pic: Who should have gotten the foul? part 1

[savage]

If a bot has at least one way of egress from a possible pin, like in this match that your complaint is about then there should be no pin called or blockading. As 3284 sole role in the match was to block the shooter. Now my .02 i think the GDC needs to change the max height rule for when you are on one side of the field or the other. They have done it in the past I just cant remember at this time.

And for the last time NO Instant REPLAY EVER!!!!!!!!!! Most events run late as it is, and this is why we have 5-6 REFS on the Field at one time, to cover all the zones. Yes they miss calls but so does the NFL and they have replay.

But Back to the match on hand, the Red Alliance should have seen this coming and changed their game plan. They got Tunnel Vision and missed the other two bots scoring undefended, which was a huge mistake and cost them the match.

[Zakreon]

You're pretty well spot on there Todd. Red received a technical foul for blocking our team from returning to the autonomous zone, and we received a regular foul for moving out of the zone before our net could lower. There were also 2 separate fouls on red for contacting the blue pyramid.

1288 also had a great shooter, but it was broken in this match, they couldn't shoot. 1706 was their only viable offensive bot, it actually does make sense that both 1288 and 1444 would be trying to push us out of the way to let 1706 score.

[ToddF]

I saw two touches of the pyramid, one at 1:30 and one at 1:35. I reviewed the rule for pyramid touches:

G27
ROBOTS may not contact or otherwise interfere with their opponents’ PYRAMID. Inconsequential contact will not be penalized.

For the first touch, the only robot touching the blue pyramid was the red robot, so the contact was inconsequential. For the second touch, a blue robot lined up on an opposite corner to shoot while the red robot was still touching. I ruled this as also inconsequential.

At 2:02, at first it looked like red might have touched while blue was hanging, but I could see a white disk on the ground between the red robot and the pyramid, so no touch.

[Zakreon]

Those may have been unwarranted, but I do believe that they received fouls for the contact.

[ericbanker]

Originally Posted by Zakreon

1288 also had a great shooter, but it was broken in this match, they couldn't shoot. 1706 was their only viable offensive bot, it actually does make sense that both 1288 and 1444 would be trying to push us out of the way to let 1706 score.

1288's shooter was broken? So that's why they were forced to play defense. Does anyone know when and how that happened? 1288 had a really great robot, their shooter was a bit better than ours, and what I believe was a sideways turned holonomic/mecanum drive was really innovative.

Edit: I just rewatched the matches and they were shooting fine in the 1st finals match. They must have gotten damaged from the impacts by defenders in that match...but then they score a buzzer beater into the 3 point goal. So I'm still lost on what happened. In match 2, their autonomous fails to launch discs, and you can hear it clicking.

[bulbajackel]

Originally Posted by ericbanker

1288's shooter was broken? So that's why they were forced to play defense. Does anyone know when and how that happened? 1288 had a really great robot, their shooter was a bit better than ours, and what I believe was a sideways turned holonomic/mecanum drive was really innovative.

Edit: I just rewatched the matches and they were shooting fine in the 1st finals match. They must have gotten damaged from the impacts by defenders in that match...but then they score a buzzer beater into the 3 point goal. So I'm still lost on what happened. In match 2, their autonomous fails to launch discs, and you can hear it clicking.

It happened somewhere where the robot just didn't respond to the field i believe. I don't know the specifics, but whatever happened there almost changed things. Didn't they start looking for a replacement?

[Zakreon]

A teammate told me that their cam that raises the shooter broke in some way, so the shooter could not properly move into position to fire