NJ Elim Yellow Card Oddity

[Kevin Sevcik]

Originally Posted by Spikey

This has been around for awhile. During 2005 at the Philadelphia Regional our alliance partner received a red card during the finals. As a result our entire alliance was DQed and our alliance was given a loss instead of penalty points. The rules for the Playoffs have always applied alliance wide vs. Team wide. I must I saw shocked when it happened to us 3 years ago, and I was pretty pissed.

Sadly I don't have sympathy when the entire alliance got carded, at least they got to keep playing. I think its a silly rule, but its been around for awhile..

The entire Elim Alliance being DQ'd for a red card is very clearly spelled out in T11. Similarly in reply to Dan, T11 doesn't mention a thing about yellow cards or any cards applying to an entire alliance. Just that a red card DQ's the whole alliance, because just DQing one team wouldn't make sense. I agree that this rule is from whence the confusion sprang, but I don't think there's any reasonable way of reading it like this.