Go to Post a robot can always be your girl. xcept for the fact you need to share - greencactus3 [more]
Home
Go Back   Chief Delphi > Technical > Electrical
CD-Media   CD-Spy  
portal register members calendar search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read FAQ rules

 
Closed Thread
Thread Tools Rate Thread Display Modes
  #1   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 19-03-2013, 13:21
mcarobotics's Avatar
mcarobotics mcarobotics is offline
M. McEwen
AKA: M.McEwen
FRC #4595 (Infinity Robotics)
Team Role: Electrical
 
Join Date: Dec 2012
Rookie Year: 2013
Location: Canada
Posts: 32
mcarobotics is on a distinguished road
Speed Controllers: Which is best?

Our team's robot uses Victors exclusively as our speed controllers because they are smallest and cheaper than Jaguars and Talons.
However, I have seen many teams using Jaguars and Talons a lot instead of Victors. I have seen some people use Spikes a lot as well.
Which type of speed controller works best and why? Which is the best quality/most durable? Which one does your team use the most?
I'm trying to decide if our team should switch next year or stick with Victors.
Thanks!
__________________
The Fish is watching you.
http://www.mcainfinityrobotics.com
  #2   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 19-03-2013, 13:27
CalTran's Avatar
CalTran CalTran is online now
MST Rolla Senior
FRC #2410 (BV CAPS Metal Mustang Robotics)
Team Role: College Student
 
Join Date: Apr 2010
Rookie Year: 2010
Location: Overland Park, Kansas
Posts: 2,419
CalTran has a reputation beyond reputeCalTran has a reputation beyond reputeCalTran has a reputation beyond reputeCalTran has a reputation beyond reputeCalTran has a reputation beyond reputeCalTran has a reputation beyond reputeCalTran has a reputation beyond reputeCalTran has a reputation beyond reputeCalTran has a reputation beyond reputeCalTran has a reputation beyond reputeCalTran has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Speed Controllers: Which is best?

For the record, spikes are not "motor controllers" per say...they're relays, and generally used as on/off switches for certain motors (R52 for more information)

Our team used Talons this year, and we are immensely satisfied with the result. The linear response and small footprint is incredible, not to mention how it is an enclosed motor controller so we don't have to worry too much about shavings and dust and whatnot.
As far as using Jaguars, the only reason to continue using them right now would be an inventory of them or if your team is particularly fond of CAN/2CAN.
__________________
Team 2410 thinks KISSing is amazing! Keep It Super Safe!
  • "You know you've been in robotics too long when you start talking to your tools." "Well, you've been in robotics CLEARLY too long when they start talking back"
  • Theory is when you know everything but nothing works. Practice is when everything works but you don't know why. On our team, theory and practice comes together - nothing works and nobody knows why.
MMR 2410 Student (2010 - 2013) | MMR 2410 Mentor (2013 - Present)
FTC Game Announcer / EmCee (2014 - Present) | FRC EmCee (2015 - Present) | FRC Referee (2016) | FTC Referee (2017)
Academic Student (Forever)
  #3   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 19-03-2013, 13:28
midway78224 midway78224 is offline
Registered User
AKA: Rudy
FRC #5572 (Rosbots)
Team Role: Mentor
 
Join Date: Apr 2007
Rookie Year: 2004
Location: San Antonio, Texas
Posts: 240
midway78224 is a splendid one to beholdmidway78224 is a splendid one to beholdmidway78224 is a splendid one to beholdmidway78224 is a splendid one to beholdmidway78224 is a splendid one to beholdmidway78224 is a splendid one to beholdmidway78224 is a splendid one to behold
Send a message via Yahoo to midway78224
Re: Speed Controllers: Which is best?

For my team we use jags on our practice bot and talons on our competition bot. The first thing we notice was the big difference in the speed of the drivetrain. Then we notice the difference in the flywheel. We ran the same set up on both drivetrain and flywheel just with different speed controllers. On our flywheel with talons we would hit dead center in the 3 pointers but with jags we notice a ft drop in height of shot.

