Go to Post The FIRST World has your back. - MishraArtificer [more]
Home
Go Back   Chief Delphi > FIRST > General Forum
CD-Media   CD-Spy  
portal register members calendar search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read FAQ rules

 
Reply
Thread Tools Rating: Thread Rating: 18 votes, 5.00 average. Display Modes
  #46   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 09-04-2014, 13:55
Alan Anderson's Avatar
Alan Anderson Alan Anderson is offline
Software Architect
FRC #0045 (TechnoKats)
Team Role: Mentor
 
Join Date: Feb 2004
Rookie Year: 2004
Location: Kokomo, Indiana
Posts: 9,113
Alan Anderson has a reputation beyond reputeAlan Anderson has a reputation beyond reputeAlan Anderson has a reputation beyond reputeAlan Anderson has a reputation beyond reputeAlan Anderson has a reputation beyond reputeAlan Anderson has a reputation beyond reputeAlan Anderson has a reputation beyond reputeAlan Anderson has a reputation beyond reputeAlan Anderson has a reputation beyond reputeAlan Anderson has a reputation beyond reputeAlan Anderson has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Swerve Drive vs Mecanum Wheel drive?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Citrus Dad View Post
From a scouting perspective, we heavily discount robots with mecanum drive because they don't have the same defensive abilities as tank drive.
Prejudice like that shouldn't be part of scouting. I think the appropriate thing would be to make your assessment based on what each robot actually does, and how well, rather than what you think its design is capable of.
Reply With Quote
  #47   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 09-04-2014, 13:58
Monochron's Avatar
Monochron Monochron is offline
Engineering Mentor
AKA: Brian O'Sullivan
FRC #4561 (TerrorBytes)
Team Role: Engineer
 
Join Date: Feb 2007
Rookie Year: 2002
Location: Research Triangle Park, NC
Posts: 910
Monochron has a reputation beyond reputeMonochron has a reputation beyond reputeMonochron has a reputation beyond reputeMonochron has a reputation beyond reputeMonochron has a reputation beyond reputeMonochron has a reputation beyond reputeMonochron has a reputation beyond reputeMonochron has a reputation beyond reputeMonochron has a reputation beyond reputeMonochron has a reputation beyond reputeMonochron has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Swerve Drive vs Mecanum Wheel drive?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Citrus Dad View Post
From a scouting perspective, we heavily discount robots with mecanum drive because they don't have the same defensive abilities as tank drive. To be honest, we haven't see a high-scoring mecanum drive robot, even at Worlds, so I don't have an opinion about the use there.
This is an incorrect assessment of mecanum wheels. See the RoboBees this year:
https://www.youtube.com/user/TheHive836

They were easily the top performing robot at the NC Regional, had the highest OPR by nearly 20 points, and missed out on taking the whole thing due solely to a Tech foul that their alliance got in the last match of finals. Yes, there were absolutely robots out there with more pushing power, but letting another team snatch up the robobees in selections would be a bad idea.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A3dKBW8dbOI

Last edited by Monochron : 09-04-2014 at 14:12.
Reply With Quote
  #48   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 09-04-2014, 14:02
Keegbot's Avatar
Keegbot Keegbot is offline
Registered User
AKA: Keegan McCrary
FRC #2438 (Beta Blues)
Team Role: College Student
 
Join Date: Jan 2014
Rookie Year: 2012
Location: Honolulu, Hawaii
Posts: 40
Keegbot is an unknown quantity at this point
Re: Swerve Drive vs Mecanum Wheel drive?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Citrus Dad View Post
From a scouting perspective, we heavily discount robots with mecanum drive because they don't have the same defensive abilities as tank drive. To be honest, we haven't see a high-scoring mecanum drive robot, even at Worlds, so I don't have an opinion about the use there.
Mecanum can play defense, but it is a different style than defense with tank. While tank can dish out hits and stop an opponent in their tracks, mecanum can maneuver around the opponent and get in their way when when they shoot or try to pick up the ball. I know mecanum can play defense because I have done it.

