Possible Implementation of Instant Replay

[pyroslev]

*Hands you Pandora's box*

There have been more than a few times I myself would like to have seen a replay on a dicey ruling. But there are many concerns. Having it just for the Elims would be problematic.

1. Match play varies a great deal between Qualifications and Eliminations.
2. Elims last 6 hours or less.
3. Takes up space on the field/truck where it is at a premium.
4. Has to be maintained so it doesn't crash.
5. Finding persons neutral enough to operate it.
6. Challenges already take up a lot of time.
7. Lessons are lost by teams not learning how to argue their case.
8. Costing a team a valuable time out is problematic.

The short answer is that while it is a great notion, I cannot support it.