Go to Post Thank you for participating. It'd be a blank website without all of you. :) - Brandon Martus [more]
Home
Go Back   Chief Delphi > Other > Math and Science
CD-Media   CD-Spy  
portal register members calendar search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read FAQ rules

 
Reply
Thread Tools Rate Thread Display Modes
  #1   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 04-12-2015, 21:18
lindsgubes lindsgubes is offline
Registered User
FRC #0308
 
Join Date: Dec 2015
Location: michigan
Posts: 1
lindsgubes is an unknown quantity at this point
Debating with physics teacher.

On a recent quiz I got the following question incorrect and after debating it with my teacher he would not budge.
The question is as follows: A heavy rock and a light rock of the same size are falling through the air from a tall building. The one that encounters the greatest air resistance is the
A) light rock
B) heavy rock
C) same for both




After doing some research I still stand behind my answer of C) same for both. The teachers answer was A) light rock.
I have found explanations for both equal and heavy but am baffled as to how the answer could be the light rock.
What are your opinions or thoughts?
Reply With Quote
  #2   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 04-12-2015, 21:43
GeeTwo's Avatar
GeeTwo GeeTwo is offline
Technical Director
AKA: Gus Michel II
FRC #3946 (Tiger Robotics)
Team Role: Mentor
 
Join Date: Jan 2014
Rookie Year: 2013
Location: Slidell, LA
Posts: 3,570
GeeTwo has a reputation beyond reputeGeeTwo has a reputation beyond reputeGeeTwo has a reputation beyond reputeGeeTwo has a reputation beyond reputeGeeTwo has a reputation beyond reputeGeeTwo has a reputation beyond reputeGeeTwo has a reputation beyond reputeGeeTwo has a reputation beyond reputeGeeTwo has a reputation beyond reputeGeeTwo has a reputation beyond reputeGeeTwo has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Debating with physics teacher.

The answer will vary depending on how the teacher defines "the same size" and "air resistance". The most likely meaning of "the same size" is "the same shape and volume"; I'll assume that as the intent. Then, the definition of "air resistance" may be defined either in terms of force, in which case the heavier rock will experience slightly more at any given time, as it will move faster; or in terms of acceleration, time to fall a given distance, or other motion-based measure, in which case the lighter rock will be more impacted by the effects of the air.
__________________

If you can't find time to do it right, how are you going to find time to do it over?
If you don't pass it on, it never happened.
Robots are great, but inspiration is the reason we're here.
Friends don't let friends use master links.
Reply With Quote
  #3   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 04-12-2015, 22:58
headlight headlight is offline
Registered User
no team
 
Join Date: May 2013
Rookie Year: 2012
Location: Rochester Hills, MI
Posts: 69
headlight is an unknown quantity at this point
Re: Debating with physics teacher.

He might be trying to think of it from a terminal velocity perspective. The heavy rock will have a faster terminal velocity, the lighter rock will have a slower terminal velocity. So it would seem intuitive that the lighter rock is encountering more resistance because it is going slower (even though it is the heavier rock that actually has a greater force being applied to it by the air).

Overall it seems to be a poorly worded question, a more clear question would be to ask which experiences greater drag force due to air resistance.
Reply With Quote
  #4   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 04-12-2015, 23:09
EricH's Avatar
EricH EricH is offline
New year, new team
FRC #1197 (Torbots)
Team Role: Engineer
 
Join Date: Jan 2005
Rookie Year: 2003
Location: SoCal
Posts: 19,726
EricH has a reputation beyond reputeEricH has a reputation beyond reputeEricH has a reputation beyond reputeEricH has a reputation beyond reputeEricH has a reputation beyond reputeEricH has a reputation beyond reputeEricH has a reputation beyond reputeEricH has a reputation beyond reputeEricH has a reputation beyond reputeEricH has a reputation beyond reputeEricH has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Debating with physics teacher.

Quote:
Originally Posted by headlight View Post
He might be trying to think of it from a terminal velocity perspective. The heavy rock will have a faster terminal velocity, the lighter rock will have a slower terminal velocity. So it would seem intuitive that the lighter rock is encountering more resistance because it is going slower (even though it is the heavier rock that actually has a greater force being applied to it by the air).

Overall it seems to be a poorly worded question, a more clear question would be to ask which experiences greater drag force due to air resistance.
And drag force is affected by both surface area and velocity.

If you put together a free body diagram, you may be able to solve this one out. Gravity is acting downwards (9.8m/s^2 * Mh for the heavy rock, 9.8m/s^2 * Ml for the light rock), drag force is acting upwards (I don't have a formula handy, but it's a function of velocity and surface area, and varies depending on shape--thankfully, rocks tend to be approximated "nicely" with a sphere).

Now all you have to do is determine which one needs a greater drag force to have Fgravity = Fdrag, and then you can determine things like which one is falling faster...

