[FRC Blog] Regional Registration Issues

[JesseK]

Meh. Sure, there's more they could have done. Here's the thing about "software", coming from someone who's done "it" and only "it" for 14 years professionally.

"Why didn't ABC use XYZ?" completely ignores any actual tradeoffs or decision making an organization does based upon things we as teams do not know are considerations. No, FIRST doesn't need to be so transparent in their minute decisions. In aggregate I bet teams spend more money on coffee and pizza than on their robots and yet we do not expect any transparency from coffee growers or milk farmers about their products and services.

Web tech changes every 9 months or so. Most of the new stuff is crap, full of bugs, full of leveraged software's bugs, and doesn't integrate well without a bit of very specific, specialized knowledge. Stuff that's been around a few years is just now being analyzed for tradeoffs versus the older technology. Sometimes a new tech is great, sometimes it's crap. It's an early-adopter's common fallacy that old = irrelevant and useless.

"They're THIS big, why isn't this process better" completely plays into the software fallacy about adding more people to a project will get it done sooner or better. Since testing is usually the #1 thing that has its schedule cut when approaching a deadline, I'm going to guess they ran out of time to test large quantities of simultaneous connections.

"My high school students could have done this better" (heard elsewhere on social media) is a complete lie or pipe dream. Even the best high school teams lack what it takes to get something out of "sandbox" mode and into production at scale before a deadline - unless they have help from seasoned veterans. 90% of college kids have the same issue. Even most of the 'black box' stuff I received from post-grad researchers made so many assumptions about environment and lacked any kind of deployment or scale consideration.

Their re-structuring of the problem for 2018 seems like a much better way to scale registration.