Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince (Spoilers)

[shyra1353]

Originally Posted by Alex Pelan

Pretty much everything I've had to say was already said, but my cousin threw out this idea: Harry, or another person, as one of the horcruxes? If so, someone will have a very difficult decision to make come book 7. I found this to be the weakest book so far, but still a decent read.

I considered Harry as one of the Horcruxes but ruled it out because it just didn't make sense. Why would Voldemort try and kill Harry if Harry is a part of his soul and without him, Voldemort is one bit closer to mortality.

Also .. another question that was supposed to be answered or at least hinted toward is what were the professions of Lily and James? I can't remember where I read it but they weren't Aurors ...

Also .. I didn't like how JKR made Dumbledore point out everythign from the memories oh so blatantly. Like he would say "I hope you can see how so and so" But at the same time I can see that she did that so the younger readers would be able to follow the story. So while I'm not a huge fan of it, I also can't see another way around it ...