Video Review Needs to Happen Now

[gblake]

Originally Posted by Chris is me

I would ask again in the fall. Most offseasons happen in the spring or fall; relatively few in the summer.

Sure - I'm aware, I thought a few were going to do some trials this summer, so I asked. I or someone should give this thread another poke in late Fall.

Originally Posted by Chris is me

I feel like a "it has to be perfect or it isn't worth doing at all" attitude here will really hold people back from experimenting with this.

I certainly hope not.

Conducting experiments is how you quantify "better, but not perfect". When a discussion reaches that stage, it can leave endless cycles of hand-waving behind.

Imperfect is fine, if the imperfections are known, and well-understood; and if the decision-makers agree that the imperfect system is the one they want (because it's better (in some hopefully well-defined sense) than the system it replaces).

Imperfect, and poorly understood, when/if it were implemented, ... Well, that would be a different kettle of fish.

Well designed experiments are exactly what this topic needs.

Blake