Time for a Scouting Award--Eagle Scout???

[MechEng83]

This would be a nightmare to judge. Judges are recruited from the professional world. Often, they have never seen an FRC competition or know what FIRST is prior to walking into the first judges' meeting. When they judge things like machine design, they're drawing on their knowledge base and generally have a good grasp on mechanical/electrical/computer systems. Other judges are recruited for their expertise in things like business planning or social awareness.

IMHO, to judge this would require a panel of judges who are intimately familiar with scouting practices, ranking systems, and how scouting fits in to the competition.

Also, I think the creativity award has been given to teams who have a unique scouting system, as this falls under "strategy." There is also the Judges Award if judges feel the team deserves special recognition for their scouting system.