Update 11

[EricH]

Update #11 is out.

The good news: NO RULE CHANGES! Just two or three pieces of information that may be useful to some teams out there...

[GaryVoshol]

Of course there's no rule changes. We have to wait for ThunderChickens and Wildstang to get to their first competitions.

[Leav]

Originally Posted by GaryVoshol

Of course there's no rule changes. We have to wait for ThunderChickens and Wildstang to get to their first competitions.

please enlighten me...

do they usually do something so out of the intent of the rules yet legal that the GDC have to change the rules AFTER the ship date?

has this ever happened?

-Leav

[EricH]

Originally Posted by Leav

please enlighten me...

do they usually do something so out of the intent of the rules yet legal that the GDC have to change the rules AFTER the ship date?

has this ever happened?

-Leav

No robots starting on top of other robots, last year. (Wildstang strategy)

Rules have changed post-ship-date. Look up the 2002 rules/updates, and the furor over tape-measure tethers. (not one of the referenced teams)

[GaryVoshol]

The ThunderChickens reference was to whether teams could or could not bring power tools (bandsaws, etc) with them to competitions. That changed back and forth last year.

[Richard Wallace]

Originally Posted by vhcook

... I'm deeply curious what Thunderchickens did to get a game-breaker reputation.

They did no such thing. Their reputation is among the best in FIRST.

The Thunderchickens have a trailer in which they have transported machine tools to several FRC events, at which they have allowed other teams to use them. This generous and gracious act got them in trouble during Week 1 last season, due to concerns about venue restrictions and potential liability. Nothing dangerous actually happened, but the incident resulted in a more clearly stated FIRST policy regarding power tools. You can find that policy in the 2008 FRC Manual, Sections 3.9.13 and 3.9.14.

[vhcook]

I beg your pardon, and theirs. That didn't come out quite the way I meant it to.

[Dave Flowerday]

Originally Posted by EricH

No robots starting on top of other robots, last year. (Wildstang strategy)

Just to be clear, the play that we made last year of having our alliance partners form a stack before the match was completely legal, and specifically identified as such by a Q&A asked during the season (asked by another team). We did not bend the rules in any way, shape, or form by this move.

After this happened, FIRST reversed their decision and said this was no longer legal.

[Leav]

Originally Posted by Dave Flowerday

Just to be clear, the play that we made last year of having our alliance partners form a stack before the match was completely legal, and specifically identified as such by a Q&A asked during the season (asked by another team). We did not bend the rules in any way, shape, or form by this move.

After this happened, FIRST reversed their decision and said this was no longer legal.

Cool! did you just wait in the home zone until match ends or did you have a sort of power-rangers style megzord robot with two manipulators?



-Leav

[Vikesrock]

Originally Posted by Leav

Cool! did you just wait in the home zone until match ends or did you have a sort of power-rangers style megzord robot with two manipulators?



-Leav

The stacked robots both immediately E-stopped and Wildstang proceeded to outscore the other alliance by themselves even without the bonus.

http://www.thebluealliance.net/tbatv...p?matchid=1735

[JaneYoung]

Originally Posted by Dave Flowerday

Just to be clear, the play that we made last year of having our alliance partners form a stack before the match was completely legal, and specifically identified as such by a Q&A asked during the season (asked by another team). We did not bend the rules in any way, shape, or form by this move.

After this happened, FIRST reversed their decision and said this was no longer legal.

It was a total jaw dropper when it occurred and made me realize anew how important coaching/strategy/and continuing to play the game is and how it can affect the outcome.

It is one of the defining moments that I still think about from 2007.

The Thunder Chickens mobile machine shop is another one. Excellence on wheels.

[thefro526]

I remember seeing the video of Wildstangs alliance and though zomg that's a pretty cool way to guarantee 30 points. I like how they specified the legality of the '07 controller so now most vet's will have a spare.

[catsylve]

It is amazingly cool to share the field with teams like Wildstang and the Thunderchickens. They were really graceful to us as a rookie team last year and made us feel at home. Actually, the little plastic chicken trophy we were given by the Thunderchickens is our teams favorite piece of memorabilia. (AND it squeaks! )

The effort that Wildstang went to in helping to get films made for the Blue Alliance has benefited a LOT of teams.

Make no mistake, these are some of the teams that make up the backbone of FIRST and their creativity on the field and off has benefited a ton of kids. That's what is important.

[Richard McClellan]

I'm a little surprised that they didn't have much follow up to the IR board issues that were mentioned in Team Update #10. There's a link to the master code, but no instructions on how to download it to the actual IR board.

Our IR board did experience the symptoms described in Update 10, but we were able to reflash the firmware after reading the posts on CD about it. But shouldn't these download instructions (with an ICSP cable) be documented on the FIRST website as well?

[Swan217]

Originally Posted by GaryVoshol

Of course there's no rule changes. We have to wait for ThunderChickens and Wildstang to get to their first competitions.

Well, to be honest, Team 217 has taken credit for a number of rule additions. Off the top of my head sharing credit for the "no air horns" rule after their "21 air horn salute" and "no food given away as swag" rule made after Peeps in eggs and "chicken feed" were tossed out and ended up all over the arena.

Game rule-wise, in '06 217 was responsible for relaxing "incidental contact" rules after 30 pt penalties got out of hand in Week 1. I'd have to ask their resident historian for a few others I'm forgetting...