As for the high-scoring part, I think that has more to do with type of shooter and intake that the robot has, not the drive.
__________________
2012-15: Team 2438 'Iobotics - driver, build team
2016: Team 5975 Beta Blues - college mentor
Reply With Quote
  #49   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 09-04-2014, 15:38
Tyler2517's Avatar
Tyler2517 Tyler2517 is offline
ShortOnes
AKA: Tyler Gibb
FRC #2517 (Evergreen Robotics)
Team Role: Mentor
 
Join Date: Dec 2013
Rookie Year: 2011
Location: Vancouver, WA
Posts: 203
Tyler2517 has a spectacular aura aboutTyler2517 has a spectacular aura aboutTyler2517 has a spectacular aura about
Re: Swerve Drive vs Mecanum Wheel drive?

On the other side swerve drives can play some really mean defense too. The ability to lock your wheels in to a X or O. This way you cant get pushed but maintain a very high gear ratio. We played some mean defense by just out maneuvering robots and out running them then locking the wheels and that's a nice 1/2-1 foot a second across the field no matter how much pushing power you got.
Reply With Quote
  #50   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 09-04-2014, 15:51
Abhishek R Abhishek R is offline
Registered User
FRC #0624
Team Role: Alumni
 
Join Date: Mar 2013
Rookie Year: 2012
Location: Texas
Posts: 892
Abhishek R has a reputation beyond reputeAbhishek R has a reputation beyond reputeAbhishek R has a reputation beyond reputeAbhishek R has a reputation beyond reputeAbhishek R has a reputation beyond reputeAbhishek R has a reputation beyond reputeAbhishek R has a reputation beyond reputeAbhishek R has a reputation beyond reputeAbhishek R has a reputation beyond reputeAbhishek R has a reputation beyond reputeAbhishek R has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Swerve Drive vs Mecanum Wheel drive?

In my opinion only, I feel there will always be exceptions, but mecanum just doesn't have any appealing aspects. Whenever I see a competitive team with mecanum I just wonder what they could have done with tank, butterfly/nonadrive (I've heard this is called TexCoast Drive now...) or swerve. The idea of using rollers on wheels is very unappealing to me.
__________________
2012 - 2015 : 624 CRyptonite
Team Website
Reply With Quote
  #51   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 09-04-2014, 15:57
Tyler2517's Avatar
Tyler2517 Tyler2517 is offline
ShortOnes
AKA: Tyler Gibb
FRC #2517 (Evergreen Robotics)
Team Role: Mentor
 
Join Date: Dec 2013
Rookie Year: 2011
Location: Vancouver, WA
Posts: 203
Tyler2517 has a spectacular aura aboutTyler2517 has a spectacular aura aboutTyler2517 has a spectacular aura about
Re: Swerve Drive vs Mecanum Wheel drive?

I think that a drive should be chosen for what it's robots goal is. Yes you can push a mecanum drive. But a good mecanum driver would not be being pushed for to long.
On a different note mecanum is much funner to enplane with people then a tank drive is. Cool maths and some programming a a long talk on vector math beats explaining a tank drive. At least for marketing stuff.
Reply With Quote
  #52   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 09-04-2014, 16:32
Joe Ross's Avatar Unsung FIRST Hero
Joe Ross Joe Ross is offline
Registered User
FRC #0330 (Beachbots)
Team Role: Engineer
 
Join Date: Jun 2001
Rookie Year: 1997
Location: Los Angeles, CA
Posts: 8,574
Joe Ross has a reputation beyond reputeJoe Ross has a reputation beyond reputeJoe Ross has a reputation beyond reputeJoe Ross has a reputation beyond reputeJoe Ross has a reputation beyond reputeJoe Ross has a reputation beyond reputeJoe Ross has a reputation beyond reputeJoe Ross has a reputation beyond reputeJoe Ross has a reputation beyond reputeJoe Ross has a reputation beyond reputeJoe Ross has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Swerve Drive vs Mecanum Wheel drive?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Alan Anderson View Post
Prejudice like that shouldn't be part of scouting. I think the appropriate thing would be to make your assessment based on what each robot actually does, and how well, rather than what you think its design is capable of.
I think 1678 probably has the scouting thing figured out pretty well. They won Curie last year, after 4 teams declined them.

While I wouldn't recommend going beyond objective evidence for most teams, it's clear that additional information in the hands of informed individuals can make for better decisions. If a team passes over picking a awesome robot with mecanum drive, it's their potential loss.

