Silicon Valley Regional 2014

[billbo911]

I haven't seen anyone post the rules related to this situation. So, without further comment, let's start there:

T20
If during a TIMEOUT an ALLIANCE CAPTAIN determines that they need to call up a BACKUP TEAM, they must submit their BACKUP TEAM coupon to the Head Referee while there are still at least two (2) minutes remaining on the ARENA Timer. After that point, they will not be allowed to utilize the BACKUP TEAM.

Alternatively, an ALLIANCE CAPTAIN may choose to call up a BACKUP TEAM without using their TIMEOUT by informing the Head Referee directly within two (2) minutes of the Head Referee issuing the ARENA reset signal preceding their MATCH.

In the case where the ALLIANCE CAPTAIN’S ROBOT is replaced by a BACKUP TEAM, the ALLIANCE CAPTAIN is allowed in the ALLIANCE STATION as a thirteenth ALLIANCE member so they can serve in an advisory role to their ALLIANCE.

The BOLD and BOLD UNDERLINE are mine.

Now for my comments based entirely on my opinion. I watched the webcast and was not in attendance. I know Mark and must admit, I trust his judgement whether I agree with it or not.

Based on the quoted rule, I believe Mark had no choice, he had to make the call that he did. No where in the rule does it say that the Captain needs to verbally request a substitute. It is based entirely on the coupon presented. As to which team needs to be replaced, that must be a verbal communication. So, obviously we are missing some information as to why Madtown was substituted out. I can only assume it was due to a verbal communication error. Again, that is my assumption based on comments in this thread.