But, in this case, it's the heavy one (Mh is by definition > Ml). The EFFECT of the air resistance is seen most on the light one (Fdrag needing to be smaller on a body that is to all intents and purposes the same surface area but less massive in order to counter Fgravity).
__________________
Past teams:
2003-2007: FRC0330 BeachBots
2008: FRC1135 Shmoebotics
2012: FRC4046 Schroedinger's Dragons

"Rockets are tricky..."--Elon Musk

Reply With Quote
  #5   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 07-12-2015, 10:11
FrankJ's Avatar
FrankJ FrankJ is offline
Robot Mentor
FRC #2974 (WALT)
Team Role: Mentor
 
Join Date: Feb 2011
Rookie Year: 2009
Location: Marietta GA
Posts: 1,900
FrankJ has a reputation beyond reputeFrankJ has a reputation beyond reputeFrankJ has a reputation beyond reputeFrankJ has a reputation beyond reputeFrankJ has a reputation beyond reputeFrankJ has a reputation beyond reputeFrankJ has a reputation beyond reputeFrankJ has a reputation beyond reputeFrankJ has a reputation beyond reputeFrankJ has a reputation beyond reputeFrankJ has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Debating with physics teacher.

At best a poorly worded question. It would be better as a short answer, but in that case any could be correct with the right reasoning. The best answer is B the heavier rock. For a given velocity air resistance is independent of mass. Air resistance is a function of the cube of the velocity. Since the heavier rock has greater force of gravity acting on it, it will have a greater terminal velocity thereby a greater force from air resistance.

Or once again at terminal velocity: do a force balance
F=MAg = F(air resistance). Since the more massive rock has a greater force from gravity, the counteracting force from air resistance will be greater. At less than terminal velocity, the more massive rock will have a greater acceleration, but at any given velocity the force from air resistance will be the same on both rocks. A=(MAg-F(air resistance))/M

If you measure the acceleration of the rocks and the terminal velocities, the effect of the air resistance might seem to be greater on the lighter rock since it will accelerate slower & have a lower terminal velocity, but that was not the question was it?
F=force, M=mass, Ag= acceleration of gravity, F(air resistance) Force as a function of air resistance
__________________
If you don't know what you should hook up then you should read a data sheet

Last edited by FrankJ : 07-12-2015 at 10:39. Reason: grammar
Reply With Quote
  #6   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 07-12-2015, 10:19
wilsonmw04's Avatar
wilsonmw04 wilsonmw04 is online now
Coach
FRC #1086 (Blue Cheese)
Team Role: Teacher
 
Join Date: Dec 2006
Rookie Year: 2007
Location: Midlothian, VA
Posts: 1,875
wilsonmw04 has a reputation beyond reputewilsonmw04 has a reputation beyond reputewilsonmw04 has a reputation beyond reputewilsonmw04 has a reputation beyond reputewilsonmw04 has a reputation beyond reputewilsonmw04 has a reputation beyond reputewilsonmw04 has a reputation beyond reputewilsonmw04 has a reputation beyond reputewilsonmw04 has a reputation beyond reputewilsonmw04 has a reputation beyond reputewilsonmw04 has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Debating with physics teacher.

In a high school physics classroom (or intro college level for that matter), why even bring up the issue of air resistance? As illustrated by the complexity of the answers in this thread, it muddies the waters in what should be an application of a simple model.
__________________
Currently: Coach FRC 1086/FTC 93
2006-2011 Coach FRC 2106/FTC 35
If you come to a FRC event to see a robot competition, you are missing the point.
Reply With Quote
  #7   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 07-12-2015, 12:13
JamesBrown JamesBrown is offline
Back after 4 years off
FRC #5279
Team Role: Engineer
 
Join Date: Nov 2004
Rookie Year: 2005
Location: Lynchburg VA
Posts: 1,270
JamesBrown has a reputation beyond reputeJamesBrown has a reputation beyond reputeJamesBrown has a reputation beyond reputeJamesBrown has a reputation beyond reputeJamesBrown has a reputation beyond reputeJamesBrown has a reputation beyond reputeJamesBrown has a reputation beyond reputeJamesBrown has a reputation beyond reputeJamesBrown has a reputation beyond reputeJamesBrown has a reputation beyond reputeJamesBrown has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Debating with physics teacher.

Quote:
Originally Posted by wilsonmw04 View Post
In a high school physics classroom (or intro college level for that matter), why even bring up the issue of air resistance? As illustrated by the complexity of the answers in this thread, it muddies the waters in what should be an application of a simple model.
Because it is important to understand why the model does not match real world results. Understanding what other forces are in play is important, even if understanding how to quantify those forces is beyond the scope of the course.
__________________
I'm Back


5279 (2015-Present)
3594 (2011)
3280 (2010)
1665 (2009)
1350 (2008-2009)
1493 (2007-2008)
1568 (2005-2007)
Reply With Quote
  #8   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 07-12-2015, 12:59
wilsonmw04's Avatar
wilsonmw04 wilsonmw04 is online now
Coach
FRC #1086 (Blue Cheese)
Team Role: Teacher
 
Join Date: Dec 2006
Rookie Year: 2007
Location: Midlothian, VA
Posts: 1,875
wilsonmw04 has a reputation beyond reputewilsonmw04 has a reputation beyond reputewilsonmw04 has a reputation beyond reputewilsonmw04 has a reputation beyond reputewilsonmw04 has a reputation beyond reputewilsonmw04 has a reputation beyond reputewilsonmw04 has a reputation beyond reputewilsonmw04 has a reputation beyond reputewilsonmw04 has a reputation beyond reputewilsonmw04 has a reputation beyond reputewilsonmw04 has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Debating with physics teacher.

