Lessons Learned - The Negative

[EricH]

Originally Posted by Steve_Alaniz

You are a rookie in the same way baseball players are rookies... until the start of the next season. But the in between time is undefined as far as I can tell.
I agree with you it is confusing and that is part of the problem and exactly what I was trying to say. It's definitely a tough call to make and you make some very valid points that highlight that confusion.
I must also admit that this whole thing may just be Bad writing on the part of Woodie's speech writer. Perhaps only the season was considered by the judges.
I nitpick when it comes to wording. Let's just call it a bad habit.

Poor analogy, Steve, due to having to play x games to not be a rookie in MLB (i.e., if you have to play 70 MLB games to be a non-rookie, then you can play 68, get injured, and still get Rookie of the Year the next year.) But I'll take it at face value--you're a rookie until your second season or declared otherwise.

I also have that habit, so no comment there.

And yeah, it is very confusing. Let's say that a team goes through 4 stages. It may not go through all of them, but here they are, along with an approximate timeframe:

1. Pre-rookie. Did not compete in FRC the previous year, it's their first year coming up, and the season hasn't started. For simplicity, they become rookies on Kickoff, though they have a number previously.
2. Rookie. Kickoff through Championship/other final official event of the season. Please note: EVERY year that I can remember, Dean or Woodie tells the rookies for the year that they are now veterans at some point during award ceremonies.
3. Sophomore-class. Starts right after the Rookie status ends and continues for a year or two. (Years end at Championship now.)
4. Veteran. 3+ years under their belts.

Note that it's easy to jump stages; I would count 2753 as sophomore-class after they won NJ, and a full veteran now. Most other teams their age would be sophomore-class right now.

The problem is that FIRST doesn't define exactly when a team goes between pre-rookie and rookie, effectively. They also don't use the full spread, confining themselves to 2 and 4.

If you start as a pre-rookie after it's completely impossible to get into the event, anything after you start is fair game in my book.