NFL Pickem Week 3

[Cory]

Originally Posted by santosh

They beat the Falcon's fair and square, but it doesnt mean that Vick is a bad QB and it doenst mean it was his fault either.

How many years in a row does Vick need to be a terrible passer until the mystique disappears and reality sets in?--Vick is a glorified RB and not a QB

He's had a rating of over 80 only once.

He's had an inordinately high number of turnovers, between fumbles and picks

His best completion percentage is 56%, which is pretty bad. Especially in the WCO which is based on high percentage passes.

[Logan Byers]

Here's my $0.02

Vick is a great athlete. I doubt there is anyone who can argue that he isn't.
I agree that he is closer to a RB than a QB. a QB is most often a passer first and a runner second. What makes me think Vick is not a good QB is the fact that he can't learn/run a Pro-style offense. He doesn't/can't fit in the WCO. The Falcons have had to draw up some college-level plays for him to run. Now, to Vick's defense, his WR's are young and have underperformed. TE Alge Crumpler is probably his best pass receiver.
Either way, no matter what I think, the Falcons seem to find ways to win their fair share of games. And in the end, winning is all that matters in Pro sports.