Go to Post Design is iterative, right? - JesseK [more]
Home
Go Back   Chief Delphi > FIRST > General Forum
CD-Media   CD-Spy  
portal register members calendar search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read FAQ rules

 
Reply
Thread Tools Rate Thread Display Modes
  #16   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 11-01-2017, 12:00
niklas674's Avatar
niklas674 niklas674 is offline
Mecanum+drive=A bad idea
FRC #0701 (Robovikes)
Team Role: CAD
 
Join Date: Oct 2015
Rookie Year: 2015
Location: Vacaville
Posts: 190
niklas674 is a glorious beacon of lightniklas674 is a glorious beacon of lightniklas674 is a glorious beacon of lightniklas674 is a glorious beacon of lightniklas674 is a glorious beacon of light
Re: Mecanum vs. Tank Drive?

Tank.
__________________



My views do not represent the views of my team
Reply With Quote
  #17   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 11-01-2017, 12:08
Lord Basket's Avatar
Lord Basket Lord Basket is offline
President & Drive team coach
AKA: Parker
FRC #1719 (The Umbrella Corporation)
Team Role: Leadership
 
Join Date: Jan 2014
Rookie Year: 2014
Location: Baltimore, MD
Posts: 21
Lord Basket has a spectacular aura aboutLord Basket has a spectacular aura aboutLord Basket has a spectacular aura about
Re: Mecanum vs. Tank Drive?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Taylor View Post
However, I have noticed that the people who proclaim they'd never ally with a mecanum robot, aren't usually in a picking position.
While that may be the case sometimes, look at what members of consistently great teams are posting in this thread. Members of Citrus Circuits, Techfire and Robovikes literally posted one-word answers that just say "tank" and a member of the Cheesy Poofs posted "Just say no to mecanum drive." A member of TORC posted a more detailed response, but the conclusion was the same. Those teams are some of the best in the world and are in a picking position every year. While they haven't explicitly said they'd never pick a mecanum robot, they don't seem to think too highly of mecanums, to say the least.

Last edited by Lord Basket : 11-01-2017 at 12:14.
Reply With Quote
  #18   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 11-01-2017, 12:15
Koko Ed's Avatar
Koko Ed Koko Ed is offline
Serial Volunteer
AKA: Ed Patterson
FRC #0191 (X-Cats)
Team Role: Mentor
 
Join Date: Mar 2002
Rookie Year: 2002
Location: Rochester,NY
Posts: 22,948
Koko Ed has a reputation beyond reputeKoko Ed has a reputation beyond reputeKoko Ed has a reputation beyond reputeKoko Ed has a reputation beyond reputeKoko Ed has a reputation beyond reputeKoko Ed has a reputation beyond reputeKoko Ed has a reputation beyond reputeKoko Ed has a reputation beyond reputeKoko Ed has a reputation beyond reputeKoko Ed has a reputation beyond reputeKoko Ed has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Mecanum vs. Tank Drive?

Mecanums are effective if there's no defense present. There will be lots of defense this year and it will be brutal. Especially since there are no safe zones when you are looking to score gears.
Go with tank drive.
__________________
Reply With Quote
  #19   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 11-01-2017, 12:21
Ben Martin's Avatar
Ben Martin Ben Martin is offline
Long Distance Mentor
FRC #0225 (TechFire)
Team Role: Mentor
 
Join Date: Jan 2006
Rookie Year: 2005
Location: York, PA
Posts: 466
Ben Martin has a reputation beyond reputeBen Martin has a reputation beyond reputeBen Martin has a reputation beyond reputeBen Martin has a reputation beyond reputeBen Martin has a reputation beyond reputeBen Martin has a reputation beyond reputeBen Martin has a reputation beyond reputeBen Martin has a reputation beyond reputeBen Martin has a reputation beyond reputeBen Martin has a reputation beyond reputeBen Martin has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Mecanum vs. Tank Drive?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Lord Basket View Post
While they haven't explicitly said they'd never pick a mecanum robot, they don't seem to think too highly of mecanums, to say the least.
Only in contact games is it a factor. Mecanums make you both easier to defend against and a worse defender.
__________________
TechFire 225 -- Website -- Facebook
2015 & 2016 MAR Champions
Past teams: 234, 1747
Reply With Quote
  #20   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 11-01-2017, 12:23
scaryone's Avatar
scaryone scaryone is offline
Registered User
FRC #0058 (The Riot Crew)
Team Role: Coach
 
