|
|
|
![]() |
|
|||||||
|
||||||||
![]() |
|
|
Thread Tools | Rate Thread | Display Modes |
|
|
|
#1
|
||||
|
||||
|
listen to these guys
I totally agree with Ken W.'s comments about what goes on in your first couple years of engineering school. You are learning the foundation, the theories behind the applications. Those concepts are very important because there will be many times in an engineering career where you go back to those fundamentals.
It is difficult, and competitive. But why would you expect anything less? Hopefully FIRST is giving the students an idea of what things are possible AFTER you get your engineering degree (not so much WHILE you are getting it). Ken W. described the impact he has had on some truly impressive engineering programs. I would guess that most of the engineers involved in FIRST are proud of their accomplishments and their positive impact on society. So from where we are sitting (enjoying the rewards of an engineering education) its very easy to conclude that going to engineering school is worth the effort. The great thing about FIRST is that students get to experience some of this while they are in high school and they can easily change the educational path they are on. I often tell people that I don't care if students involved in FIRST become engineers - we are just giving them the opportunity to decide for themselves (and I think enough of them will see the bright light at the end of the tunnel and go for it). Good luck, Aaron - I think your careful thought about what you really want to do will serve you well, regardless of what career path you choose. Ken Mechanical Engineer since 1985 |
|
#2
|
|||||
|
|||||
|
Re: listen to these guys
Quote:
And they all (mostly) felt that the FIRST experience was hard work but priceless and it allowed them to examine many new opportunities they didn't know about. PS- This thread/postings is one of the best I've seen, I don't know there was so many old timer.... oh I meant Senior FIRSTers! ![]() Last edited by Rich Wong : 15-11-2003 at 00:37. |
|
#3
|
||||||
|
||||||
|
Re: listen to these guys
Quote:
However maybe we could, as a program, do a better job of helping students see this difference ahead of time. In any endeavor, (work, FIRST, marriage, school, long outdoor trips) it helps to know that while there will be difficult times, they are temporary. It helps to know that what you really need to do is hang on and gut it out in the short term, and the result will be a long term gain. Forewarned is Forearmed Aarron, what you are going through is perfectly normal. Your advantage is that you have had a taste of what life can be like after you make it through the tough part. The real question is do you want what you have tasted bad enough to struggle through and get there? If yes, then press on If not, then think very carefully about what you DO want and pursue that. Finally, if you get too bogged down with something you don't understand in your classwork, then post a question here and we will try and explain it. I remember I was having trouble with some things in Physics, I wasn't understanding how some problems were solved. I explained my frustration to a fellow student who was a year or so ahead of me. It turned out the Physics class was using mathematical techniques we hadn't been taught yet. In fifteen minutes another this resolved a problem I had been struggling with a whole quarter. We can do that here too. There is nothing in FIRST that says mentoring has to stop when you graduate... |
|
#4
|
|||||
|
|||||
|
Re: Purdue - Engineering
Quote:
Great to see some more people at Purdue. When I started at Purdue I thought engineering was the thing, however at that point I had never actually met an engineer and really didn't know what they did but it seemed right. (No FIRST back then as far as I knew '91) However after 6 semesters in EE at Purdue I began to wonder, is this for me, is this what I want to do for the rest of my life. (Purdue is very intensive into the theory, many engineers from Purdue seem destined for research) For those of you who aren't from Purdue it is probably very similar to many Universities in that there is almost nothing remotely connected to Electrical until about your third year, until then you go through Freshman engineering which is the same for all disciplines then advanced math and physics. However I am definitely more of a hands on person, math didn't bother me but it doesn't have much 'fun factor' figuring out the attraction of a single atom to a infinite plane of atoms 1 meter away My father always told me to make sure I pick a career that I enjoy going to otherwise each day will seem like an eternity. Well what did I do, I started asking around and found the Technology department at Purdue and ended up transferring to EET. Immediately instead of reading about the theory of a transistor, I was designing circuits, learning how they work and how to troubleshoot. Then I was able to get into some MET classes and CNC machine and design. Later I found classes in PLC programming and control systems to be the most interesting and thats how I ended up at GM in the Controls, Robotics, and