Our software is compatible, baby.
Home
Go Back   Chief Delphi > Technical > Motors
CD-Media   CD-Spy  
portal register members calendar search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read FAQ rules

 
Closed Thread
Thread Tools Rating: Thread Rating: 5 votes, 5.00 average. Display Modes
  #1   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 12-01-2015, 12:01
1Scouser 1Scouser is offline
Registered User
FRC #3196
 
Join Date: Jan 2015
Location: North Carolina
Posts: 4
1Scouser is an unknown quantity at this point
When is a "motor" a "motor"?

Hi, this is my first year as an electrical mentor with an FRC team. I have been and still am involved with Jr FLL and FLL teams for 5 years so I am a little dazzled by the bright lights and rules of FRC.

My question when is a motor not a motor relates to "window motors". One of the students has found an off the shelf linear actuator that appears to powered by a window motor. I say appears as I have not been able to get a data sheet for it yet, but looking at the photographs it appears to have the same metal motor housing and connector as a window motor.

Rule R18 says "window motor" various - does this define a window motor as the whole assembly with the "end effector / gear chain" that's primary / designed use is for opening and closing windows?

Or is it the actual electrical motor component that could be integrated in to an alternative off the shelf part that is not primarily designed to open and close windows?





I guess the underlying question is - If the electrical specification is the same as the electrical specification of a window motor, would this actuator be legal?


Thanks.

(By searching this forum, you have already answered many of my questions, please keep up the great work)
  #2   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 12-01-2015, 12:06
Whippet's Avatar
Whippet Whippet is offline
MIT Class of 2020
AKA: Luis Trueba
FRC #4301 (New Tech Narcissists)
Team Role: Alumni
 
Join Date: Feb 2011
Rookie Year: 2011
Location: Cambridge, MA
Posts: 1,188
Whippet has a reputation beyond reputeWhippet has a reputation beyond reputeWhippet has a reputation beyond reputeWhippet has a reputation beyond reputeWhippet has a reputation beyond reputeWhippet has a reputation beyond reputeWhippet has a reputation beyond reputeWhippet has a reputation beyond reputeWhippet has a reputation beyond reputeWhippet has a reputation beyond reputeWhippet has a reputation beyond repute
Send a message via Yahoo to Whippet
Re: When is a "motor" a "motor"?

If, when you purchased it, it was labelled as a window motor, then it is a window motor.
__________________
2010: FRC 3043, Build Assistant
2011: FRC 3043, Head of Minibot subteam; FLL 12762, Team Captain
2012: FRC 3043, Electrical; FLL 12762, Team Captain; FTC 5670, Team Captain
2013: FRC 4301, Electrical, Team Co-Captain
2014: FRC 4301, Electrical/Programming, Team Co-Captain
2015: FRC 4301, Electrical/Programming, Team Captain
2016: FRC 4301, Chief Technical Officer; FTC 10860, 10861, and 11004: Mentor. Winner, Hub City Regional (3310 & 4063)
  #3   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 12-01-2015, 12:14
adciv adciv is offline
One Eyed Man
FRC #0836 (RoboBees)
Team Role: Mentor
 
Join Date: Jan 2012
Rookie Year: 2010
Location: Southern Maryland
Posts: 478
adciv is a name known to alladciv is a name known to alladciv is a name known to alladciv is a name known to alladciv is a name known to alladciv is a name known to all
Re: When is a "motor" a "motor"?

I don't suppose you could share the part number and source of that wonderful product with us?
__________________
Quote:
Originally Posted by texarkana View Post
I would not want the task of devising a system that 50,000 very smart people try to outwit.
  #4   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 12-01-2015, 12:14
MrForbes's Avatar
MrForbes MrForbes is offline
Registered User
AKA: Jim
FRC #1726 (N.E.R.D.S.)
Team Role: Mentor
 
Join Date: Feb 2006
Rookie Year: 2006
Location: Sierra Vista AZ
Posts: 6,045
MrForbes has a reputation beyond reputeMrForbes has a reputation beyond reputeMrForbes has a reputation beyond reputeMrForbes has a reputation beyond reputeMrForbes has a reputation beyond reputeMrForbes has a reputation beyond reputeMrForbes has a reputation beyond reputeMrForbes has a reputation beyond reputeMrForbes has a reputation beyond reputeMrForbes has a reputation beyond reputeMrForbes has a reputation beyond repute
Re: When is a "motor" a "motor"?

or it could be a Door Motor, Windshield Wiper Motor, or Seat Motor. I like how wide open the rule is, but I'm sure it'll get mucked up because someone will ask "is this motor legal?" on Q&A, and get it ruled illegal.