Join Date: Jan 2011
Rookie Year: 2007
Location: South Portland Maine
Posts: 140
scaryone will become famous soon enough
Re: Mecanum vs. Tank Drive?

Respectfully speaking, mecanums get a bad rap. While it does have a slight disadvantage in a pushing contest, in my opinion, it is way overstated on CD. Weight distribution is important but not mission critical. Hard programming? How is it harder? Practice is critical, but isn't it for every team/drivetrain? Humbly speaking, the students have 2 Blue Banners using mecanums. Not sure what we'll do this year but mecanums are in the running.
Reply With Quote
  #21   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 11-01-2017, 12:32
Tom Bottiglieri Tom Bottiglieri is offline
Registered User
FRC #0254 (The Cheesy Poofs)
Team Role: Engineer
 
Join Date: Jan 2004
Rookie Year: 2003
Location: San Francisco, CA
Posts: 3,188
Tom Bottiglieri has a reputation beyond reputeTom Bottiglieri has a reputation beyond reputeTom Bottiglieri has a reputation beyond reputeTom Bottiglieri has a reputation beyond reputeTom Bottiglieri has a reputation beyond reputeTom Bottiglieri has a reputation beyond reputeTom Bottiglieri has a reputation beyond reputeTom Bottiglieri has a reputation beyond reputeTom Bottiglieri has a reputation beyond reputeTom Bottiglieri has a reputation beyond reputeTom Bottiglieri has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Mecanum vs. Tank Drive?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Lord Basket View Post
While they haven't explicitly said they'd never pick a mecanum robot, they don't seem to think too highly of mecanums, to say the least.
We don't have a rule against picking mecanums, but usually we ding them a bunch due to being susceptible to defense and not being able to play effective defense. I think we've picked maybe one or two mecanum bots since I joined in 2010.

I think this year's game may require defense. So I'd steer clear (get it?) of mecanum.

Last edited by Tom Bottiglieri : 11-01-2017 at 12:34.
Reply With Quote
  #22   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 11-01-2017, 12:36
Michael Corsetto's Avatar
Michael Corsetto Michael Corsetto is online now
Breathe in... Breathe out...
FRC #1678 (Citrus Circuits)
Team Role: Mentor
 
Join Date: May 2004
Rookie Year: 2002
Location: Davis, CA
Posts: 1,141
Michael Corsetto has a reputation beyond reputeMichael Corsetto has a reputation beyond reputeMichael Corsetto has a reputation beyond reputeMichael Corsetto has a reputation beyond reputeMichael Corsetto has a reputation beyond reputeMichael Corsetto has a reputation beyond reputeMichael Corsetto has a reputation beyond reputeMichael Corsetto has a reputation beyond reputeMichael Corsetto has a reputation beyond reputeMichael Corsetto has a reputation beyond reputeMichael Corsetto has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Mecanum vs. Tank Drive?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Lord Basket View Post
While that may be the case sometimes, look at what members of consistently great teams are posting in this thread. Members of Citrus Circuits, Techfire and Robovikes literally posted one-word answers that just say "tank" and a member of the Cheesy Poofs posted "Just say no to mecanum drive." A member of TORC posted a more detailed response, but the conclusion was the same. Those teams are some of the best in the world and are in a picking position every year. While they haven't explicitly said they'd never pick a mecanum robot, they don't seem to think too highly of mecanums, to say the least.
+1 to this. We do a first pass filter on our second pick list based upon drivetrain style. If it's not tank style, we often drop the team from our list right there.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Taylor View Post
I will also say there is a stigma with mecanums, with questionable merit, and some teams say they would not pick a mecanum robot to ally with in eliminations. However, I have noticed that the people who proclaim they'd never ally with a mecanum robot, aren't usually in a picking position.
My experience has been the opposite, but YMMV. I know to us, and a few other teams usually in picking position, mecanum is almost always an instant "do not pick".

