[FRC Blog] Two Championship Survey Results and Path Forward

[R2D2DOC]

Hello All,

With the objective of establishing as many FIRST programs at the high school level as possible, we need to look at HIGH SCHOOL level events as well as the limited time and resources for these young people. An extra level of competitions after a championsplit seems a bit much.

The district model has been working well in Michigan. My son was a student and I was a mentor when we transitioned from regionals to districts. It was an adjustment in 2009. But by 2010 it was fine. The process of the state championship is scaleable and is evident by the success of the 2015 Michigan State Championship.

Will the district model work everywhere? Hopefully in one form another. We rely on the wisdom and dedication of the students and volunteers throughout FRC to make that happen. Will there be regionals? Perhaps, if it fills the need. Any crossing between districts and districts to regionals? That still needs to be addressed and may change as we move along. The same could be said concerning qualifications to go the world championship. That too may evolve.

We are in a challenging transition, albiet on a larger scale, for the entire FRC community compared to the Michigan experience. FIRST is seeking a balance between incuding as many teams as possible and making the championship experience gratifying and unique. Do District Championships fulfill part of the goal of inclusion as well as a "championship" experience? Depends on who you ask.

I have judged at Michigan districts, Michigan champs and World Champs. Each has it's own benefit and I believe district championships fills the void for inclusion, and a good portion of the championship experience.

FIRST will have to gauge the community's reactions. I believe they will steer a viable course for the future. Remember, this is all for the students.