Ethical question: What would you do if...

[Jon K.]

Originally Posted by KenWittlief

I was in a meeting this week, and softdrinks were provided, and an ethical question came to mind:

What would you do if you were in a meeting (FIRST meeting, team meeting, someones house, sponsors facility....)

and you opened a bottle of soda (pop)

and happened to notice the inside of the cap said "Million dollar winner!"

?

I think we all know what the PC answer is, but what would you really do?

To me it depends on the place. At a team meeting, we have a soda machine which we pay money for the soda, so I would keep most of the money, and donate some to the team as a sponsor. At someones house, I would probably give up the cap, as I didn't pay for the soda nor was it ever truly mine, and hope that they might share as I did give the cap back. At a sponsor's facility, well again its like the team thing where if I bought it from a machine then I would keep it, but if it were provided, I am not quite sure what I would do and it would depend on the sponsor as well. But again very interesting question being posed here.

[Arefin Bari]

The first thing that would pop into my mind would be "Finally, I can help those little kids who are suffering as well as the homeless who deserve some help."

... then I would buy a house (good enough for me and her) and 2 cars (that has very good gas mileage), and also get her a huge diamond ring and necklace set.

[thegathering]

I'd sprint to the door, open it, then run to the car and drive away. And be a millionaire.

If it were at a team meeting, and they had paid for the soda, I'd give it to the team. Because a million dollar robotics team would be unstoppable. (step one, buy my own warehouse for the team to be in, then start buying nice CNC tools. woot!)

[Noah Kleinberg]

Depends on how personally the soda was given out. If it's something like a regional and someone who works at the venue is handing out free drinks, I think it would make sense to keep it. If someone buys you a drink, then you should give them the cap.

[KenWittlief]

Just to make sure everyone understands (Im not a lawyer but Im pretty sure Im right on this)

if someone gave you the bottle, or you purchased it from a machine, it is yours - and regarding the prize possesion is 100% of the law (providing you did not beat someone senseless then pry it from their fingers).

So legally the prize would be yours, to do with as you see fit (same as if you purchased the bottle yourself from a supermarket).

Ethically.... thats another issue

[hoorayforpink]

i would probably yell out some obscene curse word out of surprise (what can i say im not perfect) and be like "you guys look at this!" and just freak out like crazy as far as the money is concerned half goes to me some to robotics and the rest to my family

[Greg Needel]

step 1: place cap in pocket
step 2: grin heavily
step 3:wait until end of meeting to leave
step 4: verify I am actually a millionaire (there are alot of pranksters out there)
step 5: put money in bank account
step 6: Go to meeting next day act as if nothing happened and volunteer to buy the food and drinks.