OCCRA
Go to Post We are different, on purpose, for a reason. No one in FIRST should EVER forget that. - Rich Kressly [more]
Home
Go Back   Chief Delphi > Technical > Technical Discussion
CD-Media  
portal register members calendar search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read FAQ rules

 
Reply
Thread Tools Rate Thread Display Modes
  #1   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 11-01-2018, 04:21 AM
Noah Bamberger Noah Bamberger is offline
Registered User
FRC #5970 (Beavertronics)
Team Role: CAD
 
Join Date: Apr 2018
Rookie Year: 2016
Location: Oregon
Posts: 20
Noah Bamberger is an unknown quantity at this point
Using steel gears in the 3 cim ball shifters from vexpro

My team has noticed some very significant wear on the 50t gear in the 3 cim ball shifters that meshes with the cim pinions. My theory is that this is because it is aluminum and the cim pinions are steel, so it would wear faster. As it itself does not mesh with any aluminum gears, would it be worth it to replace it with a steel gear of the same size? We have some lying around from AndyMark. What might be some problems with this if any?
Reply With Quote
  #2   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 11-01-2018, 05:39 AM
electroken's Avatar
electroken electroken is offline
Electron Tamer
AKA: Ken Pontbriant
FRC #0230 (Gaelhawks)
Team Role: Mentor
 
Join Date: Jan 2012
Rookie Year: 2012
Location: Shelton, CT
Posts: 248
electroken is a jewel in the roughelectroken is a jewel in the roughelectroken is a jewel in the roughelectroken is a jewel in the rough
Re: Using steel gears in the 3 cim ball shifters from vexpro

You would have no problem with the swap unless your robot was already 120.0 pounds at inspection. The primary reason for using an aluminum gear in place of steel is weight reduction. I suppose one could argue that an aluminum gear would also be easier to machine if you were making your own.

We've used aluminum gears in the drive train of several of our more portly machines and haven't worn one out yet during the machine's <10 hour operational life.
Reply With Quote
  #3   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 11-01-2018, 08:40 AM
cbale2000's Avatar
cbale2000 cbale2000 is offline
Registered User
AKA: Chris Bale
FRC #5712 (Gray Matter)
Team Role: Mentor
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Rookie Year: 2004
Location: Saginaw, MI
Posts: 1,665
cbale2000 has a reputation beyond reputecbale2000 has a reputation beyond reputecbale2000 has a reputation beyond reputecbale2000 has a reputation beyond reputecbale2000 has a reputation beyond reputecbale2000 has a reputation beyond reputecbale2000 has a reputation beyond reputecbale2000 has a reputation beyond reputecbale2000 has a reputation beyond reputecbale2000 has a reputation beyond reputecbale2000 has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Using steel gears in the 3 cim ball shifters from vexpro

Quote:
Originally Posted by Noah Bamberger View Post
My team has noticed some very significant wear on the 50t gear in the 3 cim ball shifters that meshes with the cim pinions. My theory is that this is because it is aluminum and the cim pinions are steel, so it would wear faster. As it itself does not mesh with any aluminum gears, would it be worth it to replace it with a steel gear of the same size? We have some lying around from AndyMark. What might be some problems with this if any?
Out of curiosity, what lubricant are you using in your gearboxes? I've used 3 CIM Ball Shifters for about 5 years and never had any noticeable wear of the aluminum gears inside them. Also, what ratios are you using (including external reductions and wheel diameter)? This may also be a factor.

If you're not already using it, I STRONGLY recommend using Lucas Oil Products Red "N" Tacky #2 Grease. It stays on the gears far better than regular White Lithium grease, and, when applied liberally, in my experience typically doesn't need to be reapplied throughout the season (though it never hurts).
__________________
2005-2008: FRC 703 Phoenix - Robot Driver
2009-2016: FRC 703 Phoenix - Mentor
2017-????: FRC 5712 Gray Matter - Mentor

Last edited by cbale2000 : 11-01-2018 at 08:50 AM.
Reply With Quote
  #4   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 11-01-2018, 10:40 AM
nuclearnerd's Avatar
nuclearnerd nuclearnerd is offline
Speaking for myself, not my team
AKA: Brendan Simons
FRC #5406 (Celt-X)
Team Role: Engineer
 
Join Date: Jan 2014
Rookie Year: 2014
Location: Hamilton, Ontario, Canada
Posts: 889
nuclearnerd has a reputation beyond reputenuclearnerd has a reputation beyond reputenuclearnerd has a reputation beyond reputenuclearnerd has a reputation beyond reputenuclearnerd has a reputation beyond reputenuclearnerd has a reputation beyond reputenuclearnerd has a reputation beyond reputenuclearnerd has a reputation beyond reputenuclearnerd has a reputation beyond reputenuclearnerd has a reputation beyond reputenuclearnerd has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Using steel gears in the 3 cim ball shifters from vexpro

We have seen serious wear on the 50t first stage gear in 3 cim ball shifters. We had to replace that gear at least once during each of the two seasons we used them as drive gearboxes.

