14-09-2009 13:20

Abrakadabra

Re: paper: FRC1189 2009 Shooter Gearbox Development

Mark -
This is a fantastic resource and one that I think will really wake up alot of folks to the true versatility and usefulness of the FP motor and gearbox. I especially liked your honest description of the all-too-common-in-FRC last minute design constraints that played into your decisions. Plus, the narrative form really makes the paper fun to read!

Thanks for sharing!

14-09-2009 14:26

kramarczyk

Re: paper: FRC1189 2009 Shooter Gearbox Development

Thanks.

I've hemmed and hawed about posting this for most of the summer. I wanted to get the FP info out there since I don't know of any consolidated source. Some of it is spread through a variety of CD posts, but can be hard to find. I really wasn't sure if I should include the team oriented narritive, so I'm glad the dirtiness of the iteration played well.

14-09-2009 14:56

Jared Russell

Re: paper: FRC1189 2009 Shooter Gearbox Development

This is a fantastic resource, thanks.

14-09-2009 22:11

Karibou

Re: paper: FRC1189 2009 Shooter Gearbox Development

I know I told you this when I saw this several months ago, but this is a FANTASTIC paper.

14-09-2009 22:24

AdamHeard

Re: paper: FRC1189 2009 Shooter Gearbox Development

Was the ability to aim left/right ever used? How effective was varying the speeds?

15-09-2009 07:03

kramarczyk

Re: paper: FRC1189 2009 Shooter Gearbox Development

Yes, it was used when pinning someone at the trailer hitch. The varying speeds did work with the camera, but the game ended up play faster that we thought and as a system (camera through to hardware) it wasn't fast enough to automatically track. Fortunately there are manual options for left,center, right at a contact distance (~3 ft). Did it work as well as I would have liked, no. Did it work, yes. As the balls broke, down the variation in game pieces caused problems.

http://www.thebluealliance.net/tbatv/match/2009gl_qm76
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DH8KL... F6C2B&index=0

15-09-2009 09:26

JVN

Re: paper: FRC1189 2009 Shooter Gearbox Development

Great paper!
A must read for anyone wanting to learn more about utilizing FP motors.

15-09-2009 10:58

jonboy

Re: paper: FRC1189 2009 Shooter Gearbox Development

Great paper and thank you for your effort to pass useful info along. I would bet there will be some FP motors and gear boxes in this year's KOP.

One comment: As I recall the FP motor air intake is on the front face and the exhaust is at the rear where you can see the fan blades. Would it add to reliability and longevity to add some openings in the gear box to allow air intake to keep the armature a little colder? Cooler armature would result in cooler winding lowering the resistance with resulting possible increase in output power.

Keep up the good work. ... jon

15-09-2009 13:03

Jared Russell

Re: paper: FRC1189 2009 Shooter Gearbox Development

Has anyone ever machined a heat sink to fit over the FP motors' body? I would think that if you can get a snug metal-metal (or metal-thermal paste-metal) fit, you could probably cool the motor quite effectively by increasing the volume/surface area of heat dissipation and decreasing the effective power density.

15-09-2009 13:25

Aren_Hill

Re: paper: FRC1189 2009 Shooter Gearbox Development

In 2008 we used part of a quadcore cpu heatsink that was round, and simply spread it wide enough to fit over the fp motor, worked quite well.

you can see it in the lower left of this pic

http://www.chiefdelphi.com/media/photos/31538

15-09-2009 13:36

Chris is me

Re: paper: FRC1189 2009 Shooter Gearbox Development

I've heard this heat sink worked wonders on 1024's 2008 robot.