Last edited by Joe Ross : 09-04-2014 at 16:36.
Reply With Quote
  #53   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 09-04-2014, 16:57
Joe Ross's Avatar Unsung FIRST Hero
Joe Ross Joe Ross is offline
Registered User
FRC #0330 (Beachbots)
Team Role: Engineer
 
Join Date: Jun 2001
Rookie Year: 1997
Location: Los Angeles, CA
Posts: 8,574
Joe Ross has a reputation beyond reputeJoe Ross has a reputation beyond reputeJoe Ross has a reputation beyond reputeJoe Ross has a reputation beyond reputeJoe Ross has a reputation beyond reputeJoe Ross has a reputation beyond reputeJoe Ross has a reputation beyond reputeJoe Ross has a reputation beyond reputeJoe Ross has a reputation beyond reputeJoe Ross has a reputation beyond reputeJoe Ross has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Swerve Drive vs Mecanum Wheel drive?

Quote:
Originally Posted by ekapalka View Post
I've been tentatively skimming through this code for around half an hour and can't seem to find where the magic happens... I'm not particularly accustomed to the command based model Could someone point me in the right direction? Thanks!
src/org/usfirst/frc2084/CMonster2014/commands/FieldCentricMecanumDriveCommand.java
Reply With Quote
  #54   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 09-04-2014, 22:07
EDesbiens's Avatar
EDesbiens EDesbiens is offline
Passionate crackpot
AKA: Étienne Desbiens
FRC #5859 (i)
Team Role: College Student
 
Join Date: Apr 2014
Rookie Year: 2013
Location: Canton de Hatley, QC, Canada
Posts: 297
EDesbiens is a glorious beacon of lightEDesbiens is a glorious beacon of lightEDesbiens is a glorious beacon of lightEDesbiens is a glorious beacon of lightEDesbiens is a glorious beacon of lightEDesbiens is a glorious beacon of light
Re: Swerve Drive vs Mecanum Wheel drive?

I think its all about the drivers... I never drove a robot on swerves but I know how mecanums feel... If you are able to drive correctly, you don't need power. You only need to know your robot and how to counter the other team.

It's all about strategy and logic, it's not material...
Reply With Quote
  #55   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 10-04-2014, 01:10
Michael Corsetto's Avatar
Michael Corsetto Michael Corsetto is offline
Breathe in... Breathe out...
FRC #1678 (Citrus Circuits)
Team Role: Mentor
 
Join Date: May 2004
Rookie Year: 2002
Location: Davis, CA
Posts: 1,132
Michael Corsetto has a reputation beyond reputeMichael Corsetto has a reputation beyond reputeMichael Corsetto has a reputation beyond reputeMichael Corsetto has a reputation beyond reputeMichael Corsetto has a reputation beyond reputeMichael Corsetto has a reputation beyond reputeMichael Corsetto has a reputation beyond reputeMichael Corsetto has a reputation beyond reputeMichael Corsetto has a reputation beyond reputeMichael Corsetto has a reputation beyond reputeMichael Corsetto has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Swerve Drive vs Mecanum Wheel drive?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Joe Ross View Post
I think 1678 probably has the scouting thing figured out pretty well. They won Curie last year, after 4 teams declined them.
Thanks Joe.

Obviously, there will always be good robots with a whole spectrum of drivetrain configurations (great example is 1425 this year, what a machine!)

In many cases, selecting a first pick robot is a straightforward offensive scouting exercise. Keep in mind, we picked 368 at SVR, a fantastic offensive machine, which also happened to feature one of the meanest swerve drives I've ever seen. Seriously, check it out at Champs, it may surprise you to see how many COTS components play a key role in that design.

However, our second pick preferences are very specific, and mecanum does not fit our desired robot configuration for our second pick. This is obviously our team bias, and is shaped by how we want to build our alliance, but it is a guideline we have followed with decent success over the past few years.

I won't say mecanum robots aren't good, because that's not true, there are plenty of great robots with mecanum drivetrains. However, they probably won't make our 2nd pick list.

But that's just us, we're still figuring this whole scouting thing out. I'd like to think we're making progress, but there's still so much we can be doing better!

-Mike
__________________
Team 1678: Citrus Circuits - Lead Technical Mentor, Drive Coach **Like Us On Facebook!**
Reply With Quote
  #56   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 10-04-2014, 01:32
Chadfrom308's Avatar
Chadfrom308 Chadfrom308 is offline
Slave to the bot
AKA: Chad Krause
FRC #0308 (The Monsters)
Team Role: Driver
 
Join Date: Jan 2013
Rookie Year: 2011
Location: Novi
Posts: 272
Chadfrom308 is a splendid one to beholdChadfrom308 is a splendid one to beholdChadfrom308 is a splendid one to beholdChadfrom308 is a splendid one to beholdChadfrom308 is a splendid one to beholdChadfrom308 is a splendid one to beholdChadfrom308 is a splendid one to behold
Re: Swerve Drive vs Mecanum Wheel drive?

