Go to Post I had a fight with my robot once during competition. I felt bad about it and apologized. - Tommy F. [more]
Home
Go Back   Chief Delphi > Technical > Motors
CD-Media   CD-Spy  
portal register members calendar search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read FAQ rules

 
Closed Thread
Thread Tools Rate Thread Display Modes
  #16   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 23-12-2011, 12:46
DonRotolo's Avatar
DonRotolo DonRotolo is offline
Back to humble
FRC #0832
Team Role: Mentor
 
Join Date: Jan 2005
Rookie Year: 2005
Location: Atlanta GA
Posts: 7,019
DonRotolo has a reputation beyond reputeDonRotolo has a reputation beyond reputeDonRotolo has a reputation beyond reputeDonRotolo has a reputation beyond reputeDonRotolo has a reputation beyond reputeDonRotolo has a reputation beyond reputeDonRotolo has a reputation beyond reputeDonRotolo has a reputation beyond reputeDonRotolo has a reputation beyond reputeDonRotolo has a reputation beyond reputeDonRotolo has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Motor Quiz

Quote:
Originally Posted by Ether View Post
The whole concept using "significant figures" this way, although still taught in high schools, is deeply flawed.
Are you saying that there's more than 4 significant digits in the 'best' answer?
Quote:
Originally Posted by EricH View Post
I'm curious why you say it's flawed--besides the fact it confused me every time I tried to use it!
Me too, because I'm not sure in which way you find flaw.

The statement I use is "Just because your calculator shows 8 digits doesn't mean they are all important".

On the other hand, it is very important to know just how many digits you really have to work with, and a good idea of physical reality to check for reasonableness.
__________________

I am N2IRZ - What's your callsign?
  #17   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 23-12-2011, 12:52
nighterfighter nighterfighter is offline
1771 Alum, 1771 Mentor
AKA: Matt B
FRC #1771 (1771)
Team Role: Mentor
 
Join Date: Sep 2009
Rookie Year: 2007
Location: Suwanee/Kennesaw, GA
Posts: 835
nighterfighter has a brilliant futurenighterfighter has a brilliant futurenighterfighter has a brilliant futurenighterfighter has a brilliant futurenighterfighter has a brilliant futurenighterfighter has a brilliant futurenighterfighter has a brilliant futurenighterfighter has a brilliant futurenighterfighter has a brilliant futurenighterfighter has a brilliant futurenighterfighter has a brilliant future
Re: Motor Quiz

Quote:
Originally Posted by xSAWxBLADEx View Post
yep never did like quizes, multiple guess tests are better.
In real life, there are no multiple choice questions.

Usually....
  #18   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 23-12-2011, 13:58
Ether's Avatar
Ether Ether is offline
systems engineer (retired)
no team
 
Join Date: Nov 2009
Rookie Year: 1969
Location: US
Posts: 8,125
Ether has a reputation beyond reputeEther has a reputation beyond reputeEther has a reputation beyond reputeEther has a reputation beyond reputeEther has a reputation beyond reputeEther has a reputation beyond reputeEther has a reputation beyond reputeEther has a reputation beyond reputeEther has a reputation beyond reputeEther has a reputation beyond reputeEther has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Motor Quiz

Quote:
Originally Posted by EricH View Post
It's also at least touched on at the college level. I'm curious why you say it's flawed--besides the fact it confused me every time I tried to use it! (I typically hold about a 2-3 decimal digit precision in the final answer, but I'll often go to 4-5 decimal digits or more during calculations.)
Several parallel thoughts come to mind:

1) for a detailed (and humorous) treatment, see this link.

