2008 G23

[jgannon]

There are no provisions for giving penalties for <G23>, so 1 appears to be no.

2 is questionable... yes seems sensible, but I would double-check that on Q&A. The problem there is that any other way of handling the situation would just be making up rules... there are no additional penalties for continuing clockwise after you've broken the plane of the line.

3 is definitely no. Being pushed into the next quadrant is not a penalty, and thus has nothing to do with <G23>. Regardless of how you crossed a line, if under your own power you break the plane of a line you've already crossed, you run afoul of the direction-of-traffic rule.

[ALIBI]

Originally Posted by jgannon

There are no provisions for giving penalties for <G23>, so 1 appears to be no.

2 is questionable... yes seems sensible, but I would double-check that on Q&A. The problem there is that any other way of handling the situation would just be making up rules... there are no additional penalties for continuing clockwise after you've broken the plane of the line.

3 is definitely no. Being pushed into the next quadrant is not a penalty, and thus has nothing to do with <G23>. Regardless of how you crossed a line, if under your own power you break the plane of a line you've already crossed, you run afoul of the direction-of-traffic rule.

1: Appears to be mostly good for bots playing deffense.
2: Appears to be mostly good for bots playing offense.
3: Appears to be very good for bots playing deffense.

I would agree with your insight. Thankyou!