Since the original intent of the rules restricting motor use seems to have been to make things "fair", by not allowing extra powerful motors, or motors that were not COTS, it appears to me that the nifty little linear actuator motor assembly you found fits the intent of the rules. But you might want to see if there's a way to call it one of the names of motors used in automobiles, listed above. There was a thing a few years ago where FIRST got the auto salvage industry involved, by letting us get free automotive motors from salvage yards (voucher system), and I think it's related somehow.

also, in past years the window motors were treated as an assembly with the gearbox, and could not be modified significantly, and still be legal to use.

For a new mentor, you sure picked a challenging question!
  #5   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 12-01-2015, 12:17
IronicDeadBird's Avatar
IronicDeadBird IronicDeadBird is offline
Theory Crafting Fo days...
AKA: Charles Ives "M" Waldo IV
FRC #1339 (Angelbots)
Team Role: Tactician
 
Join Date: Feb 2014
Rookie Year: 2005
Location: Colorado
Posts: 958
IronicDeadBird has a reputation beyond reputeIronicDeadBird has a reputation beyond reputeIronicDeadBird has a reputation beyond reputeIronicDeadBird has a reputation beyond reputeIronicDeadBird has a reputation beyond reputeIronicDeadBird has a reputation beyond reputeIronicDeadBird has a reputation beyond reputeIronicDeadBird has a reputation beyond reputeIronicDeadBird has a reputation beyond reputeIronicDeadBird has a reputation beyond reputeIronicDeadBird has a reputation beyond repute
Oh gosh is this another "how its sold" fiascos where depending on marketing a part is legal... How did the last one go I only heard about it I didn't actuallly participate in the shenanigans.
__________________
HERO 俺を讃える声や 喝采なんて 欲しくはないさ
So I got my jacket back, but it turns out the "W" in WPI doesn't stand for that steak sauce I can't pronounce.
Play is for kids this is serious...
  #6   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 12-01-2015, 12:19
1Scouser 1Scouser is offline
Registered User
FRC #3196
 
Join Date: Jan 2015
Location: North Carolina
Posts: 4
1Scouser is an unknown quantity at this point
Re: When is a "motor" a "motor"?

Here is the link to the web site.

It would be truly wonderful if it is legal to use.

My fear is that it is not.

http://www.e-motioninc.com/Double_Ra...or_p/p-200.htm

I am looking to see if we can replace the existing motor with an off the shelf window motor. I guess I need to read the rules again to check the impact.

Thanks for the help so far.
  #7   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 12-01-2015, 12:21
Whippet's Avatar
Whippet Whippet is offline
MIT Class of 2020
AKA: Luis Trueba
FRC #4301 (New Tech Narcissists)
Team Role: Alumni
 
Join Date: Feb 2011
Rookie Year: 2011
Location: Cambridge, MA
Posts: 1,188
Whippet has a reputation beyond reputeWhippet has a reputation beyond reputeWhippet has a reputation beyond reputeWhippet has a reputation beyond reputeWhippet has a reputation beyond reputeWhippet has a reputation beyond reputeWhippet has a reputation beyond reputeWhippet has a reputation beyond reputeWhippet has a reputation beyond reputeWhippet has a reputation beyond reputeWhippet has a reputation beyond repute
Send a message via Yahoo to Whippet
Re: When is a "motor" a "motor"?

Quote:
Originally Posted by IronicDeadBird View Post
Oh gosh is this another "how its sold" fiascos where depending on marketing a part is legal... How did the last one go I only heard about it I didn't actuallly participate in the shenanigans.
It went pretty chaotically. As I recall, the last time this happened, "light switches" were allowed for use on the 2011 Minibots, but certain switches were not sold as "light switches," but as "120 Volt Switches," or something like that, thus making them pointlessly illegal.
__________________
2010: FRC 3043, Build Assistant
2011: FRC 3043, Head of Minibot subteam; FLL 12762, Team Captain
2012: FRC 3043, Electrical; FLL 12762, Team Captain; FTC 5670, Team Captain
2013: FRC 4301, Electrical, Team Co-Captain
2014: FRC 4301, Electrical/Programming, Team Co-Captain
2015: FRC 4301, Electrical/Programming, Team Captain
2016: FRC 4301, Chief Technical Officer; FTC 10860, 10861, and 11004: Mentor. Winner, Hub City Regional (3310 & 4063)
  #8   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 12-01-2015, 12:34
JesseK's Avatar
JesseK JesseK is online now
Expert Flybot Crasher
FRC #1885 (ILITE)
Team Role: Mentor
 
Join Date: Mar 2007
Rookie Year: 2005
Location: Reston, VA
Posts: 3,736
JesseK has a reputation beyond reputeJesseK has a reputation beyond reputeJesseK has a reputation beyond reputeJesseK has a reputation beyond reputeJesseK has a reputation beyond reputeJesseK has a reputation beyond reputeJesseK has a reputation beyond reputeJesseK has a reputation beyond reputeJesseK has a reputation beyond reputeJesseK has a reputation beyond reputeJesseK has a reputation beyond repute
Re: When is a "motor" a "motor"?