Welding group. At first I was concerned that the BS in EET would not be held as highly as the EE degree that I was working on, however it turned out nearly opposite. Many of the EET's and MET's are actually very prepared right away for application type engineering where as many of my co-workers with straight EE degrees had no/little experience in hands-on building, programming, debugging. If I could do it again, Purdue now has a program called CIMT (Computer Integrated Manufacturing Technology) which is exactly what I do and would have been perfect. (Control Systems, Robots, Manufacturing all in one).So is Engineering right for you? It very well might be, however don't become an engineer because your parents want you to, or someone else says it is right for you. If you want to be an engineer talk to the engineers that you get to experience FIRST with, find out if they would do it the same way if they could or what might be a better pick for your special case. If anyone out there wants any further info from me please drop me an email I would be happy to help. |
|
#5
|
||||
|
||||
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Last edited by Adam Y. : 15-11-2003 at 15:40. |
|
#6
|
||||
|
||||
|
Engineering technolgy is geared more towards fabrication, assemlbling systems, and testing assemblies.
Electrical engineering is geared towards designing systems - designing end products. For example, I spend a lot of time designing circuit boards at Xerox - if you take the back cover off a Xerox machine you will see boards in there that I designed (and you will void your warrenty :c) when those boards are fabricated and assembled in a factory (not ours) they are tested as bare boards, and tested after they are assembled. A person with an engineering technology degree would be the one to design or assembly the componets of those test fixtures, and figure out how to test the board as fully as possible before it is assembled into a machine - its a field of science all unto itself. An electrical technician (a 2 year degree) would be the person who wires up systems, or debugs parts of it when its not working correctly, or who debugs boards that fail the automated tests. |
|
#7
|
||||||
|
||||||
|
Warning to any freshman in engineering:
Many schools make the first year (and sometimes second year) fundamental classes extremely hard on purpose to weed out those who are not really there for the right reasons. My first Physics exam at Purdue kicked my butt and depressed the heck out of me because I never saw it coming and thought that I had flunked the test. In fact, a 35% on the test was considered a "C" grade. No one had gotten higher than a 65% on that test. I survived that class and a few others like it (2nd semester chemistry was even worse). After a while you learn to deal with the curve graded system and how to maximize your score on exams by not getting stuck on one hard problem. A straight "A" student in high school can easily become a "B" student in college if they do not adapt properly. Any way, as others have said, do not judge whether you should stick with engineering based on early college classes, but rather on doing some soul searching and decide if what engineers do in real life turns you on. And of course, pick the engineering fields interest you the most. Raul PS - don't mind Mike Soukup. He is a little sensitive about SW engineering cause we tease him and pick on SW when the robot doesn't work. But he is right - it can be very complex. |
|
#8
|
||||
|
||||
|
Quote:
|
|
#9
|
||||
|
||||
|
Quote:
|
|
#10
|
|||
|
|||
|
Quote:
---------------------------------------------- Here's my take on the issue. After being involved in FIRST for 3 years I "knew" what I wanted to do. I applied to a few different schools and was accepted into the Engineering programs at places like the Milwaukee School Of Engineering (MSOE), and the University of Evansville. Around mid April of this year, I found out that I wouldn't be able to attend MSOE due to the financial situation and a few other reasons. I ended up going to my last ditched choice, the Purdue School of Technology, but take classes here in my hometown of Kokomo and major in Computer Technology (Computer Engineering Technology), then eventually transfer into the Engineering School at Purdue later. Well I'm glad that I didn't end up at MSOE, otherwise I'd probably hate it. Over time, I've realized that Computer Technology was what was right for me and I'm sitting in a position that I will be able to move to West Lafayette and finish my degree at the main campus of Purdue. My biggest mistake was that I assumed w/o researching or trying. Fortunately due to the fact that I couldn't afford going to a 32,000+ a year college, I could find out what was right for me w/o wasting money and ruining my GPA. I was lucky that I caught myself before making a mistake in how I am going to spend the rest of my life. All I can say is exactly what everyone else said before with this exception: Don't assume what you think is right for you, make sure you know what it right for you. |
|
#11
|
||||
|
||||
|
Sorry guys, stuff like that makes my neurons fire.