We used the steel pinions on the motors. Aluminum pinions might have been kinder, or they might have worn out too. The gearboxes were stuffed with lubricant.

I think replacing it with a steel gear (like this https://www.andymark.com/Gear-p/am-0149.htm) is a wise choice.
Attached Thumbnails
Click image for larger version

Name:	stripped gears.jpg
Views:	223
Size:	700.3 KB
ID:	23645  
Reply With Quote
  #5   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 11-01-2018, 11:38 AM
cbale2000's Avatar
cbale2000 cbale2000 is offline
Registered User
AKA: Chris Bale
FRC #5712 (Gray Matter)
Team Role: Mentor
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Rookie Year: 2004
Location: Saginaw, MI
Posts: 1,665
cbale2000 has a reputation beyond reputecbale2000 has a reputation beyond reputecbale2000 has a reputation beyond reputecbale2000 has a reputation beyond reputecbale2000 has a reputation beyond reputecbale2000 has a reputation beyond reputecbale2000 has a reputation beyond reputecbale2000 has a reputation beyond reputecbale2000 has a reputation beyond reputecbale2000 has a reputation beyond reputecbale2000 has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Using steel gears in the 3 cim ball shifters from vexpro

One other thing that just occurred to me, another way to reduce wear on a gearbox is to implement an acceleration "ramp" in the robot code to prevent backlash due to sudden direction changes. If done properly, the driver won't notice the difference but your gearbox definitely will.

I still can't figure out what could be causing you guys to have issues with these gearboxes. This year we ran our gearboxes at 2 districts, district champs, worlds, and 2 off-season events with one of the most aggressive (high speed) reductions I've ever tried, and every time I've opened up the gearboxes for inspection the ceramic coating is barely even warn off the 50t gears.
__________________
2005-2008: FRC 703 Phoenix - Robot Driver
2009-2016: FRC 703 Phoenix - Mentor
2017-????: FRC 5712 Gray Matter - Mentor

Last edited by cbale2000 : 11-01-2018 at 11:45 AM.
Reply With Quote
  #6   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 11-01-2018, 02:58 PM
Noah Bamberger Noah Bamberger is offline
Registered User
FRC #5970 (Beavertronics)
Team Role: CAD
 
Join Date: Apr 2018
Rookie Year: 2016
Location: Oregon
Posts: 20
Noah Bamberger is an unknown quantity at this point
Re: Using steel gears in the 3 cim ball shifters from vexpro

Quote:
Originally Posted by cbale2000 View Post
One other thing that just occurred to me, another way to reduce wear on a gearbox is to implement an acceleration "ramp" in the robot code to prevent backlash due to sudden direction changes. If done properly, the driver won't notice the difference but your gearbox definitely will.

I still can't figure out what could be causing you guys to have issues with these gearboxes. This year we ran our gearboxes at 2 districts, district champs, worlds, and 2 off-season events with one of the most aggressive (high speed) reductions I've ever tried, and every time I've opened up the gearboxes for inspection the ceramic coating is barely even warn off the 50t gears.
Itís possible that we didnít grease them enough but they wore out after one season of (very) aggressive driving in steamworks through world champs and countless outreach events and lots of driving practice. I think in the future we will use the steel gears for the first stage and also regressed after at least district competitions.
Reply With Quote
  #7   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 11-01-2018, 03:02 PM
Noah Bamberger Noah Bamberger is offline
Registered User
FRC #5970 (Beavertronics)
Team Role: CAD
 
Join Date: Apr 2018
Rookie Year: 2016
Location: Oregon
Posts: 20
Noah Bamberger is an unknown quantity at this point
Re: Using steel gears in the 3 cim ball shifters from vexpro

Quote:
Originally Posted by cbale2000 View Post
One other thing that just occurred to me, another way to reduce wear on a gearbox is to implement an acceleration "ramp" in the robot code to prevent backlash due to sudden direction changes. If done properly, the driver won't notice the difference but your gearbox definitely will.