There's lots of jokes/meme's around mecanum, because for contact games, it's just not what teams in picking positions want out of a second pick, so those mecanum robots get instantly dropped from pick lists. Carefully consider if this is a risk your team is willing to take.

-Mike

"Friends don't let friends build mecanum"
__________________
Team 1678: Citrus Circuits - Lead Technical Mentor, Drive Coach **Like Us On Facebook!**
Reply With Quote
  #23   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 11-01-2017, 12:36
BotDesigner's Avatar
BotDesigner BotDesigner is online now
Design/CAD/Strategy
AKA: David Gedney
FRC #4418 (Team Impulse)
Team Role: Leadership
 
Join Date: Dec 2015
Rookie Year: 2011
Location: Colorado
Posts: 118
BotDesigner has much to be proud ofBotDesigner has much to be proud ofBotDesigner has much to be proud ofBotDesigner has much to be proud ofBotDesigner has much to be proud ofBotDesigner has much to be proud ofBotDesigner has much to be proud ofBotDesigner has much to be proud ofBotDesigner has much to be proud of
Re: Mecanum vs. Tank Drive?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Tom Bottiglieri View Post
We don't have a rule against picking mecanums, but usually we ding them a bunch due to being susceptible to defense and not being able to play effective defense. I think we've picked maybe one or two mecanum bots since I joined in 2010.

I think this year's game may require defense. So I'd steer clear (get it?) of mecanum.
Silly question, were those two mecanum bots picked in 2015?
__________________

2016, 2017 Colorado FLL Champions
2014 FLL North American Invitational, 1st place Strategy and Innovation Award
2014, 2013 Kentucky FLL Champions

2nd place Strategy and Innovation Award
FLL Team Automaticus Rex, Team Captain('11-'14) youth mentor ('15-'17) FRC Team 4418 Member ('14-') Design Lead ('15-17')

Last edited by BotDesigner : 11-01-2017 at 12:38.
Reply With Quote
  #24   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 11-01-2017, 12:47
MrForbes's Avatar
MrForbes MrForbes is offline
Registered User
AKA: Jim
FRC #1726 (N.E.R.D.S.)
Team Role: Mentor
 
Join Date: Feb 2006
Rookie Year: 2006
Location: Sierra Vista AZ
Posts: 6,033
MrForbes has a reputation beyond reputeMrForbes has a reputation beyond reputeMrForbes has a reputation beyond reputeMrForbes has a reputation beyond reputeMrForbes has a reputation beyond reputeMrForbes has a reputation beyond reputeMrForbes has a reputation beyond reputeMrForbes has a reputation beyond reputeMrForbes has a reputation beyond reputeMrForbes has a reputation beyond reputeMrForbes has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Mecanum vs. Tank Drive?

Quote:
Originally Posted by euhlmann View Post
Tank
Cons: go up to feeder station. You're not aligned. Drive back and turn. Go up again. Still not aligned. Drive back and turn again...
Or....build your collecting mechanism so it does not require precise alignment...and practice driving...
Reply With Quote
  #25   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 11-01-2017, 12:57
IronicDeadBird's Avatar
IronicDeadBird IronicDeadBird is offline
Theory Crafting Fo days...
AKA: Charles Ives "M" Waldo IV
FRC #1339 (Angelbots)
Team Role: Tactician
 
Join Date: Feb 2014
Rookie Year: 2005
Location: Colorado
Posts: 958
IronicDeadBird has a reputation beyond reputeIronicDeadBird has a reputation beyond reputeIronicDeadBird has a reputation beyond reputeIronicDeadBird has a reputation beyond reputeIronicDeadBird has a reputation beyond reputeIronicDeadBird has a reputation beyond reputeIronicDeadBird has a reputation beyond reputeIronicDeadBird has a reputation beyond reputeIronicDeadBird has a reputation beyond reputeIronicDeadBird has a reputation beyond reputeIronicDeadBird has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Mecanum vs. Tank Drive?

