humorous or commercialish?

[kcy88]

This is a great question. I'm still confused about what Autodesk is looking for and this will be my third year on Animation. I think it's more challenging now since the regionals are peer judged; many of us have different tastes. Personally, I like an animation that is put together well, flows smoothly, and has several elements that just makes you think, "wow, how did they do that?". Others may look for humor. But what do the professional judges want?

Well, after reviewing all the regional winners from last year's AVA competition from the DVD, I'll have to disagree that most of the winning animations contain humor. Most of them have little or no humor.

And my opinion to Salik's question, I'm still clueless... The teams that win regionals are more like commericials; so I guess teams shouldn't focus too much on humor since pixar isn't judging it... Humor is fine as long as the animation as a whole is "serious" and appealing.

Happy Animating

[White_Orpheus]

Last year we weren't really trying for something humorous, but we tried to focus more on making something visually stunning rather than promoting FIRST. Our animation essentially had no meaning whatsoever, but it sure looked cool. It held out at the regional, but we got killed in the content score at the national. I think the best approach is just to make something that looks cool, yet promotes FIRST, cause the national judges certainly aren't going to have much appreciation for humor.

[Koko Ed]

Originally Posted by White_Orpheus

Last year we weren't really trying for something humorous, but we tried to focus more on making something visually stunning rather than promoting FIRST. Our animation essentially had no meaning whatsoever, but it sure looked cool. It held out at the regional, but we got killed in the content score at the national. I think the best approach is just to make something that looks cool, yet promotes FIRST, cause the national judges certainly aren't going to have much appreciation for humor.

Like team 114's championship winning aniamtion from 2002.
That was one the greatest I have ever seen.

[Team905Animator]

For the past three years 905 has "tried" to go the informational/serious route, this year though we are going off on a tangent and putting a dark mysterious animation around our message

[MConte05]

Originally Posted by Team905Animator

For the past three years 905 has "tried" to go the informational/serious route, this year though we are going off on a tangent and putting a dark mysterious animation around our message

I too am planning on heading towards a humorish side, something simple, both in concept and modeling. I plan to spend about week modeling and texturing, 4 weeks animating since I want a very strong, fluid animation in my character and the surrounding props.....

[Ryan Dognaux]

Really, it's whatever you want to do. If you look at the Thunderchicken's animation from last year, it was somewhat humorous, and displayed their message well. You just want to make something that people will remember, and humor seems to be the easiest way to do that.