Karthik: Effective FIRST Strategies 2010

[ExTexan]

I am really looking forward to your discussion.

I'll probably spend a good amount of time discussing the current scoring and ranking system and the various strategies and the ethical issues associated with them.

I just threw these numbers together and I'm sure there is much more depth than this but at the Michigan State Championship with 65 teams:

Seeding rankings 13, 14, 15, 17, and 18 were not selected for the top 24.

Seeding rankings 44, 45, 47, 48, and 62 were selected in the top 24 with 45 as the fourth pick and 62 selected by the top seeded alliance and eventual victors.

I apologize if my numbers or team numbers are incorrect but it certainly speaks to the seeding rankings. Huge importance for top 8.....much less for the rest of the pack.

[Tom Line]

I'm not surprised the picks went that way. There are completely different criteria and weighting for the second pick than there are the first.

Generally speaking, the second pick is a defensive pick. Therefore, many robots get thrown out of the mix simply becuase of small things like their lack of acceleration, speed, or traction. Those robots may be excellent offensive bots, but no-so-good defensive ones.

[Wayne TenBrink]

[quote=ExTexan;948397]

Seeding rankings 44, 45, 47, 48, and 62 were selected in the top 24 with 45 as the fourth pick and 62 selected by the top seeded alliance and eventual victors.


Hmmmm. I'm getting off topic, but this is the first I've heard this. I'm not in charge of scouting, but it goes to show how low the importance of seeding rank is when looking for a good 2nd pick partner. Never despair.

I would be interested to hear what JVN has to say. The difficulty and importance of scouting is underrated by so many. I think some of our students consider it is a form of punishment.

[The Lucas]

Originally Posted by Wayne TenBrink

I would be interested to hear what JVN has to say. The difficulty and importance of scouting is underrated by so many. I think some of our students consider it is a form of punishment.

I'm sure JVN will say something (usually heckling from the back) but Karthik will be talking for most of the strategy presentation. JVN's panel is afterwards in the same room (come early get a good seat for all the presentations).

"Scouting is not a punishment" is an important point of Karthik's presentation. Making strategy fun for my team is my focus since I attended Karthik talk a few years ago. His talk inspires you to improve your approach to strategy.
Examples of improvements my team made:
-More technology usage
-Getting to know the team you are scouting
-More lively Friday night meetings
-Fantasy FIRST Draft for the strategy team before the event w/ prizes for winners.