Go to Post You do realize that you all started jumping to conclusions without asking first which JVN he was talking about. - Jay H 237 [more]
Home
Go Back   Chief Delphi > Technical > Technical Discussion
CD-Media   CD-Spy  
portal register members calendar search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read FAQ rules

 
View Poll Results: Which do you prefer?
Live Axles 29 35.80%
Dead (stationary) Axles 52 64.20%
Voters: 81. You may not vote on this poll

Closed Thread
Thread Tools Rate Thread Display Modes
  #16   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 03-05-2006, 12:04
Woodie Flowers Award
Ken Patton Ken Patton is offline
purple
FRC #0051 (Wings of Fire)
Team Role: Engineer
 
Join Date: Jul 2001
Rookie Year: 1997
Location: Pontiac, MI
Posts: 338
Ken Patton has a reputation beyond reputeKen Patton has a reputation beyond reputeKen Patton has a reputation beyond reputeKen Patton has a reputation beyond reputeKen Patton has a reputation beyond reputeKen Patton has a reputation beyond reputeKen Patton has a reputation beyond reputeKen Patton has a reputation beyond reputeKen Patton has a reputation beyond reputeKen Patton has a reputation beyond reputeKen Patton has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Live vs. Dead axles

We usually have used dead axles. One year when we cantilevered our front wheels, we went live.

Using dead axles allows you to use the axle as a structural member. I see that as one strong advantage. It does not take us very long to do a wheel swap (but I admit its longer than some of you live axle guys are describing).

As somebody already mentioned, there are some nice wheels out there (IFI's, AM's, etc) that are suited to the dead axle approach.

Ken
  #17   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 03-05-2006, 12:37
Paul Copioli's Avatar Unsung FIRST Hero Woodie Flowers Award
Paul Copioli Paul Copioli is offline
President, VEX Robotics, Inc.
FRC #3310 (Black Hawk Robotics)
Team Role: Engineer
 
Join Date: Jun 2001
Rookie Year: 2000
Location: Rockwall, TX
Posts: 1,393
Paul Copioli has a reputation beyond reputePaul Copioli has a reputation beyond reputePaul Copioli has a reputation beyond reputePaul Copioli has a reputation beyond reputePaul Copioli has a reputation beyond reputePaul Copioli has a reputation beyond reputePaul Copioli has a reputation beyond reputePaul Copioli has a reputation beyond reputePaul Copioli has a reputation beyond reputePaul Copioli has a reputation beyond reputePaul Copioli has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Live vs. Dead axles

Quote:
Dead axles. Why would I transmit torque through something I don't have to?
.. for ease of maintenance silly
  #18   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 03-05-2006, 12:38
Tristan Lall's Avatar
Tristan Lall Tristan Lall is offline
Registered User
FRC #0188 (Woburn Robotics)
 
Join Date: Aug 2001
Rookie Year: 1999
Location: Toronto, ON
Posts: 2,484
Tristan Lall has a reputation beyond reputeTristan Lall has a reputation beyond reputeTristan Lall has a reputation beyond reputeTristan Lall has a reputation beyond reputeTristan Lall has a reputation beyond reputeTristan Lall has a reputation beyond reputeTristan Lall has a reputation beyond reputeTristan Lall has a reputation beyond reputeTristan Lall has a reputation beyond reputeTristan Lall has a reputation beyond reputeTristan Lall has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Live vs. Dead axles

Though I haven't tried this specifically, you could always get most of the benefits of both systems by using a dead axle, and a live, quick-change hub. That would permit you to remove the wheel from the hub, but keep the chains attached. It seems easy enough to do with a couple of dowel pins for transmitting torque, rather than the usual bolted-together wheels and hubs, or single-piece wheel-and-hub units; you just need a way to constrain the components axially.

Incidentally, Woburn robots have typically used dead axles, but that was often because it was more convenient to use cheap bearings/bushings in the frame, and better bushings/bearings (or even oiled wood bores!) on the shafting.

Last edited by Tristan Lall : 03-05-2006 at 12:42.
  #19   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 03-05-2006, 12:50
Gabe's Avatar
Gabe Gabe is offline
Pocket Full of Tools
FRC #0604 (Quixilver)
Team Role: College Student
 
Join Date: Mar 2006
Rookie Year: 2001
Location: California
Posts: 654
Gabe has a reputation beyond reputeGabe has a reputation beyond reputeGabe has a reputation beyond reputeGabe has a reputation beyond reputeGabe has a reputation beyond reputeGabe has a reputation beyond reputeGabe has a reputation beyond reputeGabe has a reputation beyond reputeGabe has a reputation beyond reputeGabe has a reputation beyond reputeGabe has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Live vs. Dead axles

Quote:
Originally Posted by Tristan Lall
It seems easy enough to do with a couple of dowel pins for transmitting torque, rather than the usual bolted-together wheels and hubs, or single-piece wheel-and-hub units; you just need a way to constrain the components axially.
Like a car! I hadn't thought of it that way. A car has a live axle which ends with a faceplate that has 4-6 lug bolts. You mount your tire by sliding the tire rim onto the faceplate, and tightening the lug nuts. Instead of dowel pins, a faceplate with bolts sticking out would handle your axial and radial movement when you tighten the wheel down with nylon-insert nuts.