Additionally, how would you go about calculating the acceleration for this ramp?
Reply With Quote
  #8   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 11-01-2018, 03:40 PM
cbale2000's Avatar
cbale2000 cbale2000 is offline
Registered User
AKA: Chris Bale
FRC #5712 (Gray Matter)
Team Role: Mentor
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Rookie Year: 2004
Location: Saginaw, MI
Posts: 1,665
cbale2000 has a reputation beyond reputecbale2000 has a reputation beyond reputecbale2000 has a reputation beyond reputecbale2000 has a reputation beyond reputecbale2000 has a reputation beyond reputecbale2000 has a reputation beyond reputecbale2000 has a reputation beyond reputecbale2000 has a reputation beyond reputecbale2000 has a reputation beyond reputecbale2000 has a reputation beyond reputecbale2000 has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Using steel gears in the 3 cim ball shifters from vexpro

Quote:
Originally Posted by Noah Bamberger View Post
Additionally, how would you go about calculating the acceleration for this ramp?
Honestly, for us it's just been a lot of trial and error. You see what your driver can tolerate and make sure the ramp doesn't create too much control latency; a "sloppy" ramp can create a delay between control input and robot reaction, which can cause you to run into things you didn't intend to. That said, a properly tuned ramp can actually make your robot easier for your driver to control (not to mention it tends to make top-heavy robots slightly harder to tip).

If your programmers already use a ramp for accel/decel autonomous control (it seems like many teams do), that can be a good starting point.

It doesn't take much to eliminate the effects of backlash, so even if the ramp is barely noticeable to your driver it's still MUCH better than your motors slamming from +5000rpm to -5000rpm in a fraction of a second like un-ramped controls do.
__________________
2005-2008: FRC 703 Phoenix - Robot Driver
2009-2016: FRC 703 Phoenix - Mentor
2017-????: FRC 5712 Gray Matter - Mentor
Reply With Quote
  #9   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 11-01-2018, 03:46 PM
nuclearnerd's Avatar
nuclearnerd nuclearnerd is offline
Speaking for myself, not my team
AKA: Brendan Simons
FRC #5406 (Celt-X)
Team Role: Engineer
 
Join Date: Jan 2014
Rookie Year: 2014
Location: Hamilton, Ontario, Canada
Posts: 889
nuclearnerd has a reputation beyond reputenuclearnerd has a reputation beyond reputenuclearnerd has a reputation beyond reputenuclearnerd has a reputation beyond reputenuclearnerd has a reputation beyond reputenuclearnerd has a reputation beyond reputenuclearnerd has a reputation beyond reputenuclearnerd has a reputation beyond reputenuclearnerd has a reputation beyond reputenuclearnerd has a reputation beyond reputenuclearnerd has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Using steel gears in the 3 cim ball shifters from vexpro

Voltage ramping is a great way to reduce the current draw on your robot, and reduce the chances for browning out, but I'm not convinced it will increase the life of your gearbox. The failures we saw were not individual tooth failures caused by overload. Rather they were gradual wear, first through the anodizing and then through the aluminum until the teeth are gone. Certainly load on the gears affects the wear rate, but the ramping only affects a small portion of the duty cycle.
Reply With Quote
  #10   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 11-02-2018, 12:42 AM
Delr!n's Avatar
Delr!n Delr!n is offline
775pro serial killer
AKA: Joshua Isakson
FRC #0997 (Spartan Robotics)
Team Role: CAD
 
Join Date: Dec 2017
Rookie Year: 2017
Location: Oregon
Posts: 24
Delr!n is a glorious beacon of lightDelr!n is a glorious beacon of lightDelr!n is a glorious beacon of lightDelr!n is a glorious beacon of lightDelr!n is a glorious beacon of light
Re: Using steel gears in the 3 cim ball shifters from vexpro

Having never used the 3 cim ball shifter(we do custom) take everything i say with a grain of salt.

The only time we've ever worn out gears in our drive train was on our practice robot in 2018 because we never greased them. other then that we have never worn out aluminum gears. id check your grease i saw someone else posted about using red n tacky id go with that or what we use is white lithium grease.

Edit:in 2017 we did see a vary small amount of wear on the first stage of our gearbox(3 cim single speed geared for 17ish? f/s) by the end of season(2 districts a dcmp worlds and an off season event) but it was negligible.

