Are 8 play regional reasonable?

[Ginger Power]

Originally Posted by pntbll1313

I agree the ranking system isn't great, but don't they use a similar structure to the districts? As far as I know your seed doesn't factor into how many points you get to qualify for State. Even your W/L is weighted pretty low compared to how early you get picked and how you perform in eliminations.

The ranking system is essentially the same the district ranking system to my knowledge. The biggest differences are that Chairman's Award winning teams qualify automatically, and only your first event counts.

I'm not sure how I feel about CA winners automatically qualifying... I like that we're rewarding the teams that win the most prestigious award in FIRST, but it doesn't necessarily bring the best teams to the competition. Although if your team is winning CA, you probably have a competitive team anyways, at least that's what I gather by checking out past winners.

I definitely know how I feel about a teams second event not counting. If the goal of the state championship is to have all the best teams in the state competing to figure out the best of the best then you have to count a second regional. You can do an average of the results of the first and second regionals to maintain some parity, but the teams that go to 2 events will get better at their second event.

If the goal of the state championship is anything other than figuring out the best of the best... then don't call it a state championship.

I know this thread is about 8 regional plays being fair or not, but let's be honest, it has evolved into an open discussion about FIRST in Minnesota. A discussion that is important, and should happen.