What came first: the student or the mentor?
__________________
Team site: Q U I X I L V E R
My favorite tool is my imagination; I’m always finding new ways to use it.
  #20   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 03-05-2006, 13:04
Unsung FIRST Hero
JVN JVN is offline
@JohnVNeun
AKA: John Vielkind-Neun
FRC #0148 (Robowranglers)
Team Role: Engineer
 
Join Date: May 2001
Rookie Year: 2000
Location: Greenville, Tx
Posts: 3,159
JVN has a reputation beyond reputeJVN has a reputation beyond reputeJVN has a reputation beyond reputeJVN has a reputation beyond reputeJVN has a reputation beyond reputeJVN has a reputation beyond reputeJVN has a reputation beyond reputeJVN has a reputation beyond reputeJVN has a reputation beyond reputeJVN has a reputation beyond reputeJVN has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Live vs. Dead axles

Quote:
Originally Posted by Paul Copioli
.. for ease of maintenance silly
Design is all about tradeoffs.
I just happen to TOTALLY disagree with the tradeoff you're making; but that is pretty much par for the course.
  #21   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 03-05-2006, 13:27
Tim Baird's Avatar
Tim Baird Tim Baird is offline
Design Ninja
FRC #0126 (Gael Force)
Team Role: Engineer
 
Join Date: May 2001
Rookie Year: 1999
Location: Clinton, MA
Posts: 241
Tim Baird has a reputation beyond reputeTim Baird has a reputation beyond reputeTim Baird has a reputation beyond reputeTim Baird has a reputation beyond reputeTim Baird has a reputation beyond reputeTim Baird has a reputation beyond reputeTim Baird has a reputation beyond reputeTim Baird has a reputation beyond reputeTim Baird has a reputation beyond reputeTim Baird has a reputation beyond reputeTim Baird has a reputation beyond repute
Send a message via AIM to Tim Baird
Re: Live vs. Dead axles

Quote:
Originally Posted by Ken Patton
We usually have used dead axles. One year when we cantilevered our front wheels, we went live.

Using dead axles allows you to use the axle as a structural member. I see that as one strong advantage. It does not take us very long to do a wheel swap (but I admit its longer than some of you live axle guys are describing).

As somebody already mentioned, there are some nice wheels out there (IFI's, AM's, etc) that are suited to the dead axle approach.
We use dead axles for pretty much the same reasons. Plus, old habits die hard...
__________________
Tim Baird
FRC Alum and FRC/FLL Volunteer
Project Engineer @ Nypro

History:
Gael Force 126: 1999-2000
WPI 190: 2001-2004
Gael Force 126: 2005-2010
Event Volunteer Only: 2011-Present
  #22   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 03-05-2006, 13:56
lukevanoort lukevanoort is offline
in between teams
AKA: Luke Van Oort
no team
 
Join Date: Oct 2005
Rookie Year: 2005
Location: Waterloo, ON, Canada
Posts: 1,873
lukevanoort has a reputation beyond reputelukevanoort has a reputation beyond reputelukevanoort has a reputation beyond reputelukevanoort has a reputation beyond reputelukevanoort has a reputation beyond reputelukevanoort has a reputation beyond reputelukevanoort has a reputation beyond reputelukevanoort has a reputation beyond reputelukevanoort has a reputation beyond reputelukevanoort has a reputation beyond reputelukevanoort has a reputation beyond repute
Send a message via AIM to lukevanoort
Re: Live vs. Dead axles

I think we've used both, but I've only worked on dead. I can see the benefits of live, but I'm with JVN in this, I like dead better than the idea of live. The efficiency, durability, and the fact that we already have the parts is worth loss of quick change capability. Tristan's idea is interesting though... I really need to register Inventor.
__________________
Team 1219: 2009 - Mentor
Team 587: 2005 - Animator, 2006-2008 - Team Captain
  #23   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 03-05-2006, 15:37
Tom Bottiglieri Tom Bottiglieri is offline
Registered User
FRC #0254 (The Cheesy Poofs)
Team Role: Engineer
 
