Hall of Fame Award and Display

[RoboMom]

[quote=Rich Kressly]Ed:
It's my understanding it's ongoing as well.

RoboMom:
My apologies. I thought you were speaking of Championship Winners only since it was in this thread. I like your idea personally and I agree, but the four page entries are not the property of FIRST, rather they are the property of teams. There have been threads in the past (I remember one started by Rich Wong last year) that discussed the pros and cons of sharing CA submissions and I'd suggest reading those.


Rich: no apologies needed. Thanks for the suggestion and I'll move off this thread and onto the one for CA. I'll make sure I read the past threads before I send off my letter to FIRST.
Thanks.
Jenny

[Rich Kressly]

Great idea Jenny.

[nuggetsyl]

Question isn't 16 in the hall of fame and if they are how did they win a reagional chairmans???? I am not clear if 16 is a chairmans awards winner or not. Too many hits in the head building the robot i guess.

shaun

[Koko Ed]

Originally Posted by nuggetsyl

Question isn't 16 in the hall of fame and if they are how did they win a reagional chairmans???? I am not clear if 16 is a chairmans awards winner or not. Too many hits in the head building the robot i guess.

shaun

Uh yeah, they have and I guess FIRST has decided that they can qualify for both awards or something.

[nuggetsyl]

Originally Posted by Koko Ed

Uh yeah, they have and I guess FIRST has decided that they can qualify for both awards or something.

ok so they are chairmans award winners i though you could never win twice any more???? I though that you had to earn stars or something??? Can any other hall of fame teams and or 16 explain(clarify) this to me because i am not getting it?

shaun

[Redhead Jokes]

Originally Posted by RoboMom007

Do you really think it is impractical for FIRST to post all this year's Regional winning entries?

If FIRST or Chief Delphi doesn't do it, we can do it.

[Koko Ed]

Originally Posted by nuggetsyl

Question isn't 16 in the hall of fame and if they are how did they win a reagional chairmans???? I am not clear if 16 is a chairmans awards winner or not. Too many hits in the head building the robot i guess.

shaun

Well it would help if FIRST put out an official document about the Chairman's award status of previous winners and this award's elegiblity. As of right now, I guess you can go for both awards.

[Koko Ed]

Originally Posted by Redhead Jokes

If FIRST or Chief Delphi doesn't do it, we can do it.

You got all of the documents?

[meaubry]

Wait - now I'm confused.
Ed, are you sure Baxter Mountain Home has won a Chairmans Award prior to this year? I don't recall that, but if you are correct then somethings wrong because we recieved a letter stating that previous winners were not eligible for a regional chairmans award. I think we were told to send our 4 page submittal directly to FIRST to get approved to create the presentation at Atlanta. I'm thinking that Baxter has not ever won a National Chairmans Award yet.

[Koko Ed]

Originally Posted by meaubry

Wait - now I'm confused.
Ed, are you sure Baxter Mountain Home has won a Chairmans Award prior to this year? I don't recall that, but if you are correct then somethings wrong because we recieved a letter stating that previous winners were not eligible for a regional chairmans award. I think we were told to send our 4 page submittal directly to FIRST to get approved to create the presentation at Atlanta. I'm thinking that Baxter has not ever won a National Chairmans Award yet.

'fraid so.

HISTORICAL CHAIRMAN'S AWARD WINNERS
2002
175 - "BUZZ" - Hamilton Sundstrand Space Systems International/The New England Air Museum/Techni-Products/Veritech Media & Enrico Fermi High School

2001
22 - NASAJPL/Boeing/Rocketdyne/FADL Engineering/Decker Machine & Chatsworth High School

2000
16 - Baxter Healthcare Corporation & Mountain Home High School

1999
120 - NASA Lewis Research Center/TRW, Inc./Battelle Memorial Institute & East Technical High School

1998
23 - Boston Edison & Plymouth North High School

1997
47 - Delphi International & Pontiac Central High School

1996
144 - Procter & Gamble & Walnut Hills High School

1995
151 - Lockheed Sanders & Nashua High School

1994
191 - Xerox Corporation & JC Wilson Magnet High School

1993
7 - AT&T Bell Labs & Science High School

1992
191 - Xerox Corporation & JC Wilson Magnet High School

[Rich Kressly]

We have the same letter. I'm sure there is an explanation. The BombSquad is a great team, a fine example for us all, and super to work with as an alliance partner, but it appears that there may have been a miscommunication.

[meaubry]

Originally Posted by Rich Kressly

We have the same letter. I'm sure there is an explanation. The BombSquad is a great team, a fine example for us all, and super to work with as an alliance partner, but it appears that there may have been a miscommunication.

Thanks for the confirmation on that one Rich.
I just checked the FIRST site and it does list Team 16 as the Chairmans Award winner at the Chesapeake Regional. I'll check it out tomorrow and find out whats going on - I'll post the answer I get later. By the way, I agree that Team 16 is a outstanding example for everyone. No disrespect intended - just confused about what we were suppose to submit to whom.

[Koko Ed]

Originally Posted by meaubry

Thanks for the confirmation on that one Rich.
I just checked the FIRST site and it does list Team 16 as the Chairmans Award winner at the Chesapeake Regional. I'll check it out tomorrow and find out whats going on - I'll post the answer I get later. By the way, I agree that Team 16 is a outstanding example for everyone. No disrespect intended - just confused about what we were suppose to submit to whom.

You weren't being disrespectful. From what I assumed before, I too, thought they were not eligible for the award and when they won I was totally shocked. But if they are deserving, they are deserving.

[meaubry]

Originally Posted by Koko Ed

You weren't being disrespectful. From what I assumed before, I too, thought they were not eligible for the award and when they won I was totally shocked. But if they are deserving, they are deserving.

I'm in total agreement with you Ed. I just wonder about other deserving teams that submitted to the Chesapeake Regional. Doesn't it seem like someone just missed out on that opportunity? Hate to be the runner up at that one!

[Koko Ed]

Originally Posted by meaubry

I'm in total agreement with you Ed. I just wonder about other deserving teams that submitted to the Chesapeake Regional. Doesn't it seem like someone just missed out on that opportunity? Hate to be the runner up at that one!

I was thinking this was why FIRST did this so that new teams could win the Chairman's award and get to go to the Championship while giving the previous award winner their due and something to aim for year after year.