FANTASY FIRST

[Xufer]

Im in guys, im sorry i didnt find this sooner ..

[Koko Ed]

Which would you prefer as teh number one seeding consideration? Win and losses or overall points scored.
I think wins and losses matter most.

[tkwetzel]

I'm in...and I also consider win/loss ratio most important, because that is more important in the game this year.

[Alex Cormier]

Originally Posted by Koko Ed

Which would you prefer as teh number one seeding consideration? Win and losses or overall points scored.
I think wins and losses matter most.

i perfer points....your alliance points not the losing alliance pts. i say pts, b/c what if ur ptr gets tipped or broken and iu do alot n get close tot he other score and try and try u still lose, that will hurt you

[Jeremiah Johnson]

Am I too late? If not I'm in!!!

[David Hoff]

Originally Posted by Koko Ed

Which would you prefer as teh number one seeding consideration? Win and losses or overall points scored.
I think wins and losses matter most.

definetly wins and losses

[Alex Cormier]

Originally Posted by Budda648

Am I too late? If not I'm in!!!

you're in Budda

[Joe Ross]

If your alliance makes it to the elimination rounds, do you get the wins of your whole alliance, or only the ones that you played in?

[Xufer]

I'd prefer points , where wins and losses are important but hey if you win you get the points if you lose you dont, but it will give teams who lose a few a chance to catch up, just a though.

[Jones571]

Originally Posted by Koko Ed

Which would you prefer as teh number one seeding consideration? Win and losses or overall points scored.
I think wins and losses matter most.

POINTS!!!! you dont have to be like the first game this year it is our own fantasy league

[Koko Ed]

Originally Posted by Joe Ross

If your alliance makes it to the elimination rounds, do you get the wins of your whole alliance, or only the ones that you played in?

You get the wins and losses for the alliance. I'm too lazy to figure out who played when plus you win and lose with the whole team anyways so it makes sense anyhow.

[Levin571]

Points all the way!

[Jones571]

Fantasy FIRST has grown fast in less then 24hours we have had 69 people say they want to play! it is great

[Koko Ed]

the problem with going with points is you get a big advantage if your team gets into the elimination rounds and it's not always the best seeded teams that always get in. In our division last year Children of the Swamp seeded 17 and did not get picked. You penalize allinces (whomever your three teams are) because they did not meet the preferance of seeded teams. There are teams that would get picked no matter what (like 71 Beaty robotics. They'd get picked if they sent a pile of parts out to the field).
At least with wins and losses (with an emphasis on w/l percentage) it's a little more fair. BTW the John V Neun example in the sample is an extream example. I doubt anyone is going to do that well.

[Shu Song]

whoa.... 148 posts in 2 days. that is amazing. but if we get funding to go to nats, im so doing this.