Autocad -vs- Cadkey

[DaBruteForceGuy]

Today i heard a statistic that upsets me to the fullest. Now the first part wasn't that surprising and it was that AUTOCAD is the #1 rated computer drawing tool in the country. Now the second part was the one that frustarted me. It was that CADKEY (the most primitive and overall most EVIL programm ever created) was rated #2!!!!!!
To me this is outragous and i dread the future. Now i am in highschool and will probably go to some division of enjineering for my career. When i heard that there is a good chance i will be working with CADKEY i almost dropped out of all of my enjineering pursuits altogether.
If anybody has any thoughts or oppinions on this matter, show them to us because it is for the best of all CADing kind!

[Rob Colatutto]

cadkey is just so high because its very simple, so schools can use it to teach it to 9th graders, thats what my school did and then you can learn autocad in 11th or 12th, i learned it on my own however

[Elgin Clock]

EChhh to CADKEY!!! I use AutoCad, Solidworks and MDT5 once in a while and I prefer Autocad for simple drawings, Solidworks for making solids for presentations and MDT5 just to print stuff that AutoCAD won't!! lol

AutoCAD is by far the easiest CAD software to cheat at!!! Thank goodness for explode!! hehehe!!

The actual drawing feature in Solidworks just stinks in my opinion, hence only being used for presentations or prototyping!

I have not used CADKEY in 2 years since I took the class in college, thank goodness!

[Clark Gilbert]

I voted for AutoCad, but i also use Inventor (dont "use" it much but i'm good w/ it) and i use Solid Edge...

[Sachiel7]

Well Guys this coming 2003 year we're gonna be getting AutoDesk Inventor Series 6...
I tinkered with it at the camp....
It will change your view on autodesk.

[Jack]

i'm taking a cad class right now, and i can't see how it is that hard to learn. In fact, i think that it is VERY easy. (Especially after taking a year of drafting)

Now, i might have some advantage because i'm good with computers, and know 3ds max (which is A LOT harder than cad to make 2d splines) but, cad is still easy.

[Andy Baker]

Gimme my Unigraphics V18 and my Spaceball and I am a happy designer.

Andy B. (UG user since V7)

[CAD-Demigod45]

I think AutoCad is better. Other programs like inventor are easy, but they suck if there are several people on the project.

[Joel Glidden]

ProEngineer

-Joel

[ChrisH]

Originally posted by Andy Baker
Gimme my Unigraphics V18 and my Spaceball and I am a happy designer.

Andy B. (UG user since V7)

Spaceballs are wonderful things. Supposedly they have a driver for AutoCad, but I haven't been desperate enough to get one for home (robotics) yet.

I'm fluent in UG and AutoCad, Semi-literate in Inventor and CATIA 4 and learning CATIA 5 soon (unfortunately, it doesn't seem to be all that much better than CATIA 4, though it does look spiffier).

Working in too many CAD systems with not enough time in any one is confusing at times to say the least. Now just where did they put that BOOLEAN command? I KNOW it's got to be here somewhere!

[Adam Y.]

Now the second part was the one that frustarted me. It was that CADKEY (the most primitive and overall most EVIL programm ever created) was rated #2!!!!!!

It doesn't seem that primitive and not even that evil to me. It is probably one of the easiest programs I have ever used. It is just like drafting on the screen. The only thing that annoyed the me about it was the fact that the undo button never really seems to work.

[Ryan Dognaux]

All I know is Inventor cause that's all I've used for the past 2 seasons. Now I'm in the Project Lead the Way class at our school, and it's teaching inventor. I tried to use AutoCAD a few times... but it was too command based for me, I like to be able to click things and BAM it's done. I bet Inventor will eventually climb to that #2 most used spot... companies just have to figure out that it's really, really easy to use

[Aaron Lussier]

Originally posted by Joel Glidden
ProEngineer

-Joel

Oh yea, Pro-E is the way to go, I have the student version on my computer, but right now I'm taking an Auto-CAD class with Auto CAD 2004, Argg.. 2-D.

[Gadget470]

Originally posted by Aaron Lussier
Argg.. 2-D.

Aaron: AutoCAD isn't really that good for 3-D graphics but it's quick, easy, and mostly to the point for 2-D. At work (Comau Pico) I use AutoCAD R14 (We're planning a switch to 2004 sometime). All 3-D Work is done with SolidWorks.

If you are using AutoCAD, you should be using it to make details and 3-way views of things. It's not to often that you'll really need 3-D models with A_CAD. Besides, converting a 3D to a 2D is a PAIN in A_CAD.

When I got my job, I had spent the last 6 months training the crap out of myself to learn AutoCAD 2002's 3D Features. I've built a full-scale model (accurate to 1mm) of 470's 2003 robot, as well as some other projects. I have not once needed to make anything in 3D with AutoCAD yet.

My advice to you: Learn Solidworks for 3D, AutoCAD for 2D (If you plan to get a job in the design business, Baker: Back me up?). You will become an asset to many companies if they don't need to train you.

[Raven_Writer]

I've used AutoCAD, and find it kinda big all those buttons.

One of team 5's engineers use Pro-E and another uses AutoCAD. Pro-E is like a stripped-down version of AC IMO.

I prefer Pro over AutoCAD