Jaguars - Current Mode Fails

[Patrickwhite]

The slaves do not and never have relied on PID loops - they draw straight from the masters.

[Joe Ross]

Originally Posted by Patrickwhite

The slaves do not and never have relied on PID loops - they draw straight from the masters.

Current mode uses PID.

[Patrickwhite]

Originally Posted by Joe Ross

Current mode uses PID.

Exclusively? For our purposes, it is not only impractical but also not healthy for the motors, as ideally the slaves should be running at the same speed as the masters.

If they use PID exclusively, is it not true that Current mode is more effective at distributing the work load?

[JewishDan18]

They use a PID loops to get the current draw as close to the target as possible. Remember, the output is some speed from -1 to 1. The Jaguar needs the PID loop to figure out what output will get the proper current draw.

[Mr. Lim]

Does anyone have any experience trying to get a "slave" CIM to sync current output with a "master" CIM - specifically in the application of a 4-motor (2 per side) drivetrain?

I'm curious what ballpark PID values were used, and what your tuning methodology was.

We're planning on using the speed control PID on the master Jags. If there is a PID loop running on the slave Jags just to match the currents, if it doesn't react fast enough, it'll confuse the master Jag's speed PID loop. Sort of like trying to hit a constantly moving target.

Has anyone already implemented something similar to this?

[JewishDan18]

Originally Posted by Mr. Lim

Does anyone have any experience trying to get a "slave" CIM to sync current output with a "master" CIM - specifically in the application of a 4-motor (2 per side) drivetrain?

I'm curious what ballpark PID values were used, and what your tuning methodology was.

We're planning on using the speed control PID on the master Jags. If there is a PID loop running on the slave Jags just to match the currents, if it doesn't react fast enough, it'll confuse the master Jag's speed PID loop. Sort of like trying to hit a constantly moving target.

Has anyone already implemented something similar to this?

If I had to do this, I would have the PID control on the master jaguar, then take whatever that PID loop is outputing, and set the slave to that value (no PID loop on the slave jaguars). I had to use two motors to control a fully connected crab drive last year, and this method worked well for it.

[Patrickwhite]

That sounds like what we were doing before - we had the slave Jaguars running in PercentVBus mode, and the master Jaguars running in PID speed control mode. We had separate PID loops on the left and right master Jaguars. To synchronize the slaves, we used:

...
jagLeftSlave.setX(jagLeftMaster.getOutputVoltage() / jagLeftMaster.getBusVoltage());
jagRightSlave.setX(jagRightMaster.getOutputVoltage() / jagRightMaster.getBusVoltage());
...

Is something similar to this not possible in current mode?

[JewishDan18]

Originally Posted by Patrickwhite

That sounds like what we were doing before - we had the slave Jaguars running in PercentVBus mode, and the master Jaguars running in PID speed control mode. We had separate PID loops on the left and right master Jaguars. To synchronize the slaves, we used:

...
jagLeftSlave.setX(jagLeftMaster.getOutputVoltage() / jagLeftMaster.getBusVoltage());
jagRightSlave.setX(jagRightMaster.getOutputVoltage() / jagRightMaster.getBusVoltage());
...

Is something similar to this not possible in current mode?

No, you can't have the same speed and current guaranteed at the same time; you need to pick one.