2) rounding the answer to 11 volts as suggested here gives a profoundly wrong answer*. At 11 volts, the torque at 3700 rpm is 75.5 oz-in

3) with modern computers and calculators, there is no reason to drop any digits of precision during intermediate calculations. carry all the precision through, then round the final answer. the number of digits to keep is not a simple matter of looking number of digits in the datum with the least digits. in the specific case of this problem, tenths of a volt is a reasonable (and necessary) precision to get a reasonably correct answer:

61 oz-in @ 3710 rpm requires 10.52 volts

59 oz-in @ 3690 rpm requires 10.40 volts

... so if you want to round to 10.5 volts that would be reasonable, but not 11 volts*


*we are talking about correct answers to the problem as stated. I know that manufacturing tolerances of the motor could cause wide variation.
  #19   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 23-12-2011, 13:59
Ether's Avatar
Ether Ether is offline
systems engineer (retired)
no team
 
Join Date: Nov 2009
Rookie Year: 1969
Location: US
Posts: 8,125
Ether has a reputation beyond reputeEther has a reputation beyond reputeEther has a reputation beyond reputeEther has a reputation beyond reputeEther has a reputation beyond reputeEther has a reputation beyond reputeEther has a reputation beyond reputeEther has a reputation beyond reputeEther has a reputation beyond reputeEther has a reputation beyond reputeEther has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Motor Quiz

Quote:
Originally Posted by DonRotolo View Post
Are you saying that there's more than 4 significant digits in the 'best' answer?
No. But I am saying using only 2 digits (11 volts), as suggested, is not a correct answer.

Quote:
Me too, because I'm not sure in which way you find flaw.
More detail posted here.

Quote:
The statement I use is "Just because your calculator shows 8 digits doesn't mean they are all important"
Agreed. But a student should learn how to use the calculator in such a way that all those digits get used through the intermediate calculations.

Quote:
On the other hand, it is very important to know just how many digits you really have to work with, and a good idea of physical reality to check for reasonableness.
I agree completely.


  #20   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 23-12-2011, 15:44
Aren Siekmeier's Avatar
Aren Siekmeier Aren Siekmeier is offline
on walkabout
FRC #2175 (The Fighting Calculators)
Team Role: Mentor
 
Join Date: Apr 2008
Rookie Year: 2008
Location: 대한민국
Posts: 735
Aren Siekmeier has a reputation beyond reputeAren Siekmeier has a reputation beyond reputeAren Siekmeier has a reputation beyond reputeAren Siekmeier has a reputation beyond reputeAren Siekmeier has a reputation beyond reputeAren Siekmeier has a reputation beyond reputeAren Siekmeier has a reputation beyond reputeAren Siekmeier has a reputation beyond reputeAren Siekmeier has a reputation beyond reputeAren Siekmeier has a reputation beyond reputeAren Siekmeier has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Motor Quiz

I agree that the whole "sig figs" deal is flawed. I had a science teacher in high school who extolled it, and perhaps it was his inability to do basic algebra that led me to skepticism of that as well. My beef with it is that it is so dependent on the base in which you are representing the numbers. If you're going to worry about such things, actually do the stats with how the initial standard deviations or uncertainties propagate through the calculations. If you don't care that much, just round your final answer at the end to something that's not way than you care about, but still gives detail relevant to the problem and its context. My answer 10.43 was perhaps too many digits: 10.4V would perhaps have been more appropriate given how much control we actually have over (and how much we actually about) the voltages in question. But it doesn't really matter that much. And as Ether has pointed out, 11V is just plain wrong. And one should never round in the intermediate steps. The best way to go about these calculations is to solve for the answer symbolically and then just plug in your parameters, since the general solution in infinitely more useful and this avoids any intermediate rounding errors. I do a lot of calculations in excel and keep all the digits (the first 30 some anyway) around. However, when reporting these intermediate values, I will often round to keep it uncluttered.

Also (to sanddrag mostly), my method of solving was based on the fact that stall torque and free speed scaled with voltage, so I whipped a quick mathematical model that did just that. Your (sanddrag's) approach went through the physics of it from the start, which is equally valid (in fact, that's where we get the linear dependence of stall torque and free speed on voltage, as well the linear performance curve between them).
  #21   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 23-12-2011, 16:53
MooreteP's Avatar
MooreteP MooreteP is offline
Zen Archer
AKA: Senor Mas
FRC #0571 (Team Paragon)
Team Role: Mentor
 
Join Date: Mar 2004
Rookie Year: 1998
Location: Windsor CT
Posts: 811
MooreteP has a reputation beyond reputeMooreteP has a reputation beyond reputeMooreteP has a reputation beyond reputeMooreteP has a reputation beyond reputeMooreteP has a reputation beyond reputeMooreteP has a reputation beyond reputeMooreteP has a reputation beyond reputeMooreteP has a reputation beyond reputeMooreteP has a reputation beyond reputeMooreteP has a reputation beyond reputeMooreteP has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Motor Quiz

Quote:
Originally Posted by Ether View Post



The whole concept using "significant figures" this way, although still taught in high schools, is deeply flawed.