So.... for us we will stick with the talons from now on.
__________________
[size="1"]
2004-2008 '11 457 Greasemonkeys
2012-2013 3997 Screaming Chickens
2014 3614 The Love Machine
2015-Present Rosbots
  #4   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 19-03-2013, 13:44
Jon Stratis's Avatar
Jon Stratis Jon Stratis is offline
Mentor, LRI, MN RPC
FRC #2177 (The Robettes)
Team Role: Mentor
 
Join Date: Feb 2007
Rookie Year: 2006
Location: Minnesota
Posts: 3,835
Jon Stratis has a reputation beyond reputeJon Stratis has a reputation beyond reputeJon Stratis has a reputation beyond reputeJon Stratis has a reputation beyond reputeJon Stratis has a reputation beyond reputeJon Stratis has a reputation beyond reputeJon Stratis has a reputation beyond reputeJon Stratis has a reputation beyond reputeJon Stratis has a reputation beyond reputeJon Stratis has a reputation beyond reputeJon Stratis has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Speed Controllers: Which is best?

This is a very difficult question to answer, and there really is no "right" answer. Some pro's and cons of each way we have to control a motor:

- Spike: Good for low-current (less than 20A) motors that just need on/off control. Small footprint and the fact that many teams have a dozen of them laying around from previous year's kit of parts make them popular.

- Victor 884: These have been around forever, and many teams have a ton of them as a result. While they provide variable speed control, the result is the least-linear option available. This has caused many teams to move away from using them for the drive train, or situations that require precise, varied speed control. They've seen a lot of abuse, and have held up well over many years.

- Victor 888: This is brand new this year, has the same footprint as the 884, and provides a much more linear response. Due to their newness, we don't have much experience with them.

- Jaguar: These have been around for a few years. They offer some enhanced features with the use of CAN (encoder/potentiometer inputs, limit switch inputs, feedback from the controller concerning the amount of current draw, etc) that teams have made great use of, although these features can all be had with some extra programming or sensor effort if you're using other controllers. They have the biggest footprint, which isn't the best. Some teams (like mine) haven't had any reliability issues with them over 4 years, while others have complained about them and sworn them off.

- Talon: Also brand new this year, they don't have much run time. They offer a completely enclosed controller, which should help prevent damage from metal shavings. The heat sink on them allows you to run them without fans, although fan use is recommended for high-current situations (like the drive train). They have a footprint similar to the Victors.

We used all Talons this year, and absolutely love them. We only had 1 burn out, and that was due to someone accidentally powering it backwards (fed 12V from a battery into the output terminals), which would kill any of the speed controllers. We have fans on all of them as a precaution against burning any out, although we probably only need them on the drive train. The small footprint allowed us to fit twice as many on our board as we could have with Jaguars, which was a necessity due to space constraints in our design.
__________________
2007 - Present: Mentor, 2177 The Robettes
LRI: North Star 2012-2016; Lake Superior 2013-2014; MN State Tournament 2013-2014, 2016; Galileo 2016; Iowa 2017
2015: North Star Regional Volunteer of the Year
2016: Lake Superior WFFA
  #5   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 19-03-2013, 13:50
Ether's Avatar
Ether Ether is offline
systems engineer (retired)
no team
 
Join Date: Nov 2009
Rookie Year: 1969
Location: US
Posts: 8,125
Ether has a reputation beyond reputeEther has a reputation beyond reputeEther has a reputation beyond reputeEther has a reputation beyond reputeEther has a reputation beyond reputeEther has a reputation beyond reputeEther has a reputation beyond reputeEther has a reputation beyond reputeEther has a reputation beyond reputeEther has a reputation beyond reputeEther has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Speed Controllers: Which is best?

Quote:
Originally Posted by midway78224 View Post
For my team we use jags on our practice bot and talons on our competition bot. The first thing we notice was the big difference in the speed of the drivetrain.
Anyone care to comment on what might be the cause of this?