Quote:
Originally Posted by 1Scouser View Post
Here is the link to the web site.

It would be truly wonderful if it is legal to use.

My fear is that it is not.

http://www.e-motioninc.com/Double_Ra...or_p/p-200.htm

I am looking to see if we can replace the existing motor with an off the shelf window motor. I guess I need to read the rules again to check the impact.

Thanks for the help so far.
As-is, this product isn't a motor but an entire actuation system. There is no vagueness in how this particular part is sold - as a kit of motor + rack/pinion.

With that said, there are plenty of examples where COTS items have their motors replaced by FRC-legal motors for legal use in a competition - Vaccuum pumps, acme screw-based linear actuators and multi-speed Dewalt drills are three that immediately come to mind.

As pedantic as it sounds, even if the motor in that link were around the same power rating as a typical Van Door or Window motor, I don't know for sure that it would be legal to use since it came with a kit for a specific type of actuation. In the 3 examples above, some of the motors are identical but have the wrong part # on the motor and that makes the COTS setup illegal to use as-is (thus the replacement FRC-legal motor). In this actuator's case, it's a gray area given the wording of the rules. Personally I wouldn't take the risk, and would replace the actuator's motor with a Window motor from prior years' KOP - though that's easy for me since we have so many sitting around.

Last edited by JesseK : 12-01-2015 at 12:38.
  #9   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 12-01-2015, 12:35
Conor Ryan Conor Ryan is offline
I'm parking robot yacht club.
FRC #4571 (Robot Yacht Club)
Team Role: Mentor
 
Join Date: Nov 2004
Rookie Year: 2004
Location: Midtown, NYC
Posts: 1,901
Conor Ryan has a reputation beyond reputeConor Ryan has a reputation beyond reputeConor Ryan has a reputation beyond reputeConor Ryan has a reputation beyond reputeConor Ryan has a reputation beyond reputeConor Ryan has a reputation beyond reputeConor Ryan has a reputation beyond reputeConor Ryan has a reputation beyond reputeConor Ryan has a reputation beyond reputeConor Ryan has a reputation beyond reputeConor Ryan has a reputation beyond repute
Re: When is a "motor" a "motor"?

I'd ask this in the official Q&A
  #10   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 12-01-2015, 12:36
MrForbes's Avatar
MrForbes MrForbes is offline
Registered User
AKA: Jim
FRC #1726 (N.E.R.D.S.)
Team Role: Mentor
 
Join Date: Feb 2006
Rookie Year: 2006
Location: Sierra Vista AZ
Posts: 6,045
MrForbes has a reputation beyond reputeMrForbes has a reputation beyond reputeMrForbes has a reputation beyond reputeMrForbes has a reputation beyond reputeMrForbes has a reputation beyond reputeMrForbes has a reputation beyond reputeMrForbes has a reputation beyond reputeMrForbes has a reputation beyond reputeMrForbes has a reputation beyond reputeMrForbes has a reputation beyond reputeMrForbes has a reputation beyond repute
Re: When is a "motor" a "motor"?

My guess is that it's probably not legal to use.

Which means you get to do some more brainstorming and design work, to figure out a way to do it more simply. We've always shied away from linear things, and used hinged things instead. It's so easy to make a hinged mechanism...drill a hole, insert a bolt.
  #11   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 12-01-2015, 13:05
1Scouser 1Scouser is offline
Registered User
FRC #3196
 
Join Date: Jan 2015
Location: North Carolina
Posts: 4
1Scouser is an unknown quantity at this point
Re: When is a "motor" a "motor"?

Thanks for all the quick responses, I'm discovering that that is what FRC is all about!

I have just managed to speak to a tech rep for the actuator and it is indeed an automotive motor. The motor manufactures web site states " These motors are commonly used for RV and truck step lift assemblies, window lift, awning extension, and many other applications". Its listed under wiper systems.

This is the motor -



The motor and actuator are available separately or as an assembled unit.