For defense, I say we are no slouch this year.

Yes we do have mecanums, but as said above, its a different style of defense. It is turning and ramming that will get the opponent annoyed. We have played defense quite effectively, even against tank. We can normally stop tanks in their track when we go up against them. I have played better defense than some teams do with the kit of parts.

Defense is not about drive train, it's about the driver skill
Reply With Quote
  #57   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 10-04-2014, 03:05
Keegbot's Avatar
Keegbot Keegbot is offline
Registered User
AKA: Keegan McCrary
FRC #2438 (Beta Blues)
Team Role: College Student
 
Join Date: Jan 2014
Rookie Year: 2012
Location: Honolulu, Hawaii
Posts: 40
Keegbot is an unknown quantity at this point
Re: Swerve Drive vs Mecanum Wheel drive?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Chadfrom308 View Post
Defense is not about drive train, it's about the driver skill
I agree. Different drive trains can all play effective defense (the style will vary), but a good driver makes all the difference. If the driver doesn't know how to use his/her drive to the best of its abilities, the robot will be less effective regardless of the type of drive train.
__________________
2012-15: Team 2438 'Iobotics - driver, build team
2016: Team 5975 Beta Blues - college mentor
Reply With Quote
  #58   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 10-04-2014, 10:50
fox46's Avatar
fox46 fox46 is offline
Registered User
FRC #2013 (Cybergnomes)
Team Role: Mentor
 
Join Date: Feb 2003
Rookie Year: 2000
Location: Toronto, ON, Canada
Posts: 400
fox46 has a reputation beyond reputefox46 has a reputation beyond reputefox46 has a reputation beyond reputefox46 has a reputation beyond reputefox46 has a reputation beyond reputefox46 has a reputation beyond reputefox46 has a reputation beyond reputefox46 has a reputation beyond reputefox46 has a reputation beyond reputefox46 has a reputation beyond reputefox46 has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Swerve Drive vs Mecanum Wheel drive?

I like mechanum, Omni and swerve drives- it makes it real easy to bulldoze through them and get to where you want to go on the field!

Keep in mind, this is coming from someone who helped pioneer the design and iteration of several omnidirectional drives back in my days with 854 so it's not that I don't like them, I'm just honest-

Unless you have an awesome driver- preferably one who has experience with RC helicopters, don't even bother with omnidirectional drive unless you're building a practice machine and can allow piles of stick time and endless drills to get their skill level up. Far too many teams build omnidirectional drives and just don't use them to their full capability and if you aren't using them to their full capability then you WILL be outgunned by a skid steer/tank drive.

Secondly, don't even bother with Omni if you aren't using a gyro and accelerometer to take some of the work away from the driver. DC motors always run better in one direction than another and to try and pull off one of these drivetrains without some sort of logic to make sure it is doing what the driver tells it is just setting yourself up for an extremely difficult to drive robot.

Swerve drive- People think that with a swerve drive you have the tractive capabilities of a tank with the maneuverability of Omni- you do not. Each wheel has (at least) one motor. When you start pushing against something, all your weight transfers to your rear wheels leaving your front wheels spinning in the air. Hence, in a shoving match, typically you are only using half your available drive power. Furthermore, the lag time associated with steering your modules is painful. Any lag time slows down your ability to utilize your maneuverability to its maximum advantage and if you don't utilize it to its maximum advantage you WILL be outgunned by a skid steer/tank.
__________________
Mentor, Team 2013 Cybergnomes 2010 - 2014, 2016
Mentor, Team 3756 RamFerno 2011 - 2013
Mentor, Team 854 Iron Bears 2005-2007
Founding member, Team 854 Iron Bears 2000-2005

Mech.Eng.+Mgt University of Ontario 2009
B.Ed OCT Trent University 2015
Professional Education and Product Knowledge Consultant - Toyota Canada Inc.
Reply With Quote
  #59   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 10-04-2014, 13:10
Jefferson Jefferson is offline
Registered User
AKA: Jeff Clements
FRC #0016 (Bomb Squad)
Team Role: Mentor
 
Join Date: Jan 2011
Rookie Year: 2010
Location: Mountain Home, AR
Posts: 258
Jefferson has a reputation beyond reputeJefferson has a reputation beyond reputeJefferson has a reputation beyond reputeJefferson has a reputation beyond reputeJefferson has a reputation beyond reputeJefferson has a reputation beyond reputeJefferson has a reputation beyond reputeJefferson has a reputation beyond reputeJefferson has a reputation beyond reputeJefferson has a reputation beyond reputeJefferson has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Swerve Drive vs Mecanum Wheel drive?

