fine control of robot with mecanum wheels

[JamJam263]

Originally Posted by Ether

Correct.

I'd like to hear from any teams that have implemented closed-loop wheel speed control via encoders connected directly to Jags, on a bot with mecanum wheels.

~

Team 263 is using exactly that. We found that the voltage control in an open loop was way too unreliable. Each wheel is directly hooked to a AM tougbox, with an encoder directly connected to the Jaguar that controls it. Using CAN speed control made everything more reliable, no drifting and a lot better traction control. The 1kHZ PID loop in the Jags helped use tremendously. Out of 60 Teams in NYC we where the only ones using CAN, and had quite a few comments from other teams using mecanum on how much better it preformed. The only issue that was not directly fixed with CAN and the built in PID was control at lower speeds. To fix this we simply used the throttle on the joystick to make an adjustable scale where setRPM=joystick*throttle*maxRPM. With adding the throttle everything worked without any issues. Using the throttle to make an adjustable scale works for voltage control, and a PID loop can easily be set up with the encoders hooked to the cRio in a short period of time. Actually switching our C++ code from an open system using pwm to CAN didn't take us more then an hour, neither did setting up the CAN network itself if you have the cables to do it.