In b4 buttongate

[Aur0r4]

As if UNH district finals couldn't get more weird...

[Foster]

I'll bite, what are you talking about? I'm 1800 miles away ......

[Carl C]

Originally Posted by Foster

I'll bite, what are you talking about? I'm 1800 miles away ......

During the UNH District Event finals, a human player's button fell off, went through the chute, and ended up beneath the tote. When the stack was placed on the platform, the button was wedged underneath the stack. The rules state that the stack must be "completely" supported by totes to count, so the stack did not count.

I am not sure if that had any effect on the outcome of the match, but the whole thing was very bizarre.

[MikLast]

i would very much like to see this, is there any video uploaded (or going to be uploaded soon?)

[Aur0r4]

Originally Posted by MikLast

i would very much like to see this, is there any video uploaded (or going to be uploaded soon?)

Got a pic from a ref, will try to post.

[rich2202]

I'm surprised at:
1) The button made it from the Chute to the Scoring Platform; and
2) The Ref's saw the button under the stack.

In any case, the rule is the rule. Nothing can be between the Tote and the Platform except for another Tote.

[Aur0r4]

http://imgur.com/1J0dSZD

[MikLast]

Originally Posted by Aur0r4

http://imgur.com/1J0dSZD

just wow, how does that happen? also, did the HP get a foul for not having a button on?

[EmileH]

I would have thought they'd get a foul for putting something other than a tote through the human feeder chute.

[EricH]

Originally Posted by emileh3467

I would have thought they'd get a foul for putting something other than a tote through the human feeder chute.

No foul listed. And not having the button is a fix-it penalty, not a points penalty.

[Drew4564]

Originally Posted by MikLast

just wow, how does that happen? also, did the HP get a foul for not having a button on?

I was the operator for the robot who built the buttoned stack, so I (rather unfortunately) saw it all happen. In my HP's rushing around, the button (which was at about mid-tote-chute height) popped off and happened to land right in the chute behind a tote. Nobody noticed until it flew out the chute and found a snuggly spot in the bottom of our six stack. We scored and capped it, hoping it wouldn't matter, but in the back of our minds we knew it wouldn't end well.

Luckily, there were no fouls! I think we were all way too confused and surprised to think about it, I know I was

[JBeaulier]

THE button

[Collin4564]

I am the human player from 4564. The button was one of the funniest things that has happened to me in FIRST. I thought you may want to see the button! I am #buttongate

[Jay O'Donnell]

Also to note, this was a replay of match 1. The first match was stopped due to all of the lights going out in the middle of that match. This was followed by a 142-141 finish in finals match two. Such a fun, entertaining way to end an event.

[bobl]

For what it is worth, Counting the stack would not have changed the outcome. Instead of 155 to 84 it would have been 155 to 126. Congratulations Team 133, BERT, 213, The Dirty Birds and 501, The Power Knights! The 142-141 finale was awesome! This event had a plethora of high scores and terrific robots. I am looking forward to seeing and working with all the teams again at WPI for the District Championship.