Last edited by Delr!n : 11-02-2018 at 12:49 AM.
Reply With Quote
  #11   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 11-02-2018, 08:47 AM
cbale2000's Avatar
cbale2000 cbale2000 is offline
Registered User
AKA: Chris Bale
FRC #5712 (Gray Matter)
Team Role: Mentor
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Rookie Year: 2004
Location: Saginaw, MI
Posts: 1,665
cbale2000 has a reputation beyond reputecbale2000 has a reputation beyond reputecbale2000 has a reputation beyond reputecbale2000 has a reputation beyond reputecbale2000 has a reputation beyond reputecbale2000 has a reputation beyond reputecbale2000 has a reputation beyond reputecbale2000 has a reputation beyond reputecbale2000 has a reputation beyond reputecbale2000 has a reputation beyond reputecbale2000 has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Using steel gears in the 3 cim ball shifters from vexpro

Out of curiosity, Noah and Brendan, were either of your teams using 11t pinion gears on your CIM motors? While, in theory, the radius should be the same, the slight reduction in teeth might cause more undercutting of the 50t gear than a standard 12t pinion would, which might result in additional wear.

Just a thought.

As far as ramping affecting gearbox wear goes, my thought was less in regard to "overloading", which, as you indicated, would result in lost teeth rather than even wear; my concern was more in regard to the gear teeth slamming into each other during any sudden change of direction in the motors, the impact of any one of these actions would be minimal, but over time would likely cause more wear on the gears than a more gentle transition between directions would.

Have either of your teams contacted VEX about these issues? They might be able to provide better insight as to the possible cause of these problems. The rest of us are basically just making educated guesses, but they'll have a LOT more experience dealing with these sort of issues than any of us will, and their customer service and technical support (in my experience at least) is great.
__________________
2005-2008: FRC 703 Phoenix - Robot Driver
2009-2016: FRC 703 Phoenix - Mentor
2017-????: FRC 5712 Gray Matter - Mentor
Reply With Quote
  #12   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 11-02-2018, 04:18 PM
hrench's Avatar
hrench hrench is offline
mechanical build mentor
AKA: Bob Hrenchir
FRC #1108 (Panther Robotics)
Team Role: Mentor
 
Join Date: Jan 2012
Rookie Year: 2010
Location: Paola, KS
Posts: 385
hrench has a brilliant futurehrench has a brilliant futurehrench has a brilliant futurehrench has a brilliant futurehrench has a brilliant futurehrench has a brilliant futurehrench has a brilliant futurehrench has a brilliant futurehrench has a brilliant futurehrench has a brilliant futurehrench has a brilliant future
Re: Using steel gears in the 3 cim ball shifters from vexpro

I learned gear design equations, specifically Tooth Capacity in Contact Stress or Wear/Surface Durability rely on the ratio of the Modulus of Elasticity of a bull gear to a pinion gear. Design of Machine Elements, by MF Spotts.

Very often in real products designed for long-term durability, you'll want a softer tooth pinion turning a harder tooth bull gear. Why sometimes you'll see brass gears turning steel gears.

As for use in robotics, where the life of the gears is usually less than 100 hours a season (a guess) I'm not sure this applies, but for students reading this, it's a useful fact to know.
Reply With Quote
  #13   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 11-02-2018, 04:32 PM
Marcus Q Marcus Q is online now
Reversible bumpers are my trigger
AKA: Marcus Quintilian
FRC #5406 (Celt-X)
Team Role: Mechanical
 
Join Date: Mar 2012
Rookie Year: 2012
Location: Toronto
Posts: 1,611
Marcus Q has a reputation beyond reputeMarcus Q has a reputation beyond reputeMarcus Q has a reputation beyond reputeMarcus Q has a reputation beyond reputeMarcus Q has a reputation beyond reputeMarcus Q has a reputation beyond reputeMarcus Q has a reputation beyond reputeMarcus Q has a reputation beyond reputeMarcus Q has a reputation beyond reputeMarcus Q has a reputation beyond reputeMarcus Q has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Using steel gears in the 3 cim ball shifters from vexpro

I've only ever seen significant wear on the the ball shifter gears when used with steel pinions. If aluminium gears were the issue then why don't we see significant wear on the 2nd stage? Additionally since it's 3 steel pinions on one aluminium gear that's 3x the wear of a normal gear reduction with steel exasperating the effect even more. Aluminium pinions are really the preferable choice. With the drive train forces divided over 3 pinions breakage shouldn't be an issue.
__________________
2012-2015: 865 Warp7 Team Captain
2016/17: Free Agent Mentor
2018-present: 5406 Celt-X

Last edited by Marcus Q : 11-02-2018 at 04:35 PM.
Reply With Quote
  #14   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 11-03-2018, 10:41 AM
wgorgen's Avatar
wgorgen wgorgen is offline
Registered User
FRC #1533 (Triple Strange)
Team Role: Mentor
 
Join Date: Apr 2018
Rookie Year: 2014
Location: Greensboro, NC, USA
Posts: 146
wgorgen is a splendid one to beholdwgorgen is a splendid one to beholdwgorgen is a splendid one to beholdwgorgen is a splendid one to beholdwgorgen is a splendid one to beholdwgorgen is a splendid one to beholdwgorgen is a splendid one to behold
Re: Using steel gears in the 3 cim ball shifters from vexpro

In general, I would say that using steel gears would work just fine.

