed in 98, 2000 (same could be said about 25 - that arm was AMAZING, and still causes nightmares to us & the GilaMonsters I am sure), and 2001 that those 3 or 4 teams managed to build robots which (again, in my eyes) were head and shoulders above the rest.

About the direct ship or 3 day extension rule, valid points on both sides I think. Glad to have the discussion though - what you (Joe), Mike, Mike, and the rest of the CD team do on an annual basis is remarkable. I (as many do) look forward to seeing what you come up with this year!

Jason
  #17   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 14-11-2001, 07:54
Tom Fairchild's Avatar
Tom Fairchild Tom Fairchild is offline
Nice Guy
no team
 
Join Date: Jul 2001
Location: Atlanta, GA
Posts: 308
Tom Fairchild will become famous soon enoughTom Fairchild will become famous soon enough
Send a message via AIM to Tom Fairchild
After reading the posts on both sides of the issues, I must say that I think that robots should be directly shipped. This is coming from a team that lives an hour away from VCU, too. Yes, if this is a requirement, your robot not might get those final perfecting changes, but I think that that is a part of FIRST as well. Simply going to a regional gives a team an advantage with driver training, design checking and strategy. At the very worst, if a robot breaks, then drop out of the rest of the regional - you will still have more time to work on your bot than teams that are far away from regionals or don't have the resources.

Either way though, I'll be happy. I feel odd in not being in complete support of one side of the issue or the other - LoL, it really seems like people in this QOTW have said "obviously yes!" and "obviously no!" at the same time. For this I must congradulate Ken Leung for choosing a most wonderful topic choice.

~Tom~, who was really sick of the talks about how nationals were unfair etc. and is extremely glad to move on to another topic.
  #18   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 14-11-2001, 20:22
meaubry meaubry is offline
volunteer helper
FRC #6099 (Knights)
Team Role: Mentor
 
Join Date: Jun 2001
Rookie Year: 1997
Location: Shelby Twp, Mi
Posts: 784
meaubry has a reputation beyond reputemeaubry has a reputation beyond reputemeaubry has a reputation beyond reputemeaubry has a reputation beyond reputemeaubry has a reputation beyond reputemeaubry has a reputation beyond reputemeaubry has a reputation beyond reputemeaubry has a reputation beyond reputemeaubry has a reputation beyond reputemeaubry has a reputation beyond reputemeaubry has a reputation beyond repute
Just a thought... What if the rule was set up so that each team could keep their robot until 3 days before the 1st event they attended? Wouldn't that be an interesting twist - I'd bet teams would think twice about going to multiple events and concentrate on creating the best darn robot that they could for the events that they will be attending. Is that any less fair when each team has the option to choose when and where thay want to compete? Some will say that its a bad idea, and thats okay - I just thought this might be worth discussing?
  #19   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 14-11-2001, 22:00
Dan 550's Avatar
Dan 550 Dan 550 is offline
Behold the Awesomeness!
AKA: Dan Richards
#0550 (BattleTech)
Team Role: College Student
 
Join Date: Jun 2001
Rookie Year: 2000
Location: Jersey, Baby!
Posts: 310
Dan 550 is on a distinguished road
One event teams, small teams, rookies...

Last year, we at 550 were in a horrible, horrible situation. I'll start at the begining, to establish it better. Warren tech is a small technical high school, with less than 425 students, and nearly 35% of those students spend half the day at Tech and half of it at another school. There is a staff of 45 people, including maintenance and administration. We're tiny. The day before winter break last year, there was no coach, no team, no plan. Our principal managed to get one teacher to commit to going to the kick-off by the end of the day. Still no team. Monday after kickoff, the principal walked through the lunch room and grabbed a half dozen of the more intelligent people that got to know him well when he was assistant principal, myself included, and dragged us up to our auto shop. Oh, by the way, we had barely any support and no engineers, but we figure we don't need any, mainly because we still have no support. So, we're in the shop, and there's the red and green boxes and the mailing tube. It was at this time that we were declared the robotics team. For three weeks, we managed to design a bunch of stuff that couldn't be built under budget, and some other stuff. Around a week before ship date, with our lift-bot half-assembled, we started driving it around and testing. Sometime around the day before ship date we realized we couldn't finish it in time if our lives depended on it, so we boxed it. Sometime around ten minutes before ship time it was realized that we needed a bunch of papers and files and stuff to go out that day too. We garbled that, and for another three weeks we pondered the competition. Then, Tuesday of competition week, we packed all the stuff we thought we'd need. Needless to say, we brought almost nothing we did. Thursday, a driver, Dave, pulls a total-robotic-destruction move in a practice match, burns every motor on the bot except the compressor's, kills a piston, jams rack and sliders, breaks gear teeth, and sets the rug and another bot on fire! Boy, was I glad I was prepared for that! The judge comes over to me and tells me that the bot is smoking; I had noticed that, and I was looking for the cause when I saw the rug catch fire. About that time, I hit the kill button, hit Dave, and threw the bot off the field. I was angry, to say the least. Once the three flaming things (the field, a wooden bot, and the aluminum base on our bot) were extinguished, a half-hour was spent fixing the field, and then four hours were spent fixing our bot. About that time Dave informed us that he forgot his glasses, and he is legally blind without them. To this day, I have no idea why he came at all. The next day went as follows: three matches, one major repair, and a succession of a dozen or so matches requiring repair after each. We had eight people, no assigned drivers, and a load of confusion. And then came the FemBots series. Four matches, in succession, each with an excellent bot constructed wholly by engineers and driven by incompetant girls. This isn't to say all girls are incompetant; it just happens these two teams were incompetant and female. Totally, I don't think the point total of those matches exceeded 20. We dropped from 15th place to 40th place within those matches. Not a happy time. After that, the bot held up nicely, when we couldn't compete due to an amazing point deficit. We went to the party, and then Friday came. Our few matches that day went smoothly, and we wound up in 44th place, leading only one of the FemBots teams. But, on the whole, I enjoyed the experience, and I wouldn't give those full three months for anything.
  #20   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 07-04-2002, 05:07
ahecht's Avatar
ahecht ahecht is offline
'Luzer'
AKA: Zan
no team
Team Role: Alumni
 