I absolutely HATE when I get the "Programming isn't that important" response, I get that stuff fromy my teachers a lot. |
|
#12
|
||||
|
||||
|
Quote:
![]() Raul deals with software engineers every day, so I'm pretty sure he understands the importance of it. I know exactly what you mean though about it hitting a nerve. I felt the same way when I read the original post that Mike responded to. Quote:
|
|
#13
|
||||
|
||||
|
Re: Skewed Perspective
Quote:
I went threw the exact same thing that Aaron is going threw the first semester of my second year. I had this Calc 3 class that was by far the lowlight of my time at college. I had serious thought of never being able to pass that class, but I stuck with it and threw a lot of hard work and long nights I somehow passed with a C. While I do think it was the worst class I ever took, its was also the best thing for me at that time. I now know that if I passed that class there is no class that I can't pass. Like Raul said, it is really discouraging getting that test back with a 45% on the top of it, but then you see the grade distribution and realize that a 45% is the 5th highest grade in the class. And the point about weed out classes hits the nail right on the head. They are put in the program for exactly that, to get people that aren't totally interested and willing to put ridiculous amounts of time out of the program. Back to FIRST. In my sophmore design class I finally realized the value that FIRST had. The class consisted of about 60 students from all of the engineering majors. We were broken up into 3 multiple disciplinary teams and given our asignment. We were told that we need to, design, build, and test a robot to go threw the sewer system and to take video of the inside of the pipes. We were also told we had about 2 months to do it. (sound firmiliar to anyone yet?) As the class progressed I was amazed at how closely it followed FIRST. I always felt one step ahead of everyone else in the class because I had already been threw basically the same situation 3 times. Needless to say you can guess which teams robot stole the show on demo day. I have FIRST and a lot of hard work from my team to thank for that. FIRST and everyone involved in it totally changed my outlook on engineering and I know I owe the program a ton for that. |
|
#14
|
|||||
|
|||||
|
As a FIRST year Engineering Student, I do not have the experience you all have expressed here. See FIRST is my motivation. Engineering is what I want to do. FIRST has given me experiences which I feel set me a part from my"peers." But to me, my real peers to me are those of you within the FIRST community. Also its what gets me through the day. Being a mentor on NUTRONs isn't just cause I love doing this, rather it is also an escape from the vigors of freshman engineering. (Erin, you didn't just read this
) The classes you have to take your first year are to weed people out. It was the same for high school with the International Baccelaureate Program. The first year was to try to get people who didn't want to do it out. Like here at Northeastern, I think it is our chemstry course now but its probably physics next semester. Aaron, if anything else, folllow your heart to wherever it leads you. That's another thing FIRST has taught me. |
![]() |
| Thread Tools | |
| Display Modes | Rate This Thread |
|
|
Similar Threads
|
||||
| Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
| From our Perspective | LizJJury | 3D Animation and Competition | 21 | 26-07-2003 18:56 |
| Image Discuss: perspective | CD47-Bot | Extra Discussion | 1 | 02-02-2003 16:42 |
| QUESTION OF THE WEEK!!! | archiver | 2000 | 34 | 24-06-2002 00:07 |
| Is the Chairman's Award fixed? I believe so..... | archiver | 2000 | 30 | 23-06-2002 23:31 |
| One way to think about it. | Joe Johnson | General Forum | 16 | 07-10-2001 21:21 |