To use the phrase "deeply flawed" suggests that you have difficulty with the meanings of the ideas behind precision and accuracy.
Suggesting that because it is "still taught in high schools" and thus maybe has little relevance, is possibly offensive.

Just try a small exercise:
Imagine that the motor may rotate 3701 revolutions in a single minute. Not an unreasonable possibility. Or even that the 60 oz-in is actually 60.01 oz-in. Recalculate your answers.
Every digit that you include beyond four becomes irrelevant, it is just calculator detritus.

IMHO, sometimes people use excessive digits in their calculations of answers like curse words, to emphasize their supposed superiority where it is not necessary.

The precision of the measurement determines the accuracy of the result.
  #22   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 23-12-2011, 18:32
Joe Ross's Avatar Unsung FIRST Hero
Joe Ross Joe Ross is offline
Registered User
FRC #0330 (Beachbots)
Team Role: Engineer
 
Join Date: Jun 2001
Rookie Year: 1997
Location: Los Angeles, CA
Posts: 8,599
Joe Ross has a reputation beyond reputeJoe Ross has a reputation beyond reputeJoe Ross has a reputation beyond reputeJoe Ross has a reputation beyond reputeJoe Ross has a reputation beyond reputeJoe Ross has a reputation beyond reputeJoe Ross has a reputation beyond reputeJoe Ross has a reputation beyond reputeJoe Ross has a reputation beyond reputeJoe Ross has a reputation beyond reputeJoe Ross has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Motor Quiz

Quote:
Originally Posted by MooreteP View Post
Just try a small exercise:
Imagine that the motor may rotate 3701 revolutions in a single minute. Not an unreasonable possibility. Or even that the 60 oz-in is actually 60.01 oz-in. Recalculate your answers.
Every digit that you include beyond four becomes irrelevant, it is just calculator detritus.
Those are desired values, not measured values, and should not be considered when doing significant figures. It's assumed that Ether wants those values as close as possible.

Where significant figures should be applied is on the input values (In Aren's calculations the Free speed, Stall torque, and Spec voltage). All were given to at least 3 significant figures (It should be safe to assume that Spec Voltage wasn't 12v +/- 0.5, but rather +/-0.05 or even better).
  #23   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 24-12-2011, 08:15
MooreteP's Avatar
MooreteP MooreteP is offline
Zen Archer
AKA: Senor Mas
FRC #0571 (Team Paragon)
Team Role: Mentor
 
Join Date: Mar 2004
Rookie Year: 1998
Location: Windsor CT
Posts: 811
MooreteP has a reputation beyond reputeMooreteP has a reputation beyond reputeMooreteP has a reputation beyond reputeMooreteP has a reputation beyond reputeMooreteP has a reputation beyond reputeMooreteP has a reputation beyond reputeMooreteP has a reputation beyond reputeMooreteP has a reputation beyond reputeMooreteP has a reputation beyond reputeMooreteP has a reputation beyond reputeMooreteP has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Motor Quiz

Quote:
Originally Posted by Joe Ross View Post
Those are desired values, not measured values, and should not be considered when doing significant figures. It's assumed that Ether wants those values as close as possible.

Where significant figures should be applied is on the input values (In Aren's calculations the Free speed, Stall torque, and Spec voltage). All were given to at least 3 significant figures (It should be safe to assume that Spec Voltage wasn't 12v +/- 0.5, but rather +/-0.05 or even better).
And as the motor heats up near the end of a match?
Ohm's law breaks down, and nature takes her tax.
Closed Thread


Thread Tools
Display Modes Rate This Thread
Rate This Thread:

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Forum Jump


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 15:06.

The Chief Delphi Forums are sponsored by Innovation First International, Inc.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © Chief Delphi