  #6   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 19-03-2013, 13:57
Chris is me's Avatar
Chris is me Chris is me is offline
no bag, vex only, final destination
AKA: Pinecone
FRC #0228 (GUS Robotics); FRC #2170 (Titanium Tomahawks)
Team Role: Mentor
 
Join Date: Dec 2008
Rookie Year: 2006
Location: Glastonbury, CT
Posts: 7,786
Chris is me has a reputation beyond reputeChris is me has a reputation beyond reputeChris is me has a reputation beyond reputeChris is me has a reputation beyond reputeChris is me has a reputation beyond reputeChris is me has a reputation beyond reputeChris is me has a reputation beyond reputeChris is me has a reputation beyond reputeChris is me has a reputation beyond reputeChris is me has a reputation beyond reputeChris is me has a reputation beyond repute
Send a message via AIM to Chris is me
Re: Speed Controllers: Which is best?

All I can really speak to are Victors - the Victor 888 is everything the Victor 884 was, with linearity. It is just as reliable under extreme conditions. We used 888s on our drive this year and enjoyed the greater low speed controllability and general "smoothness", moreso than other years with the 884. If you're using PWM, they are certainly a worthy choice.
__________________
Mentor / Drive Coach: 228 (2016-?)
--2016 Waterbury SFs (with 3314, 3719), RIDE #2 Seed / Winners (with 1058, 6153), Carver QFs (with 503, 359, 4607)
Mentor / Consultant Person: 2170 (2017-?)
.
College Mentor: 2791 (2010-2015)
-- 2015 TVR Motorola Quality, FLR GM Industrial Design -- 2014 FLR Motorola Quality / SFs (with 341, 4930)
-- 2013 BAE Motorola Quality, WPI Regional #1 Seed / Delphi Excellence in Engineering / Finalists (with 20, 3182)
-- 2012 BAE Imagery / Finalists (with 1519, 885), CT Xerox Creativity / SFs (with 2168, 118)
Student: 1714 (2009) - 2009 MN 10K Lakes Regional Winners (with 2826, 2470)
2791 Build Season Photo Gallery - Look here for mechanism photos My Robotics Blog (Updated April 11 2014)
  #7   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 19-03-2013, 13:58
Racer26 Racer26 is offline
Registered User
no team
Team Role: Alumni
 
Join Date: Apr 2003
Rookie Year: 2003
Location: Beaverton, ON
Posts: 2,229
Racer26 has a reputation beyond reputeRacer26 has a reputation beyond reputeRacer26 has a reputation beyond reputeRacer26 has a reputation beyond reputeRacer26 has a reputation beyond reputeRacer26 has a reputation beyond reputeRacer26 has a reputation beyond reputeRacer26 has a reputation beyond reputeRacer26 has a reputation beyond reputeRacer26 has a reputation beyond reputeRacer26 has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Speed Controllers: Which is best?

If I had to guess, my money would be on differences in calibration between the controllers used.
  #8   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 19-03-2013, 14:00
coalhot's Avatar
coalhot coalhot is offline
Assistant to the regional manager
AKA: Phil
FRC #4454 (Artisan Rockets)
Team Role: Mentor
 
Join Date: Jan 2008
Rookie Year: 2007
Location: Philadelphia
Posts: 393
coalhot has a brilliant futurecoalhot has a brilliant futurecoalhot has a brilliant futurecoalhot has a brilliant futurecoalhot has a brilliant futurecoalhot has a brilliant futurecoalhot has a brilliant futurecoalhot has a brilliant futurecoalhot has a brilliant futurecoalhot has a brilliant futurecoalhot has a brilliant future
Send a message via AIM to coalhot
Re: Speed Controllers: Which is best?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Jon Stratis View Post
- Talon: Also brand new this year, they don't have much run time. They offer a completely enclosed controller, which should help prevent damage from metal shavings. The heat sink on them allows you to run them without fans, although fan use is recommended for high-current situations (like the drive train). They have a footprint similar to the Victors.
We are using talons for the drivetrain of our robot, and haven't had any issues yet (fingers crossed). We've vacuumed a lot of metal shavings and haven't had any problems at all. No fans either.
__________________
Current home, 4454 (Glowa's ghetto Philly FRC team). Check us out!

