2016 Alliance Selection Results

[Anthony Galea]

Center Line:

1) 1481-0123-5756 (SF)
2) 3098-0503-5915 (F)
3) 5567-1189-5555 (SF)
4) 1701-5053-2048 (W)
5) 4680-0818-3175 (QF)
6) 0910-0245-5623 (QF)
7) 3632-0815-0280 (QF)
8) 5478-0453-2673 (QF)

no declines

[Zebra_Fact_Man]

Originally Posted by MikLast

PNW Ellensburg

1 3711 1318 2926 (f)
3 4450 2147 4495 (qf)

4450 declined 3711.

Lol. Sometimes you're better off accepting the invitation.

[Ether]

Originally Posted by Zebra_Fact_Man

Lol. Sometimes you're better off accepting the invitation.

or maybe, at this particular time and place, they were more interested in the experience of being an alliance captain.

[Dezion]

Week 2

NC District Wake County

1. 4935 - 2642 -3661 (W)
2. 435 - 2059 - 5544 (F)
3. 3215 - 2682 - 6003 (QF)
4. 5518 - 3459 - 4816 (SF)
5. 4795 - 587 - 5190 (QF)
6. 6215 - 900 - 5607 (SF)
7. 3331 - 3737 - 5160 (QF)
8. 3336 - 5919 - 4828 (QF)

No declines


Week 3

NC District UNC Asheville

1. 2655 - 238 - 3680 (W)
2. 4290 - 2059 - 3845 (QF)
3. 5160 - 1533 - 3229 (SF)
4. 587 - 3506 - 3971 (SF)
5. 4828 - 5854 - 5446 (QF)
6. 4935 - 3196 - 5727 (QF)
7. 3402 - 422 - 5679 (F)
8. 4767 - 2640 - 1225 (QF)

I believe there was a decline by 587.

[Zebra_Fact_Man]

Originally Posted by Ether

the experience of being an alliance captain.

( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
mfw

[dmorewood]

Originally Posted by BMSOTM

Correct. 2729 also declined in the second round, I think it was the #4 alliance.

Does anyone know why 2729 declined.

[Dibit1010]

Originally Posted by Dezion

Week 2



NC District Wake County



1. 4935 - 2642 -3661 (W)

2. 435 - 2059 - 5544 (F)

3. 3215 - 2682 - 6003 (QF)

4. 5518 - 3459 - 4816 (SF)

5. 4795 - 587 - 5190 (QF)

6. 6215 - 900 - 5607 (SF)

7. 3331 - 3737 - 5160 (QF)

8. 3336 - 5919 - 4828 (QF)



No declines





Week 3



NC District UNC Asheville



1. 2655 - 238 - 3680 (W)

2. 4290 - 2059 - 3845 (QF)

3. 5160 - 1533 - 3229 (SF)

4. 587 - 3506 - 3971 (SF)

5. 4828 - 5854 - 5446 (QF)

6. 4935 - 3196 - 5727 (QF)

7. 3402 - 422 - 5679 (F)

8. 4767 - 2640 - 1225 (QF)



I believe there was a decline by 587.

As someone from 587 we did decline 4290 because they were 2nd seed and with 24 teams would have a weaker team because of the third pick. We went on to be in an alliance with yeti and Kai orbus and went to semi finials (would have gone to finals if we didn't lose coms on the field)

[Shane_Iron]

Originally Posted by Zebra_Fact_Man

Lol. Sometimes you're better off accepting the invitation.

Well, they had told us that they were going to decline us. We used that to our own strategic advantage and chose them so Skunk Works 1983, would not pick them. It was a great competition!

[Ether]

Originally Posted by Shane_Iron

Well, they had told us that they were going to decline us

Did they mention why?

[Zebra_Fact_Man]

Originally Posted by Dibit1010

would have gone to finals if we didn't lose coms on the field

TBA show you losing 2/2 SF matches. You lose com both matches? I would have said something to the ref and/or used a time-out to diagnose the problem after the first failure.