Join Date: Jan 2004
Rookie Year: 2003
Location: San Francisco, CA
Posts: 3,189
Tom Bottiglieri has a reputation beyond reputeTom Bottiglieri has a reputation beyond reputeTom Bottiglieri has a reputation beyond reputeTom Bottiglieri has a reputation beyond reputeTom Bottiglieri has a reputation beyond reputeTom Bottiglieri has a reputation beyond reputeTom Bottiglieri has a reputation beyond reputeTom Bottiglieri has a reputation beyond reputeTom Bottiglieri has a reputation beyond reputeTom Bottiglieri has a reputation beyond reputeTom Bottiglieri has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Live vs. Dead axles

Quote:
Originally Posted by lukevanoort
I think we've used both, but I've only worked on dead. I can see the benefits of live, but I'm with JVN in this, I like dead better than the idea of live. The efficiency, durability, and the fact that we already have the parts is worth loss of quick change capability. Tristan's idea is interesting though... I really need to register Inventor.
I can't stress enough how important it is for robot parts to swap in and out in a matter of seconds or minutes. I can't say we would be National Champions now, but I know we could have come alot closer if our CIM motors were an a more easy to access position and we had full spares on hand.

I like the idea of the modular wheel that sits on a permentantly mounted hub. This solution seems to give you the best of both worlds (but may add weight. again, a trad off.)
  #24   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 03-05-2006, 15:48
Cory's Avatar
Cory Cory is offline
Registered User
AKA: Cory McBride
FRC #0254 (The Cheesy Poofs)
Team Role: Engineer
 
Join Date: May 2002
Rookie Year: 2001
Location: Redwood City, CA
Posts: 6,825
Cory has a reputation beyond reputeCory has a reputation beyond reputeCory has a reputation beyond reputeCory has a reputation beyond reputeCory has a reputation beyond reputeCory has a reputation beyond reputeCory has a reputation beyond reputeCory has a reputation beyond reputeCory has a reputation beyond reputeCory has a reputation beyond reputeCory has a reputation beyond repute
Send a message via AIM to Cory
Re: Live vs. Dead axles

If you have the resources to do it, I really can't see much of a reason not to use a live axle setup with hex broached wheels and sprockets. It makes everything so much easier. In the time it would take to remove one or two wheels from a dead axle setup, you could replace every wheel on a live axle setup. Using hex shafts to transmit power to your wheels also eliminates any concern of keys slipping, etc.
__________________
2001-2004: Team 100
2006-Present: Team 254
  #25   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 03-05-2006, 15:55
EricH's Avatar
EricH EricH is offline
New year, new team
FRC #1197 (Torbots)
Team Role: Engineer
 
Join Date: Jan 2005
Rookie Year: 2003
Location: SoCal
Posts: 19,832
EricH has a reputation beyond reputeEricH has a reputation beyond reputeEricH has a reputation beyond reputeEricH has a reputation beyond reputeEricH has a reputation beyond reputeEricH has a reputation beyond reputeEricH has a reputation beyond reputeEricH has a reputation beyond reputeEricH has a reputation beyond reputeEricH has a reputation beyond reputeEricH has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Live vs. Dead axles

Quote:
Originally Posted by Cory
If you have the resources to do it, I really can't see much of a reason not to use a live axle setup with hex broached wheels and sprockets.
Another reason for dead axle--resources, or lack thereof. And for the live axles, you still have to pull the axle partway out (or all the way, thereby making it hard) of the frame, if you have a closed-frame robot (frame outside the wheels). So it may also depend on your frame design which is easier to maintain. If you have your wheels on the outside of your frame, it's easier to maintain them, but they take a beating and must be live axled. Inside, it doesn't matter.
__________________
Past teams:
2003-2007: FRC0330 BeachBots
2008: FRC1135 Shmoebotics
2012: FRC4046 Schroedinger's Dragons

"Rockets are tricky..."--Elon Musk

  #26   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 03-05-2006, 16:32
Lil' Lavery Lil' Lavery is offline
TSIMFD
AKA: Sean Lavery
FRC #1712 (DAWGMA)
Team Role: Mentor
 
Join Date: Nov 2003
Rookie Year: 2003
Location: Philadelphia, PA
Posts: 6,656
Lil' Lavery has a reputation beyond reputeLil' Lavery has a reputation beyond reputeLil' Lavery has a reputation beyond reputeLil' Lavery has a reputation beyond reputeLil' Lavery has a reputation beyond reputeLil' Lavery has a reputation beyond reputeLil' Lavery has a reputation beyond reputeLil' Lavery has a reputation beyond reputeLil' Lavery has a reputation beyond reputeLil' Lavery has a reputation beyond reputeLil' Lavery has a reputation beyond repute
Send a message via AIM to Lil' Lavery
Re: Live vs. Dead axles

