Victors verses Jaguars?

[Al Skierkiewicz]

Originally Posted by Ether

I'm not sure anyone knows for certain why this happens, but one prevailing hypothesis is that the PWM frequency of the Vic is low enough to create torque ripple near enough to the resonant frequency of the pins to knock them loose and keep them from jamming.

I believe that the low mass of the locking pins cause them to oscillate into a lock mode when the motor is powered through the 15kHz switching of the Jag. Removing the locks fixes this problem in many applications. While locking is still an issue with Vic, the problem seems to occur far less frequently.
While the newer Jags have gone to lower "ON" resistance FETs, the manufacturer has lowered the number to two in each leg while the Vic remains at three. I think this gives a slight edge to the Vic in terms of dissipation at sustained high currents. No one has mentioned that the Vics are conformal coated. This coating prevents a lot of the contamination that is prevalent with the Jags.
Heating of the CIMs over a two hour practice/demo is not unusual. The CIM motors are sealed and intended for intermittent duty. Internal heat has very small paths to dissipate to the outside air.