Join Date: Dec 2001
Rookie Year: 2002
Location: Billerica, MA
Posts: 978
ahecht has a reputation beyond reputeahecht has a reputation beyond reputeahecht has a reputation beyond reputeahecht has a reputation beyond reputeahecht has a reputation beyond reputeahecht has a reputation beyond reputeahecht has a reputation beyond reputeahecht has a reputation beyond reputeahecht has a reputation beyond reputeahecht has a reputation beyond reputeahecht has a reputation beyond repute
Send a message via ICQ to ahecht Send a message via AIM to ahecht Send a message via Yahoo to ahecht
I think the only way to settle this issue is to make FIRST like any other sport. Regionals are for one region, and so teams are only allowed to attend one regional (and the national). This would level the playing field a bit for smaller teams who can't afford to travel and pay $4000 per regional in order to get more practice and time. It would also avoid the many spectator comments that "all regionals are the same." However, it is also a lot less fun to only attend one regional .
__________________
Zan Hecht

Scorekeeper: '05 Championship DaVinci Field/'10 WPI Regional
Co-Founder: WPI-EBOT Educational Robotics Program
Alumnus: WPI/Mass Academy Team #190
Alumnus (and founder): Oakwood Robotics Team #992


"Life is an odd numbered problem the answer isn't in the back of the book." — Anonymous WPI Student
  #21   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 07-04-2002, 15:51
Amy Beth's Avatar
Amy Beth Amy Beth is offline
Beach 'Bot Big Sister
#0330 (Beach 'Bot)
 
Join Date: Feb 2002
Location: Northridge, CA
Posts: 295
Amy Beth will become famous soon enoughAmy Beth will become famous soon enough
Send a message via AIM to Amy Beth Send a message via Yahoo to Amy Beth
Quote:
Originally posted by ahecht
I think the only way to settle this issue is to make FIRST like any other sport. Regionals are for one region, and so teams are only allowed to attend one regional (and the national). This would level the playing field a bit for smaller teams who can't afford to travel and pay $4000 per regional in order to get more practice and time. It would also avoid the many spectator comments that "all regionals are the same." However, it is also a lot less fun to only attend one regional .
I agree, Zan, that it definitely would level the playing field for rookie teams. However, were it not for norcallers coming down to socal, we might not have gotten enough teams to have a socal regional last year. Granted, this year was much larger and it would have been better for the newer, smaller teams if they had not had to compete against some of the more experienced teams. But with a few exceptions, there were far more socal teams at the norcal regional than vice-versa.
I wonder if someday FIRST will be forced to limit teams to one regional each?
__________________
Amy Ross
hisgirl@thetruth.com
AIM: AmyBeth719

http://wandasdream.tripod.com
  #22   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 22-11-2005, 15:50
jacob07's Avatar
jacob07 jacob07 is offline
Registered User
AKA: Jacob
FRC #0397 (Knight Riders)
Team Role: College Student
 
Join Date: Oct 2005
Rookie Year: 2002
Location: Flint MI
Posts: 166
jacob07 is a splendid one to beholdjacob07 is a splendid one to beholdjacob07 is a splendid one to beholdjacob07 is a splendid one to beholdjacob07 is a splendid one to beholdjacob07 is a splendid one to behold
Send a message via AIM to jacob07
Re: QUESTION OF THE WEEK!!! [11-11-01]

I personally think that taking home a robot from a competition is a bad idea. I think it gives teams an unfair advantage over other theams. For instance, what if a Team A had a competition in the first week of competitions and Team B didnt have a competition until the third week. At the third week competition both teams were at the same competition. That means that Team A had two more weeks than Team B which is really unfair. I think that the robots should be shipped to the competitions so as no team has a leg up on each other.
__________________
  #23   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 22-11-2005, 15:59
Elgin Clock's Avatar
Elgin Clock Elgin Clock is offline
updates this status less than FB!
AKA: the one who "will break into your thoughts..."
FRC #0237 (Black Magic)
Team Role: Mentor
 