My posts represent my personal views only, and do not represent the views of my team, its school, sponsors, or FIRST.
  #9   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 19-03-2013, 14:14
Teamcodeorange's Avatar
Teamcodeorange Teamcodeorange is offline
Registered User
FRC #3476
 
Join Date: Jan 2011
Location: US
Posts: 236
Teamcodeorange has a brilliant futureTeamcodeorange has a brilliant futureTeamcodeorange has a brilliant futureTeamcodeorange has a brilliant futureTeamcodeorange has a brilliant futureTeamcodeorange has a brilliant futureTeamcodeorange has a brilliant futureTeamcodeorange has a brilliant futureTeamcodeorange has a brilliant futureTeamcodeorange has a brilliant futureTeamcodeorange has a brilliant future
Re: Speed Controllers: Which is best?

Quote:
Originally Posted by mcarobotics View Post
Our team's robot uses Victors exclusively as our speed controllers because they are smallest and cheaper than Jaguars and Talons.
However, I have seen many teams using Jaguars and Talons a lot instead of Victors. I have seen some people use Spikes a lot as well.
Which type of speed controller works best and why? Which is the best quality/most durable? Which one does your team use the most?
I'm trying to decide if our team should switch next year or stick with Victors.
Thanks!
We use Talons and love them. No problems whatsoever. Believe it or not the Talons are even smaller than the Victors.
__________________
Try Code Orange's electronics tutorials!
---------------------------------------------------------
2015 - Tesla Division Champions
2015 - Inland Empire Engineering Inspiration Award
2015 - San Diego Regional Chairman's Award
2014 - San Diego Regional Chairman's Award
2013 - Newton Division Champions
2012 - San Diego Regional Winners
  #10   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 19-03-2013, 14:41
mhos1997's Avatar
mhos1997 mhos1997 is offline
Registered User
AKA: Mohammed Hossain
FRC #1796 (RoboTigers)
Team Role: Mentor
 
Join Date: Apr 2012
Rookie Year: 2012
Location: United States
Posts: 39
mhos1997 is an unknown quantity at this point
Send a message via ICQ to mhos1997 Send a message via AIM to mhos1997
Re: Speed Controllers: Which is best?

My team uses jaguars for our drive train we vary the other speed controls depending on the motor that we use. We also use the spike specifically for our compressor to control our pneumatics.
  #11   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 19-03-2013, 15:01
kuraikou's Avatar
kuraikou kuraikou is offline
Registered User
AKA: Alex
FRC #4183 (Bit Buckets)
Team Role: Alumni
 
Join Date: Nov 2012
Rookie Year: 2013
Location: Tucson, Arizona
Posts: 73
kuraikou is an unknown quantity at this point
Re: Speed Controllers: Which is best?

I know that my team uses talons for our drive train because they are linear and the drive train usually is what other things are getting attached to and so it helps that they are closed instead of susceptible to things getting in them.
  #12   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 19-03-2013, 15:51
Trent B Trent B is offline
College Mentor
AKA: Trent Borman
no team (Surviving Grad School)
Team Role: Alumni
 
Join Date: Dec 2008
Rookie Year: 2008
Location: Ames, IA
Posts: 479
Trent B is a splendid one to beholdTrent B is a splendid one to beholdTrent B is a splendid one to beholdTrent B is a splendid one to beholdTrent B is a splendid one to beholdTrent B is a splendid one to beholdTrent B is a splendid one to beholdTrent B is a splendid one to behold
Send a message via AIM to Trent B Send a message via Yahoo to Trent B
Re: Speed Controllers: Which is best?

Neutrino used Victor 888's this year, pretty similar to your standard old 884, reliable as long as you don't get metal shavings near them.