Quote:
Originally Posted by JamesBrown View Post
Because it is important to understand why the model does not match real world results. Understanding what other forces are in play is important, even if understanding how to quantify those forces is beyond the scope of the course.
From an engineering standpoint you may be correct, but from a physics education standpoint, it is trivial and over complicates the treatment of the relationship between position, velocity and acceleration. Even when dealing with net forces I don't even deal with it. We discuss why our model breaks down when comparing real world situations, but it's not worth dealing with it even on a qualitative level. Just my opinion.
__________________
Currently: Coach FRC 1086/FTC 93
2006-2011 Coach FRC 2106/FTC 35
If you come to a FRC event to see a robot competition, you are missing the point.
Reply With Quote
  #9   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 07-12-2015, 13:58
Michael Hill's Avatar
Michael Hill Michael Hill is offline
Registered User
FRC #3138 (Innovators Robotics)
Team Role: Mentor
 
Join Date: Jul 2004
Rookie Year: 2003
Location: Dayton, OH
Posts: 1,567
Michael Hill has a reputation beyond reputeMichael Hill has a reputation beyond reputeMichael Hill has a reputation beyond reputeMichael Hill has a reputation beyond reputeMichael Hill has a reputation beyond reputeMichael Hill has a reputation beyond reputeMichael Hill has a reputation beyond reputeMichael Hill has a reputation beyond reputeMichael Hill has a reputation beyond reputeMichael Hill has a reputation beyond reputeMichael Hill has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Debating with physics teacher.

I agree...poorly worded. It really should say something about assuming they're the same shape of the same size. I read "air resistance" from a force perspective (coming from an aeronautics background). So if they're the same size and shape, the heavy rock will experience more force. You can assume they're spheres if you want (it turns out the specific shape doesn't really matter). The aerodynamic force on a sphere will be a function of shape, surface finish, and velocity. See this: https://www.grc.nasa.gov/www/K-12/ai...ragsphere.html

Because the heavier rock has a greater gravitational force, it needs a greater aerodynamic force to counteract the gravitational force (at terminal velocity). Since the aerodynamic force is greater, the velocity is greater (this is why heavier objects of the same shape have a higher terminal velocity). Since the aerodynamic force is greater, it experiences more air resistance.
Reply With Quote
  #10   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 07-12-2015, 14:27
FrankJ's Avatar
FrankJ FrankJ is offline
Robot Mentor
FRC #2974 (WALT)
Team Role: Mentor
 
Join Date: Feb 2011
Rookie Year: 2009
Location: Marietta GA
Posts: 1,900
FrankJ has a reputation beyond reputeFrankJ has a reputation beyond reputeFrankJ has a reputation beyond reputeFrankJ has a reputation beyond reputeFrankJ has a reputation beyond reputeFrankJ has a reputation beyond reputeFrankJ has a reputation beyond reputeFrankJ has a reputation beyond reputeFrankJ has a reputation beyond reputeFrankJ has a reputation beyond reputeFrankJ has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Debating with physics teacher.

Of course you could always do it in a friction less vacuum
__________________
If you don't know what you should hook up then you should read a data sheet
Reply With Quote
  #11   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 07-12-2015, 15:08
wilsonmw04's Avatar
wilsonmw04 wilsonmw04 is online now
Coach
FRC #1086 (Blue Cheese)
Team Role: Teacher
 
Join Date: Dec 2006
Rookie Year: 2007
Location: Midlothian, VA
Posts: 1,875
wilsonmw04 has a reputation beyond reputewilsonmw04 has a reputation beyond reputewilsonmw04 has a reputation beyond reputewilsonmw04 has a reputation beyond reputewilsonmw04 has a reputation beyond reputewilsonmw04 has a reputation beyond reputewilsonmw04 has a reputation beyond reputewilsonmw04 has a reputation beyond reputewilsonmw04 has a reputation beyond reputewilsonmw04 has a reputation beyond reputewilsonmw04 has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Debating with physics teacher.

Quote:
Originally Posted by FrankJ View Post
Of course you could always do it in a friction less vacuum
It's a thing; at least in my world ;-)
__________________
Currently: Coach FRC 1086/FTC 93
2006-2011 Coach FRC 2106/FTC 35
If you come to a FRC event to see a robot competition, you are missing the point.
Reply With Quote
Reply


Thread Tools
Display Modes Rate This Thread
Rate This Thread:

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Forum Jump


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 12:06.

The Chief Delphi Forums are sponsored by Innovation First International, Inc.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © Chief Delphi