The biggest thing that kills me about Mecanum is when I am at a competition and I see a Mecanum robot being driven around like a tank. Unless your design, driver, and auto really utilizes strafing then you should not be using mecanum at all. Look at your strategy and ask yourself "do we need mecanum or will drive practice also get us where we need to be"
__________________
HERO 俺を讃える声や 喝采なんて 欲しくはないさ
So I got my jacket back, but it turns out the "W" in WPI doesn't stand for that steak sauce I can't pronounce.
Play is for kids this is serious...
Reply With Quote
  #26   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 11-01-2017, 12:57
Rosiebotboss's Avatar
Rosiebotboss Rosiebotboss is offline
2015-16 Divisional LRI - Archimedes
AKA: Dana P. Henry
FRC #0839 (Rosie Robotics)
Team Role: Mentor
 
Join Date: Nov 2002
Rookie Year: 2002
Location: Agawam, MA
Posts: 855
Rosiebotboss has a reputation beyond reputeRosiebotboss has a reputation beyond reputeRosiebotboss has a reputation beyond reputeRosiebotboss has a reputation beyond reputeRosiebotboss has a reputation beyond reputeRosiebotboss has a reputation beyond reputeRosiebotboss has a reputation beyond reputeRosiebotboss has a reputation beyond reputeRosiebotboss has a reputation beyond reputeRosiebotboss has a reputation beyond reputeRosiebotboss has a reputation beyond repute
Send a message via AIM to Rosiebotboss
Re: Mecanum vs. Tank Drive?

Interesting thread.

Mecanums get a bad rap. With a skilled driver a mecanum drive train can be very effective, ease of alignment to the high shot and placement of a gear negates the use of a turret for a quick "lock on" of the high boiler and a passive gear holding system can be used for the "lift."

As far as defense, I look at it this way, a running back on a football team charges the defensive line, usually made up of bigger, stronger guys. He'll hit the line, bounce off, rotate out and start upfield again, being more agile sometimes is better than stronger. As far as playing defense, All you have to do is hit the opponent on a corner of the frame to knock the robot out of their 'spot' of slow them down and prevent them from completing all their cycles. It's not always about brute force.
__________________
Co-Founder/Mentor FRC Team 839 / JrFLL Team 137/Rosie Robotics/Agawam HS
Winner NEF District WPI 2016
Regional CA-08 Boston, 12 WPI, Eng'g Excellence, 12-15 UL Safety, 15 Motorola Quality
KPCB Entrepreneurship 04, 05, 06, 07, 10, 11, 13, 14, 15, 16
Rookie All Star and Top Rookie Seed 2002
Paul Harris Fellow, CMP Inspector 05-16, Head LRI NE FIRST JTB 1944-2008 "What did you do with your dash?"
Reply With Quote
  #27   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 11-01-2017, 13:02
eedoga's Avatar
eedoga eedoga is online now
Registered User
FRC #2980
 
Join Date: Jan 2011
Location: Oak Harbot
Posts: 231
eedoga has much to be proud ofeedoga has much to be proud ofeedoga has much to be proud ofeedoga has much to be proud ofeedoga has much to be proud ofeedoga has much to be proud ofeedoga has much to be proud ofeedoga has much to be proud of
Re: Mecanum vs. Tank Drive?

I suppose I have a few questions...

If teams are in a position to pick and simply refuse to select an alliance partner that uses Mecanum simply because they use Mecanum then isn't that a problem? I would hope that teams are utilizing scouting and performance in order to determine alliance partners...though that may not be the case.

One thing that we might consider is, if a team on the opposing alliance is tied up defending however successfully against one alliance partner, then that is one less team member on the opposing alliance that is off scoring points...

