What would you do to improve the FIRST experience?

[gblake]

Originally Posted by FarmerJohn

FIRST needs to stop being so arrogant/selfish and admit that IFI has better lower and middle level robotics competitions, and an overall better competition structure. FRC tops all, but VRC is better than FTC in every way possible, and VIQ gives teams more out of their season than FLL does. And they both cost a whole lot less. If FIRST really cared about inspiring students they'd either try their best to actually make these lower and middle level competitions better or just tell students to do VIQ and VRC. If you're promoting an educational program whose alternative is better in every way, you're not in it for the students, you're in it for yourself.

I am a huge fan of the V** programs, but FTC does have at least one significant, positive difference from VRC, and there are other more debatable differences.

If you want to design and create custom parts, FTC offers far more opportunities. Designing and creating more custom parts doesn't equal more inspiration (at least not in my book); but it can equal more fun. It can also equal less fun, and/or a barrier to entry. YMMV

My bottom line: Let's not ascribe malice to either program, or attempt to kick either to the curb. Both encourage students to stick their toes into STEM waters at low-ish cost, and with low-ish mentoring requirements. If both tripled in size, they/we still would only be nibbling at satisfying the total North American (not to mention the rest of the world) needs.

Tell students, adults, and sponsors about both and let them pick the one that is right for them. Don't attempt to make the choice for them, graciously and professionally let them choose the one that best suits their circumstances.

Blake