Join Date: May 2001
Rookie Year: 2001
Location: H20-Town, Connecticut
Posts: 7,773
Elgin Clock has a reputation beyond reputeElgin Clock has a reputation beyond reputeElgin Clock has a reputation beyond reputeElgin Clock has a reputation beyond reputeElgin Clock has a reputation beyond reputeElgin Clock has a reputation beyond reputeElgin Clock has a reputation beyond reputeElgin Clock has a reputation beyond reputeElgin Clock has a reputation beyond reputeElgin Clock has a reputation beyond reputeElgin Clock has a reputation beyond repute
Send a message via AIM to Elgin Clock
Re: QUESTION OF THE WEEK!!! [11-11-01]

Quote:
Originally Posted by jacob07
I personally think that taking home a robot from a competition is a bad idea. I think it gives teams an unfair advantage over other theams. For instance, what if a Team A had a competition in the first week of competitions and Team B didnt have a competition until the third week. At the third week competition both teams were at the same competition. That means that Team A had two more weeks than Team B which is really unfair. I think that the robots should be shipped to the competitions so as no team has a leg up on each other.
You realize this thread is 4 years old and teams have not been able to take their bots home after the competitions since 2001... right?
__________________
The influence of many leads to the individuality of one. - E.C.C. (That's me!!)

  #24   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 22-11-2005, 16:16
dlavery's Avatar
dlavery dlavery is offline
Curmudgeon
FRC #0116 (Epsilon Delta)
 
Join Date: Jun 2001
Rookie Year: 1996
Location: Herndon, VA
Posts: 3,176
dlavery has a reputation beyond reputedlavery has a reputation beyond reputedlavery has a reputation beyond reputedlavery has a reputation beyond reputedlavery has a reputation beyond reputedlavery has a reputation beyond reputedlavery has a reputation beyond reputedlavery has a reputation beyond reputedlavery has a reputation beyond reputedlavery has a reputation beyond reputedlavery has a reputation beyond repute
Re: QUESTION OF THE WEEK!!! [11-11-01]

Holy thread resurrection, Batman!


-dave
__________________
"I know what you're thinking, punk," hissed Wordy Harry to his new editor, "you're thinking, 'Did he use six superfluous adjectives or only five?' - and to tell the truth, I forgot myself in all this excitement; but being as this is English, the most powerful language in the world, whose subtle nuances will blow your head clean off, you've got to ask yourself one question: 'Do I feel loquacious?' - well do you, punk?"
- Stuart Vasepuru, 2006 Bulwer-Lytton Fiction Contest



My OTHER CAR is still on Mars!!!
  #25   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 22-11-2005, 16:25
Madison's Avatar
Madison Madison is offline
Dancing through life...
FRC #0488 (Xbot)
Team Role: Engineer
 
Join Date: Jun 2001
Rookie Year: 1999
Location: Seattle, WA
Posts: 5,246
Madison has a reputation beyond reputeMadison has a reputation beyond reputeMadison has a reputation beyond reputeMadison has a reputation beyond reputeMadison has a reputation beyond reputeMadison has a reputation beyond reputeMadison has a reputation beyond reputeMadison has a reputation beyond reputeMadison has a reputation beyond reputeMadison has a reputation beyond reputeMadison has a reputation beyond repute
Re: QUESTION OF THE WEEK!!! [11-11-01]

The 2006 game will clearly involve zombies.
__________________
--Madison--

...down at the Ozdust!

Like a grand and miraculous spaceship, our planet has sailed through the universe of time. And for a brief moment, we have been among its many passengers.
  #26   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 22-11-2005, 17:00
Rod's Avatar
Rod Rod is offline
Mentor
FRC #0662 (Rocky Mountain Robotics)
Team Role: Mentor
 
Join Date: Dec 2003
Rookie Year: 2003
Location: Colorado Springs, CO
Posts: 98
Rod is a splendid one to beholdRod is a splendid one to beholdRod is a splendid one to beholdRod is a splendid one to beholdRod is a splendid one to beholdRod is a splendid one to beholdRod is a splendid one to behold
Send a message via AIM to Rod
Re: QUESTION OF THE WEEK!!! [11-11-01]

Wow I clicked on this and got covered in dust.
__________________
-Rod-
Team 662
Rocky Mountain Robotics
Colorado Springs, CO
Closed Thread


Thread Tools
Display Modes Rate This Thread
Rate This Thread:

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Forum Jump

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
QUESTION OF THE WEEK!!! archiver 2000 8 23-06-2002 23:40
QUESTION OF THE WEEK!!! archiver 2000 20 23-06-2002 23:34
QUESTION OF THE WEEK!!! archiver 2000 21 23-06-2002 23:25
Where is question of the week? archiver 2000 0 23-06-2002 23:24
QUESTION OF THE WEEK!!! [7-29-01] Matt Leese Rumor Mill 7 30-07-2001 19:24


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 13:22.

The Chief Delphi Forums are sponsored by Innovation First International, Inc.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © Chief Delphi