Well... I've successfully avoided this thread until now, but I'm not going to walk away from this one...

Quote:
Originally Posted by fox46 View Post
I like mechanum, Omni and swerve drives- it makes it real easy to bulldoze through them and get to where you want to go on the field!
We've not been buldozed much this season, even by very well built 6 CIM tank drives.

Quote:
Originally Posted by fox46 View Post
Keep in mind, this is coming from someone who helped pioneer the design and iteration of several omnidirectional drives back in my days with 854 so it's not that I don't like them, I'm just honest-
For someone who doesn't not like omnidirectional drives, your post has a very different tone. Everything you say in here is stated as absolutes, and it's just not that clear cut.

Quote:
Originally Posted by fox46 View Post
Unless you have an awesome driver- preferably one who has experience with RC helicopters, don't even bother with omnidirectional drive unless you're building a practice machine and can allow piles of stick time and endless drills to get their skill level up. Far too many teams build omnidirectional drives and just don't use them to their full capability and if you aren't using them to their full capability then you WILL be outgunned by a skid steer/tank drive.
This is true of any drivebase, not just omni drives. A well built drivebase does nothing if the drivers don't have practice time on the sticks.

Quote:
Originally Posted by fox46 View Post
Secondly, don't even bother with Omni if you aren't using a gyro and accelerometer to take some of the work away from the driver. DC motors always run better in one direction than another and to try and pull off one of these drivetrains without some sort of logic to make sure it is doing what the driver tells it is just setting yourself up for an extremely difficult to drive robot.
We've never used an accelerometer in our drive code and only late last year incorporated a gyro into the driver-controlled code. The gyro improved the performance of the robot, not the ease of driving.

Quote:
Originally Posted by fox46 View Post
Swerve drive- People think that with a swerve drive you have the tractive capabilities of a tank with the maneuverability of Omni- you do not. Each wheel has (at least) one motor. When you start pushing against something, all your weight transfers to your rear wheels leaving your front wheels spinning in the air. Hence, in a shoving match, typically you are only using half your available drive power. Furthermore, the lag time associated with steering your modules is painful. Any lag time slows down your ability to utilize your maneuverability to its maximum advantage and if you don't utilize it to its maximum advantage you WILL be outgunned by a skid steer/tank.
Pushing doesn't make the wheels leave the ground, getting under the robot (bumper) does. ANY robot that has weight taken away will have less traction and lack pushing force.
Reply With Quote
  #60   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 10-04-2014, 13:28
Ether's Avatar
Ether Ether is offline
systems engineer (retired)
no team
 
Join Date: Nov 2009
Rookie Year: 1969
Location: US
Posts: 8,097
Ether has a reputation beyond reputeEther has a reputation beyond reputeEther has a reputation beyond reputeEther has a reputation beyond reputeEther has a reputation beyond reputeEther has a reputation beyond reputeEther has a reputation beyond reputeEther has a reputation beyond reputeEther has a reputation beyond reputeEther has a reputation beyond reputeEther has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Swerve Drive vs Mecanum Wheel drive?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Jefferson View Post
Pushing doesn't make the wheels leave the ground
Horizontal pushing "transfers some of the weight" to the rear wheels, even if the front wheels do not leave the ground.

Quote:
ANY robot that has weight taken away will have less traction and lack pushing force.
I believe the point being made was that with a chained drive, all motors on each side are still providing force... And that force will be distributed to the wheels with the greater traction (the rear wheels), once the wheels with the lesser traction (the front wheels) have reached their traction limit.



Last edited by Ether : 10-04-2014 at 13:35.
Reply With Quote
Reply


Thread Tools
Display Modes Rate This Thread
Rate This Thread:

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Forum Jump


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 05:25.

The Chief Delphi Forums are sponsored by Innovation First International, Inc.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © Chief Delphi