Originally Posted by Shane_Iron

Well, they had told us that they were going to decline us. We used that to our own strategic advantage and chose them so Skunk Works 1983, would not pick them. It was a great competition!

I have no problem with you picking them, or them declining you for that matter (it just obviously didn't work out for them).

[Shane_Iron]

Originally Posted by Ether

Did they mention why?

There was a lot of secrecy between the teams, and we let them know before alliance selection that they would be our first pick and they said they would decline. Then we had other teams telling us that Skunk Works 1983, would be choosing them for second pick and we decided to use that to our advantage. I also do believe that they may have wanted to be captains but we didn't want to take the chance of them being on Skunk Works alliance.

[JABot67]

Originally Posted by Ether

Did they mention why?

Originally Posted by Shane_Iron

There was a lot of secrecy between the teams, and we let them know before alliance selection that they would be our first pick and they said they would decline. Then we had other teams telling us that Skunk Works 1983, would be choosing them for second pick and we decided to use that to our advantage. I also do believe that they may have wanted to be captains but we didn't want to take the chance of them being on Skunk Works alliance.

I kind of wish there was a Central Washington District Event thread to discuss this. It was a great event! Everyone was on the edge of their seats as to what the final rankings would be.

The alliance selections were a classic example of "scorched earth", where the final top 8 rankings did not match most people's pick lists.

Most teams had 1983, 4450, and 1318 as the top 3 teams on their pick lists. When 3711 seeded first, they knew that 1983 and 4450 would decline them. I haven't seen 1983 and 4450's pick lists, but it's possible 3711 wasn't high enough on their lists to justify accepting an invitation from them. Thus, 3711 did the smart thing. They chose 4450 first, had them decline, and then chose 1318 who was outside the top 8. This broke up any combinations of 1983, 4450, and 1318.

I am not sure why the #3 alliance of 4450, 2147, and 4495 lost in the quarterfinal rounds, but it's possible the alliance just didn't gel well enough. Some alliances are still working out the kinks in quarters. I didn't get to watch the matches because my team was also playing in quarters. Either way, 4450 has a very, very good robot.

Congrats to 3711, 1318, and 2926 for making the final rounds (and eliminating us), and 1983, 4061, and 2149 for an absolutely dominant performance at CWU!

[Dibit1010]

Originally Posted by Zebra_Fact_Man

TBA show you losing 2/2 SF matches. You lose com both matches? I would have said something to the ref and/or used a time-out to diagnose the problem after the first failure.







I have no problem with you picking them, or them declining you for that matter (it just obviously didn't work out for them).

We did challenge but the ruling was kept- we understand why and are very happy with our playing. But they'res always that one little thing! Haha you win some you lose some I guess!

[JedG]

A bit late but here's Buckeye (week 3):

1. 4039-781-4121 (W)
2. 303-217-1787 (QF)
3. 5413-120-2010 (SF)
4. 4028-6032-1676 (QF)
5. 156-2252-3314 (SF)
6. 5740-695-263 (QF)
7. 27-379-706 (F)
8. 1590-4269-870 (QF)

There were no declines.

[caseybarisax14]

Originally Posted by Dezion

Week 2

NC District Wake County

1. 4935 - 2642 -3661 (W)
2. 435 - 2059 - 5544 (F)
3. 3215 - 2682 - 6003 (QF)
4. 5518 - 3459 - 4816 (SF)
5. 4795 - 587 - 5190 (QF)
6. 6215 - 900 - 5607 (SF)
7. 3331 - 3737 - 5160 (QF)
8. 3336 - 5919 - 4828 (QF)

No declines


Week 3

NC District UNC Asheville

1. 2655 - 238 - 3680 (W)
2. 4290 - 2059 - 3845 (QF)
3. 5160 - 1533 - 3229 (SF)
4. 587 - 3506 - 3971 (SF)
5. 4828 - 5854 - 5446 (QF)
6. 4935 - 3196 - 5727 (QF)
7. 3402 - 422 - 5679 (F)
8. 4767 - 2640 - 1225 (QF)

I believe there was a decline by 587.

Yes 587 declined due to Bots of War breaking earlier that day and risk of bad third bot