pic: Wheeled shirt launcher

[roboruler]

For something like this, it would probably be a lot better and cheaper to buy some Brushless outrunners and brushless ESC's rather than try to keep to FRC legal parts only. Your spinning a flywheel in one direction at highspeed so it's basically perfect to be made Brushless.

[Chris is me]

Originally Posted by roboruler

For something like this, it would probably be a lot better and cheaper to buy some Brushless outrunners and brushless ESC's rather than try to keep to FRC legal parts only. Your spinning a flywheel in one direction at highspeed so it's basically perfect to be made Brushless.

It really wouldn't, though. Even assuming they don't reuse old parts, a CIM is $27 and a Spark is like $45, which together is comparable to or cheaper than a 12V 300W brushless motor. You can get non-reversible PWM speed controllers for brushed motors for less than the cost of common FRC reversible controllers.

Edit: I didn't see they were feeding the CIM through a VP, which I honestly think they could skip if they wanted and just cantilever the wheels off CIM shafts with hex adapters. Kind of sketchy but it would be fine for an offseason robot.

[Andrew Schreiber]

Originally Posted by roboruler

For something like this, it would probably be a lot better and cheaper to buy some Brushless outrunners and brushless ESC's rather than try to keep to FRC legal parts only. Your spinning a flywheel in one direction at highspeed so it's basically perfect to be made Brushless.

I'm gonna ignore the cost argument. But I'd have concerns if your shooter wheels had any significant mass. There'd likely be some reconfiguring of the ESC required to get it working without starting a small fire.

DC motors can be abused and, given how students tend to do things, that's a good thing. I'd stick with maybe some 550 motors and appropriate VP gearboxes if required.