High Torque Gearboxes

[AdamHeard]

If you're talking within the realm of COTS FRC, something has to give here.

With single CIM, the GEM500 from Andymark is reasonable.

If you provide another reduction after it, the plastic 3 stage gearbox from Vex would work too. Even if you paid to get some plates cut to build another stage it wouldn't be very expensive.

COTS gearing from other industries is unlikely to accept dual motor input, so that will rule out a good deal (you'll also find that gearing for pretty much any other industry will be more expensive).

Originally Posted by llamadon

VexPro versa planetaries can be customized up to 100:1 reduction, and have a one CIM input adapter.

This breaks the versaplanetary.


EDIT: Worth pointing out that 2 CIMs at 70:1 is enough torque under stall to break many things that sometimes are assumed to be bulletproof in FRC. You'll want to verify the material for the output shaft can handle the torque (along with whatever the output gearing is) and/or limit the systems ability to maintain full stull at full voltage.

[llamadon]

Originally Posted by AdamHeard

This breaks the versaplanetary.

VexPro advertises the use of two 10:1 reduction stages to achieve the 100:1 reduction. Are the gearboxes actually useable at this reduction? What are some experiences with them breaking?

[Aren_Hill]

Originally Posted by llamadon

VexPro advertises the use of two 10:1 reduction stages to achieve the 100:1 reduction. Are the gearboxes actually useable at this reduction? What are some experiences with them breaking?

It is usable at this ratio with certain motors, please refer to the Load Rating Guide for your particular case.

Originally Posted by Ginger Power

It was stupid of me not to provide more background info. The motor/gearbox combination if not for an FRC application. It's for a NASA Robotic Mining Competiton robot that my club is building. We were hoping to avoid chains/belts by direct driving our 24" wheels... hence why we need so much torque. The more I think about it, the more sense it makes to just give up on trying to direct drive the wheels. The reasoning behind trying to use cim motors and FRC components is because that's what we're familiar with, and we intend to use the FRC control system on our robot.

If anybody has experience with non-FRC motors that may work for this application I'd love to hear it.

Edit: Hex shaft is not a requirement, just easier to work with imo.

4 CIMs is overkill for every robot I've seen at that competition, the 2013 ISU bot was 2 Mini-CIMs, one per side.
Good luck, it's a fun competition (I was with the Iowa State team 2012 and 2013)

-Aren

[Ginger Power]

Originally Posted by Aren_Hill

Good luck, it's a fun competition (I was with the Iowa State team 2012 and 2013, where used Brushless drill motors, and then Mini-CIMS)

-Aren

I was watching the highlights from the 2013 competition to try to get an idea of what to expect and they did a good segment on your team. Nice interview (starts at the 21 minute mark) by the way Your robot was incredible that year.

[EricH]

Originally Posted by Aren_Hill

4 CIMs is overkill for every robot I've seen at that competition, the 2013 ISU bot was 2 Mini-CIMs, one per side.
Good luck, it's a fun competition (I was with the Iowa State team 2012 and 2013)

-Aren

SDSM&T, 2012, for me. Try 775-18s for a direct drive via BaneBots gearboxes, maybe--that's what we used that year, 4 of 'em. Just make sure your circuit protection--and speed controllers--can handle the current. I don't think we ever blew a fuse (yep, we used inline fuses) but we also had speed controllers that would shut off under high-current conditions (say, about 3-10 seconds into a run) and not reboot. So we got some without that safety and... well... It worked until we dug ourselves into a small hole and got stuck on our last run. We could smell the smoke when we opened the case.

[Ginger Power]

Originally Posted by EricH

SDSM&T, 2012, for me. Try 775-18s for a direct drive via BaneBots gearboxes, maybe--that's what we used that year, 4 of 'em. Just make sure your circuit protection--and speed controllers--can handle the current. I don't think we ever blew a fuse (yep, we used inline fuses) but we also had speed controllers that would shut off under high-current conditions (say, about 3-10 seconds into a run) and not reboot. So we got some without that safety and... well... It worked until we dug ourselves into a small hole and got stuck on our last run. We could smell the smoke when we opened the case.

In other words...avoid doing that. Gotcha. Thanks for the input everybody! The current plan is to go with a single cim Gem500 with 3 or 4 stages- still deciding. If anybody is interested in seeing the CAD (or just a picture) PM me!

Also, can anybody speak to how well the Gem500 (and mounting bracket) can handle side loads to the output shaft (30-50lbs)?

[marshall]

Originally Posted by Ginger Power

In other words...avoid doing that. Gotcha. Thanks for the input everybody! The current plan is to go with a single cim Gem500 with 3 or 4 stages- still deciding. If anybody is interested in seeing the CAD (or just a picture) PM me!

Also, can anybody speak to how well the Gem500 (and mounting bracket) can handle side loads to the output shaft (30-50lbs)?

One issue we ran into with the GEMs was that the pressed in pinions that the planet gears sit on can wobble out if there is a lot of side loading. It depends a great deal on the type of GEM used as AM has switched out the parts over the years. In theory, there are large washers inside the GEM to help with this. We went so far as to weld them at one point and even had the shop attempt to harden them... no luck, they snapped like twigs.

Also, with 4 stages, it is possible to corkscrew the output shaft so run your calculations carefully before running it on a robot.

[EricH]

Originally Posted by Ginger Power

In other words...avoid doing that. Gotcha.

Just the speed controllers--the 775s worked like a charm if the controllers weren't taking a siesta. They were also easy to dustproof...

[Gdeaver]

If 18 or 24 volt power is possible, look at some cordless power tools. Refurbed tool only prices can be good. I have an old 24 volt impact drill. 80 - 100 rpm. Can be put into rotation only. Unbelievable torque. It's green - Hitachi?

[CJ_Elliott]

... Now I must cad this...