Youtube Game Animation #2008 Overdrive

[Denis]

Hello,

Well personnel to facilitate i upload the animation of the game of the year on youtube.

Good luck times!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kaocTCIph7M

[Tomasz Bania]

Originally Posted by Denis

Hello,

Well personnel to facilitate i upload the animation of the game of the year on youtube.

Good luck times!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kaocTCIph7M

I may be wrong, but isn't there something in FIRST's rules that doesn't allow you to "rebroadcast" their material without FIRST's approval?

If it doesn't, you are still probably not allowed to because it violates Youtube's TOS.

But on the bright side, thanks for lightening the load on NASA's servers and delivering instant gratification. :0

[RyanCesiel]

My brother posted it on Vimeo, which might have higher quality:

http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/sh...ad.php?t=60710

As far as violating FIRST's redistribution rules, I have no clue. There's a ton of Youtube videos from last year's animation, so I figured that it was okay. If we could get someone to confirm or deny that officially, that'd be nice.

[Denis]

Sorry i don't know of this rules, but the youtube is accessed tao tao and is easy to connect. In Lan House eg can not download videos or animations. In youtube not need to download anything up!


YouTube is +1 tool for we!

[X-Istence]

Bittorrent anyone?

[BanksKid]

on the subject of youtube i would just like to say...."WE HAVE A CAMERA RIGHT NOW!"

[tony.dalia.195]

Originally Posted by BanksKid

on the subject of youtube i would just like to say...."WE HAVE A CAMERA RIGHT NOW!"

LETS DO IT

[Denis]

Originally Posted by BanksKid

on the subject of youtube i would just like to say...."WE HAVE A CAMERA RIGHT NOW!"

hahahaha

[Denis]

Regarding the video, animation, it is true that there are flaws in the video? i don't understand

[Bongle]

Originally Posted by Denis

Regarding the video, animation, it is true that there are flaws in the video? i don't understand

One of the tall robots descores a trackball in the opposing team's home stretch by extending up and knocking it.

According to <G36> (possibly <G35>, I don't remember and don't have a manual handy), you can't be over 6ft in the opposing team's home stretch, meaning that robot would have incurred a penalty.

[Cory]

Guys--I would suggest you delete these copies off of youtube, and any other site you have hosted them on.

To do so without FIRST's explicit consent is copyright violation.

[BandChick]

If you guys are really concerned about the animation, keep your eyes peeled here: http://youtube.com/user/FIRSTWorldTube

And while you're waiting, watch some of the FIRST President's Circle videos that Paul Gudonis mentioned during his kickoff speech.

[dlavery]

The game animation is a copyrighted product. Unless you have received permission explicitly permitting you to do so, you do not have permission to re-host or re-distribute that material. If you are doing so, it should be removed immediately.

Again, the reason that we are making this point is not to be unnecessarily pedantic about copyright rules. It is to make the point that the rules do exist, and as consummate professionals it is our responsibility to act within them. A violation of a rule is a violation of a rule - no matter how small.

-dave

[richalex2010]

Who would we contact to receive permission, and/or to provide suggestions for licensing?

I'll need to do a bit of research that would allow it to be freely redistributed by anyone, but not modified in any way and with all intellectual property rights still belonging to FIRST. Hopefully, if a new licensing stance were taken, it would produce a win-win situation.

On a similar note, FIRST appears to pick and choose where the copyright issues are applied. It seems to me that use of anything, including the FIRST logo, brochures, etc., should not be allowed for any redistribution, yet it is available for anyone to use for such applications. This, by my understanding, should be in violation of the copyright rule, but yet it is promoted. If someone could tell me what the issue is here (different license, something else, etc.), that would be helpful.

Again, based on the rules applied (internally, by FIRST) to some files (manual, animation), nothing should be allowed to be used on anything not published *and* distributed by FIRST.
However, based on the rules that FIRST applies (internally) to other materials (logos, brochures, etc.), everything should be able to be used on websites, in promotional material, and generally spread over the web and the real world as much as possible.

I don't write this as a flame or anything like that, just to (hopefully) provoke thought. Also, please don't forget the question at the beginning of the post.

Respectfully,
-Jake Alexander

[fimmel]

along with this. im the webmaster for my team and id like to put the game animation on there. how do i get permission to do this or can i just put it up? also what about the overdrive logo and other FIRST graphics and videos? where is the line drawn for teams promoting first through their website and copyright infringement.


not to start a flame war but this is getting carried away. FIRST has asked us to help let the public become informed about FIRST, if we cant rebroadcast the video and such what are we supposed to do? make our own game animation and make it available to share? idk (if this offends anyone let me know but its something that should be said)

...forest