This was the first year sense I have been involved with 116 that we have used dead axles, and if we had swapped our front wheels to the AM Trick Wheels for improved turning, the front axles would have become live (we had our front axle's with a double bearing set up).
I prefer live axles for ease of maitenance and for ease of sensor application. 116 has, for the past several years, used shaft encoders (or attempted to) to help our autonomous navigation. Because of the dead axle situation this year, we couldn't simply add them to our drive axles this year, and they only spot we could with our simple set up would have been on the output shaft of our gearbox (but because of a lack of space and time we couldn't).
Id also have to say that having an open frame over your wheels is probably a much bigger factor in the ease of replacing your wheels, but a live axle system is alot easier, imho.
__________________
Being correct doesn't mean you don't have to explain yourself.
  #27   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 03-05-2006, 17:18
Rob Rob is offline
Registered User
AKA: Rob
FRC #0131 (CHAOS)
Team Role: Coach
 
Join Date: Mar 2004
Rookie Year: 1996
Location: New Hampshire
Posts: 304
Rob has a reputation beyond reputeRob has a reputation beyond reputeRob has a reputation beyond reputeRob has a reputation beyond reputeRob has a reputation beyond reputeRob has a reputation beyond reputeRob has a reputation beyond reputeRob has a reputation beyond reputeRob has a reputation beyond reputeRob has a reputation beyond reputeRob has a reputation beyond repute
Send a message via AIM to Rob
Re: Live vs. Dead axles

I voted live axle on this one.

The live axle design we have used the last 2 years is very simple, low cost, requires little machining resource, and has been maintenence free (not a single failure through 6 competitions last year and 2 so far this year)

I think in reality the real answer is whatever you can do best is what is best. From reading the various benefits of each system in this thread, both can be great for you if done properly. I can also attest that either can be a nightmare if done improperly or if problems arise.

Some reasons that our decision to use live axles is easy are cost and machining. We do not have the machining resources to make good wheels for dead axles, and cannot afford the off the shelf products offered by some vendors. Our wheels, bearings, shafts and sprockets were under $175 for a six wheel drive setup.

So analyze your budget and machining processes and go with whatever you can do best. (good design helps alot as well )

Edit** Here is a link to a picture of how our live axle is set up. There is one long key going through the wheel and sprockets for each shaft. http://www.joemenassa.com/Images/ROB.../IMG_2877.html


Rob

Last edited by Rob : 04-05-2006 at 09:21. Reason: added a picuture
  #28   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 03-05-2006, 20:32
Jay TenBrink Jay TenBrink is offline
Registered User
FRC #0494 (Martians)
Team Role: Engineer
 
Join Date: Jul 2003
Rookie Year: 2001
Location: Goodrich,MI
Posts: 111
Jay TenBrink has a reputation beyond reputeJay TenBrink has a reputation beyond reputeJay TenBrink has a reputation beyond reputeJay TenBrink has a reputation beyond reputeJay TenBrink has a reputation beyond reputeJay TenBrink has a reputation beyond reputeJay TenBrink has a reputation beyond reputeJay TenBrink has a reputation beyond reputeJay TenBrink has a reputation beyond reputeJay TenBrink has a reputation beyond reputeJay TenBrink has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Live vs. Dead axles

Dead axles are simple, lightweight, structural, and lend themselves to standardization of: bearings, sprockets, axle shafts, pillow blocks, axle spacers, etc. We used the same general construction for wheels, pick-up roller, and launcher.

I would like to see some examples posted of live axle designs that have been refined and are working well for those teams that use them.

Jay
  #29   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 03-05-2006, 20:49
Cuog's Avatar
Cuog Cuog is offline
Registered Linux User: 390661
AKA: Alex
FRC #0422
Team Role: Mentor
 
Join Date: Nov 2005
Rookie Year: 2004
Location: Richmond, Virginia
Posts: 852
Cuog has a reputation beyond reputeCuog has a reputation beyond reputeCuog has a reputation beyond reputeCuog has a reputation beyond reputeCuog has a reputation beyond reputeCuog has a reputation beyond reputeCuog has a reputation beyond reputeCuog has a reputation beyond reputeCuog has a reputation beyond reputeCuog has a reputation beyond reputeCuog has a reputation beyond repute
Send a message via AIM to Cuog
Re: Live vs. Dead axles

i prefer the use of dead axles, i have had to deal with too many thrown and eploding keys
__________________
KK4KQO
http://voltair.us
Too many projects, too little time.
Closed Thread


Thread Tools
Display Modes Rate This Thread
Rate This Thread:

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Forum Jump

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
How did you do your axles Justin1636 Technical Discussion 11 04-05-2005 18:04
What to do with autonomous Rickertsen2 Programming 48 17-02-2004 16:22
Fav. Beatles Song MattK Chit-Chat 17 04-12-2002 17:18
dead robot in the finals? srawls Rules/Strategy 2 24-03-2002 14:44
Who is going to the live chat? Kyle Fenton 3D Animation and Competition 1 20-02-2002 23:08


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 06:02.

The Chief Delphi Forums are sponsored by Innovation First International, Inc.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © Chief Delphi