|
|
|
 ...the hardest part of engineering is communication. - EricVanWyk [more] |
 |
|
|||||||
|
||||||||
By: 1708xMr.Roboto
New: 18-01-2011 11:52
Updated: 18-01-2011 11:52
Views: 1288 times
A 2011 Design Idea,
anyone have any pro's and con's?
Discussion
view entire thread
18-01-2011 13:39
Jamie Kalb
Re: pic: Idea #1
Con: You might want some wheels. 
Pro: Looks really sturdy (maybe unnecessarily so) and easy to mount bumpers on!
18-01-2011 14:02
Jeffy
Re: pic: Idea #1
Pros:
Looks cool
Sturdy (depending on wall thickness)
normal tank drive pros
Cons:
Looks like alot of machining on the lower supports. Why do the machining on the lower, more load bearing, frame members, but not the upper?
Lots of welding to do also
Without the ability to slide the gearboxes, you will need another way to tension the chain.
Servo shifters have not been getting a good rep from what i have read. (no personal experience)
18-01-2011 14:03
Tytus Gerrish
Re: pic: Idea #1
pro: looks stout
con: you have to get it from outer space
18-01-2011 14:34
Bob Steele
Re: pic: Idea #1
If you use two CIMS on that transmission you might have some interference with the power distribution board. Put them in your model and see.
The bottom one will be pretty close... and will definitely get in the way of working on the power distribution board...
looks pretty neat though... great job..!!
18-01-2011 15:07
Chris is me
Re: pic: Idea #1
If you have to lighten, lighten the top rather than the bottom. You want more weight down low and it would be better to compromise the strength of a cross bar rather than what you mount your wheels to.
18-01-2011 15:15
Bruneau1727
Re: pic: Idea #1
We used servo shifters once and they didn't hold up well. Once we changed them to pneumatic shifters they worked like a charm.
18-01-2011 15:37
Justin Montois
Re: pic: Idea #1
It looks great. The only drawback I can see is chances are something (either a manipulator/Arm or a minibot delivery system is going to go above your electronics. Try to keep it as accessible as possible just in case you need to get in there for whatever reason.
18-01-2011 15:56
1708xMr.Roboto
Re: pic: Idea #1
Thank's everyone, my team didn't end up going with this design; I just wanted to post it to check out what the community thought of it. I appreciate the help!
-Eddie
18-01-2011 21:25
HarveyAce
Re: pic: Idea #1
you might want to add some cooling fans to ur electronics box, otherwise the temp could damage your stuff over a period of time... other than that, looks sturdy! great job.
view entire thread
Tags
loading ...