But you might be chasing a problem to the next weakest link. So it would be better to try to understand the root of the problem (pun intended) and try to address that.

Make sure you have the right gear ratios as cbale noted:

Quote:
Originally Posted by cbale2000 View Post
Out of curiosity, Noah and Brendan, were either of your teams using 11t pinion gears on your CIM motors? While, in theory, the radius should be the same, the slight reduction in teeth might cause more undercutting of the 50t gear than a standard 12t pinion would, which might result in additional wear.
It is possible to get the wrong sized pinion. It will mesh "good enough" that, to the naked eye, you may not notice that the mesh is wrong.

The other common problem that I have seen is that, with high loading, the motor mounts can deflect and cause the contact point of the gear mesh to shift. Given the separation loads, the mesh will usually shift out toward the tip of the gear tooth and also toward the edge of the tooth closer to the motor (rather than being uniform across the entire tooth width) so if you are seeing a lot of wear on the motor end of the teeth, it is likely to be motor deflection. Make sure the motor bolts are tight and wiggle the motors to make sure there is a good amount of stiffness in the mounting. Keep in mind that the motors can also move due to inertia during robot acceleration or impacts and not just the separation forces at the gear contact point.

The 3 CIM ball shifters seem to have a decent amount of stiffness and strength so I would not expect this problem with that gearbox unless the motor bolts are loose. We used one of these gearboxes for the first time this past season for our lift and I was pretty impressed with the construction. But our application was not very abusive in terms of loading, so others may have a better input on the gearbox stiffness for more abusive applications.

The other "issue" that I would expect could cause excessive wear (although I have not experienced this directly) would be if you had one dead or poor performing motor. If one motor was dragging on the gear instead of driving, then you have the other motors working harder which would cause higher loads and more wear. Plus the bad motor would be being driven which could result in load and wear on the other side of the tooth.
__________________
Reply With Quote
  #15   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 11-03-2018, 06:28 PM
R.C.'s Avatar
R.C. R.C. is online now
2017... Oooh Kill em, Swerve!
AKA: Owner, WestCoast Products
FRC #1323 (MadTown Robotics)
Team Role: Engineer
 
Join Date: Feb 2008
Rookie Year: 2006
Location: Madera, CA
Posts: 2,289
R.C. has a reputation beyond reputeR.C. has a reputation beyond reputeR.C. has a reputation beyond reputeR.C. has a reputation beyond reputeR.C. has a reputation beyond reputeR.C. has a reputation beyond reputeR.C. has a reputation beyond reputeR.C. has a reputation beyond reputeR.C. has a reputation beyond reputeR.C. has a reputation beyond reputeR.C. has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Using steel gears in the 3 cim ball shifters from vexpro

Quote:
Originally Posted by Marcus Q View Post
I've only ever seen significant wear on the the ball shifter gears when used with steel pinions. If aluminium gears were the issue then why don't we see significant wear on the 2nd stage? Additionally since it's 3 steel pinions on one aluminium gear that's 3x the wear of a normal gear reduction with steel exasperating the effect even more. Aluminium pinions are really the preferable choice. With the drive train forces divided over 3 pinions breakage shouldn't be an issue.
We've been using aluminum gears for a long time (2011?). You'll experience worse results using the aluminum gears as the pinion and I would not use them. I forget what year but we made 11T and 12T gears out of 7068 Aluminum and had issues with them wearing out. I'd much rather change the large gear out than replace each cim gear.

The first stage experiences the most wear due to high speed + multiple pinions on the same stage. The second stage doesn't wear as badly due to slower speed and single gear contact.
__________________
R.C.
Owner, WestCoast Products || Twitter
MadTown Robotics Team 1323
Reply With Quote
Reply


Thread Tools
Display Modes Rate This Thread
Rate This Thread:

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Forum Jump


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 05:02 PM.

The Chief Delphi Forums are sponsored by Innovation First International, Inc.


Powered by vBulletin®
Copyright ©2000 - 2018, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © Chief Delphi