[BB] Bills Blog 11/10/11

[Dancin103]

Originally Posted by BugByte

It's interesting that they're suggesting teams nominate juniors for dean's list. I understand they could benefit from it the most but I would like to think it's more than that.

They have always suggested that. Our team has always tended to submit one junior and senior. It's really up to you. I know that some teams submit sophomores.

Cass

[MagiChau]

Said under 5.5 # 2. is that bumpers may be bagged separately from the robot with its own tag accounted for in the Robot Lock-Up Form. I do not know if this was in previous manuals, but I feel like pointing it out just in case.

[Bob Steele]

Originally Posted by MagiChau

Said under 5.5 # 2. is that bumpers may be bagged separately from the robot with its own tag accounted for in the Robot Lock-Up Form. I do not know if this was in previous manuals, but I feel like pointing it out just in case.

Wow ... that is great... they actually listen to us...
Good for them... this will allow un-bumpered robots to get through doors a lot easier...

Safer for handling too..

GREAT!!

[apalrd]

The idea of locking up bumpers separately seems odd, as the ability to work on your bumpers post-bag dosen't give you any advantage at all. It's better than requiring them to be in the bag, I guess.

[GaryVoshol]

Originally Posted by apalrd

The idea of locking up bumpers separately seems odd, as the ability to work on your bumpers post-bag dosen't give you any advantage at all. It's better than requiring them to be in the bag, I guess.

Not requiring them to be bagged would allow you to put off building them entirely until after Bag Day.

[Kimmeh]

Originally Posted by GaryVoshol

Not requiring them to be bagged would allow you to put off building them entirely until after Bag Day.

I can see this already:

Do we have everything loaded?
Yup.
You sure?
Mhmm.
Then what's that pile of stuff over there?
Oh that's just stuff to make ...bumpers.
What do you mean they're not built!?
Well...we didn't have to put them in the bag...So we haven't built them yet...



Seriously though, I've seen plenty of teams have issues getting though doors with them on. For that reason, my team has always packed the bumpers in the bag with them resting on top of the robot as opposed to on the robot.

[jtdowney]

Originally Posted by Kimmeh

Then what's that pile of stuff over there?
Oh that's just stuff to make ...bumpers.
What do you mean they're not built!?

Unfortunately I've overheard this conversation on Thursdays at events.

[Gary Dillard]

Hmmmmmmmmmm.... new scoring system?

6.5 COOPERTITION™ AWARD
To determine the winner of the Coopertition Award, the FMS will rank all teams in decreasing order, using the following sorting criteria:

1st Order Sort: 2 x Coopertition Score – Qualification Score
2nd Order Sort: Coopertition Score

[Chris is me]

Originally Posted by GaryVoshol

Not requiring them to be bagged would allow you to put off building them entirely until after Bag Day.

Why would this be a bad thing?

[GaryVoshol]

Originally Posted by Chris is me

Why would this be a bad thing?

Depends on your perspective whether it's good or bad. It fails the "all tools down" test.

I wouldn't say having more time to work on bumpers is extremely beneficial, but you could use the time to make the bumpers easier to come off/on, or in 148's case, add flashing red lights to it.

[IndySam]

Why is there a debate about having extra time to build the bumpers? They have to be bagged at the same time as the robot and logged onto the lock-up form.

[ratdude747]

you know, you don't HAVE to build the bumpers pre-bag. If it is like years past, couldn't you make them as part of the withholding allowance? (or has that been a confirmed change?)

of course, like anything, there is big difference between "can" and "should"

[thefro526]

Originally Posted by apalrd

The idea of locking up bumpers separately seems odd, as the ability to work on your bumpers post-bag dosen't give you any advantage at all. It's better than requiring them to be in the bag, I guess.

Bumpers are technically considered Fabricated Parts therefore subject to Withholding restrictions in previous years. This was ignored at many events, and wasn't uncommon to see a team bring in what appeared to be 35lbs of upgrade parts along with two sets of bumpers at 12-15lbs a set.

Not to mention we've put as many as 20 man hours into our bumpers in any given year, so being able to make them after ship means those 20 man hours can be spent elsewhere...

[Karibou]

Originally Posted by apalrd

The idea of locking up bumpers separately seems odd, as the ability to work on your bumpers post-bag dosen't give you any advantage at all. It's better than requiring them to be in the bag, I guess.

I think that the intention of that section was, as Bob pointed out, so that teams have an easier time getting a bagged robot through the door. It's sometimes an interesting struggle to get them through doors with bumpers.

From the wording that's there, they still have to be bagged on bag day, whether it be with the robot or in a bag by themselves.