Unfortunately we blew a MOSFET on one during the finals at Greater Kansas City (not sure if it was metal shavings or something else), resulting in us calling in a backup to avoid getting DQed.
__________________
Former 2502 (Talon) Captain and 3928 (Neutrino) Mentor, currently teamless and attending Penn State for graduate school.
Have questions about Iowa State University or Penn State University? Feel free to email or PM me
  #13   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 19-03-2013, 16:19
Racer26 Racer26 is offline
Registered User
no team
Team Role: Alumni
 
Join Date: Apr 2003
Rookie Year: 2003
Location: Beaverton, ON
Posts: 2,229
Racer26 has a reputation beyond reputeRacer26 has a reputation beyond reputeRacer26 has a reputation beyond reputeRacer26 has a reputation beyond reputeRacer26 has a reputation beyond reputeRacer26 has a reputation beyond reputeRacer26 has a reputation beyond reputeRacer26 has a reputation beyond reputeRacer26 has a reputation beyond reputeRacer26 has a reputation beyond reputeRacer26 has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Speed Controllers: Which is best?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Trent B View Post
Neutrino used Victor 888's this year, pretty similar to your standard old 884, reliable as long as you don't get metal shavings near them.

Unfortunately we blew a MOSFET on one during the finals at Greater Kansas City (not sure if it was metal shavings or something else), resulting in us calling in a backup to avoid getting DQed.
Why would you get DQd? Changing a Victor is allowed without reinspection, as it is just replacing a failed part. Calling a backup over a blown Victor is a fairly drastic measure, IMO.
  #14   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 19-03-2013, 16:21
Trent B Trent B is offline
College Mentor
AKA: Trent Borman
no team (Surviving Grad School)
Team Role: Alumni
 
Join Date: Dec 2008
Rookie Year: 2008
Location: Ames, IA
Posts: 479
Trent B is a splendid one to beholdTrent B is a splendid one to beholdTrent B is a splendid one to beholdTrent B is a splendid one to beholdTrent B is a splendid one to beholdTrent B is a splendid one to beholdTrent B is a splendid one to beholdTrent B is a splendid one to behold
Send a message via AIM to Trent B Send a message via Yahoo to Trent B
Re: Speed Controllers: Which is best?

Weren't able to get it changed fast enough, and timeout was already used, so it was either get DQed for not keeping up with time, or call in backup.

Had to run back to pits to track one down. Needless to say, I plan to have a spare victor on the cart at North Star.
__________________
Former 2502 (Talon) Captain and 3928 (Neutrino) Mentor, currently teamless and attending Penn State for graduate school.
Have questions about Iowa State University or Penn State University? Feel free to email or PM me
  #15   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 19-03-2013, 16:27
Thad House Thad House is offline
Volunteer, WPILib Contributor
no team (Waiting for 2021)
Team Role: Mentor
 
Join Date: Feb 2011
Rookie Year: 2010
Location: Thousand Oaks, California
Posts: 1,107
Thad House has a reputation beyond reputeThad House has a reputation beyond reputeThad House has a reputation beyond reputeThad House has a reputation beyond reputeThad House has a reputation beyond reputeThad House has a reputation beyond reputeThad House has a reputation beyond reputeThad House has a reputation beyond reputeThad House has a reputation beyond reputeThad House has a reputation beyond reputeThad House has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Speed Controllers: Which is best?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Trent B View Post
Weren't able to get it changed fast enough, and timeout was already used, so it was either get DQed for not keeping up with time, or call in backup.

Had to run back to pits to track one down. Needless to say, I plan to have a spare victor on the cart at North Star.
If you have room and weight, you can always mount the spare victor on the robot itself, so if it ever happens again you just switch the output and PWM to the spare one and you are up and running again. We did that in 2011 and it saved us during the Finals.
__________________
All statements made are my own and not the feelings of any of my affiliated teams.
Teams 1510 and 2898 - Student 2010-2012
Team 4488 - Mentor 2013-2016
Co-developer of RobotDotNet, a .NET port of the WPILib.
Closed Thread


Thread Tools
Display Modes Rate This Thread
Rate This Thread:

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Forum Jump


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 20:20.

The Chief Delphi Forums are sponsored by Innovation First International, Inc.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © Chief Delphi