Lessons Learned - The Negative

[Steve_Alaniz]

Originally Posted by EricH

Steve, when does FIRST change your status from "rookie" to veteran? Right after the Championship, right, at least officially? I.e., at the end of the season? So, logically, the year begins in late April. Therefore, summer counts.

But when does the "rookie" status begin? That is a tough question. When you sign up as an FRC team? Then you have a wide spread of time for rookies to get something going. When registration opens, all teams that haven't competed before are rookies? That would be more fair, but then you have a gap of several months with no rookies, only "pre-rookies". Right after Championship, when the previous rookies are now veterans (sophomore-type)? That makes more sense, but they're still "pre-rookies" all through the summer.

It's a tough call, and not one I'd want to make.

Eric,
No according to FIRST a rookie is a team that is competing in their first SEASON with FIRST and the SEASON, as defined BY FIRST, starts at kickoff. SO logically it cannot stretch back to the previous April. You are a rookie in the same way baseball players are rookies... until the start of the next season. But the in between time is undefined as far as I can tell.
I agree with you it is confusing and that is part of the problem and exactly what I was trying to say. It's definitely a tough call to make and you make some very valid points that highlight that confusion.
I must also admit that this whole thing may just be Bad writing on the part of Woodie's speech writer. Perhaps only the season was considered by the judges.
I nitpick when it comes to wording. Let's just call it a bad habit.