Finally I think it comes down to strategy. Saying that mecanum means that a team will be easy to defend against isn't exactly accurate. A mecanum drive robot can work to avoid conflicts instead of engaging in them.

I hope I haven't tipped my hat too much...Oh...and best of luck to all.

Edoga
Reply With Quote
  #28   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 11-01-2017, 13:45
Michael Corsetto's Avatar
Michael Corsetto Michael Corsetto is online now
Breathe in... Breathe out...
FRC #1678 (Citrus Circuits)
Team Role: Mentor
 
Join Date: May 2004
Rookie Year: 2002
Location: Davis, CA
Posts: 1,141
Michael Corsetto has a reputation beyond reputeMichael Corsetto has a reputation beyond reputeMichael Corsetto has a reputation beyond reputeMichael Corsetto has a reputation beyond reputeMichael Corsetto has a reputation beyond reputeMichael Corsetto has a reputation beyond reputeMichael Corsetto has a reputation beyond reputeMichael Corsetto has a reputation beyond reputeMichael Corsetto has a reputation beyond reputeMichael Corsetto has a reputation beyond reputeMichael Corsetto has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Mecanum vs. Tank Drive?

Quote:
Originally Posted by eedoga View Post
If teams are in a position to pick and simply refuse to select an alliance partner that uses Mecanum simply because they use Mecanum then isn't that a problem? I would hope that teams are utilizing scouting and performance in order to determine alliance partners...though that may not be the case.
I suppose that method is only a "problem" if it doesn't produce the intended results (win the event).

-Mike
__________________
Team 1678: Citrus Circuits - Lead Technical Mentor, Drive Coach **Like Us On Facebook!**
Reply With Quote
  #29   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 11-01-2017, 14:02
RoboChair's Avatar
RoboChair RoboChair is offline
He who fixes with hammers #tsimfd
AKA: Devin Castellucci
FRC #1678 (Citrus Circuits and 5458 Digital Minds)
Team Role: Mentor
 
Join Date: Jan 2007
Rookie Year: 2005
Location: Davis, CA
Posts: 706
RoboChair has a reputation beyond reputeRoboChair has a reputation beyond reputeRoboChair has a reputation beyond reputeRoboChair has a reputation beyond reputeRoboChair has a reputation beyond reputeRoboChair has a reputation beyond reputeRoboChair has a reputation beyond reputeRoboChair has a reputation beyond reputeRoboChair has a reputation beyond reputeRoboChair has a reputation beyond reputeRoboChair has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Mecanum vs. Tank Drive?

Quote:
Originally Posted by MrForbes View Post
Or....build your collecting mechanism so it does not require precise alignment...and practice driving...
+9001 This, Very this. Make the task of driving your robot such that the driver needs little aim.
__________________

12 Years and counting! Over a third of my life has been spent with FRC.
Reply With Quote
  #30   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 11-01-2017, 14:09
niklas674's Avatar
niklas674 niklas674 is offline
Mecanum+drive=A bad idea
FRC #0701 (Robovikes)
Team Role: CAD
 
Join Date: Oct 2015
Rookie Year: 2015
Location: Vacaville
Posts: 190
niklas674 is a glorious beacon of lightniklas674 is a glorious beacon of lightniklas674 is a glorious beacon of lightniklas674 is a glorious beacon of lightniklas674 is a glorious beacon of light
Re: Mecanum vs. Tank Drive?

While our best year involved us using a mecanum drive (mistake), we practically never used it in matches, the positioning was close enough that we didn't have to make large changes. Bottom line is that with plenty of drivers practice, you won't need to be able to strafe because your drivers will get to the exact spot almost every time.
__________________



My views do not represent the views of my team
Reply With Quote
Reply


Thread Tools
Display Modes Rate This Thread
Rate This Thread:

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Forum Jump


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 16:09.

The Chief Delphi Forums are sponsored by Innovation First International, Inc.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © Chief Delphi