Methods of shifting gears

[Tristan Lall]

The one you see most often nowadays is dog shifting: the dog gear is (with the teeth on the side face) engages a recess on one of two output gears. I've built one of these with 188; it worked great. I've also bought these off the shelf.

Captive-ball shifting is once again popular, with the release of VexPro's kit. Previously, 222 used this design. Here, balls are displaced in and out of recesses in the central shaft, to engage gears with slots in their bores.

You used to see axial-engagement ("crash") shifting more often. There, the gear teeth themselves slide in and out of mesh. I'm not a huge fan of this, but implemented with fairly large gear teeth, it works fine.

Rarely, you see tangential-engagement shifting. I tried it once with 188 and it didn't work properly (the gears wouldn't stay in mesh). However, knowing what I know now, I think I could probably make it work. However, I don't see any particular advantage to doing so.

You also used to see planetary shifters more often, when the Nothing But DeWalts modification was popular. (A DeWalt XRP drill transmission, shifted with a servo by sliding the device that locks and unlocks its planetary gearsets.) I've implemented this, again with 188, with two CIMs feeding a single DeWalt. Everything worked reasonably well, except the custom output shaft. (It needed to be hardened alloy steel, not hot-rolled free-machining steel.)