With that said should we buy them separately and self assemble or does having a data sheet for the motor assembly stating its automotive heritage suffice to meet the rules? This is were experience wins the day!

Thanks again for all your input.

Last edited by 1Scouser : 12-01-2015 at 13:12.
  #12   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 12-01-2015, 14:34
MrForbes's Avatar
MrForbes MrForbes is offline
Registered User
AKA: Jim
FRC #1726 (N.E.R.D.S.)
Team Role: Mentor
 
Join Date: Feb 2006
Rookie Year: 2006
Location: Sierra Vista AZ
Posts: 6,045
MrForbes has a reputation beyond reputeMrForbes has a reputation beyond reputeMrForbes has a reputation beyond reputeMrForbes has a reputation beyond reputeMrForbes has a reputation beyond reputeMrForbes has a reputation beyond reputeMrForbes has a reputation beyond reputeMrForbes has a reputation beyond reputeMrForbes has a reputation beyond reputeMrForbes has a reputation beyond reputeMrForbes has a reputation beyond repute
Re: When is a "motor" a "motor"?

Just to be safe, you could buy them separately...but it looks like you found a good answer. Have the documentation with you during robot inspection (the first day of the regional competition), just in case you need to show the inspector.

Also keep in mind that we are not the Q&A, so our answers are not official.

It's a fun game, having engineers play lawyer.
  #13   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 12-01-2015, 14:36
AllenGregoryIV's Avatar
AllenGregoryIV AllenGregoryIV is offline
Engineering Coach
AKA: Allen "JAG" Gregory
FRC #3847 (Spectrum)
Team Role: Coach
 
Join Date: Jul 2008
Rookie Year: 2003
Location: Texas
Posts: 2,575
AllenGregoryIV has a reputation beyond reputeAllenGregoryIV has a reputation beyond reputeAllenGregoryIV has a reputation beyond reputeAllenGregoryIV has a reputation beyond reputeAllenGregoryIV has a reputation beyond reputeAllenGregoryIV has a reputation beyond reputeAllenGregoryIV has a reputation beyond reputeAllenGregoryIV has a reputation beyond reputeAllenGregoryIV has a reputation beyond reputeAllenGregoryIV has a reputation beyond reputeAllenGregoryIV has a reputation beyond repute
Send a message via AIM to AllenGregoryIV
Re: When is a "motor" a "motor"?

After going through LRI training this weekend, without any other information besides that data sheet, I'd probably pass it at my event. But it is a bit of a grey area so it can vary from event to event, to be sure you'll need a Q&A response.
__________________

Team 647 | Cyber Wolf Corps | Alumni | 2003-2006 | Shoemaker HS
Team 2587 | DiscoBots | Mentor | 2008-2011 | Rice University / Houston Food Bank
Team 3847 | Spectrum | Coach | 2012-20... | St Agnes Academy
LRI | Alamo Regional | 2014-20...
"Competition has been shown to be useful up to a certain point and no further, but cooperation, which is the thing we must strive for today, begins where competition leaves off." - Franklin D. Roosevelt
  #14   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 12-01-2015, 15:18
Tom Line's Avatar
Tom Line Tom Line is offline
Raptors can't turn doorknobs.
FRC #1718 (The Fighting Pi)
Team Role: Mentor
 
Join Date: Jan 2007
Rookie Year: 1999
Location: Armada, Michigan
Posts: 2,570
Tom Line has a reputation beyond reputeTom Line has a reputation beyond reputeTom Line has a reputation beyond reputeTom Line has a reputation beyond reputeTom Line has a reputation beyond reputeTom Line has a reputation beyond reputeTom Line has a reputation beyond reputeTom Line has a reputation beyond reputeTom Line has a reputation beyond reputeTom Line has a reputation beyond reputeTom Line has a reputation beyond repute
Re: When is a "motor" a "motor"?

With a little engineering and some lost-motion springs that will make a nice electronic shifter.
  #15   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 12-01-2015, 16:20
1Scouser 1Scouser is offline
Registered User
FRC #3196
 
Join Date: Jan 2015
Location: North Carolina
Posts: 4
1Scouser is an unknown quantity at this point
Thumbs up Re: When is a "motor" a "motor"?

Thank you all, you have been a great help.

We will play it safe and have the correct documentation and if possible replace the motor with an existing KoP motor.

Like I said, please keep up the great work you do on this forum its invaluable to people like me.
Closed Thread


Thread Tools
Display Modes Rate This Thread
Rate This Thread:

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Forum Jump


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 17:37.

The Chief Delphi Forums are sponsored by Innovation First International, Inc.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © Chief Delphi